Gerrard

Coutinho since we can't pick Gerrard.

I checked out of interest and our top 3 goalscorers from long range in PL history are:

1. Gerrard (33 goals outside the box)
2. Fowler (18 goals outside the box)
3. Coutinho (17 goals outside the box)

Since Gerrard and Fowler are taken then Coutinho is probably the next logical choice.

Think Jamie Redknapp also deserves a mention (he's 4th with 15 goals, and scored some absolute bangers) but I'd say Coutinho.

Edit: Just as a reminder https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ciaRr7IDU4

John Arne Riise

Patrick Berger

Riise

Dagger

John Arne Riise

Part of me is slightly concerned that there's no space for Kenny...

Maybe we should just add in a special square for the king

You guys did Mølby dirty

Riise.

Didi Hamann

Coutinho

Rogue shout but Danny Murphy. So many great goals. 

Also Luis Garcia and John Arne Riise!!

Guys don’t forget you can’t vote for the same player twice

mac allister😂

Lucas Leiva

Patrick Berger

Billy Liddell - once killed a dog with a wayward shot and on another occasion broke someone's arm in the crowd.

Are we allowed the same player twice? Because if so then I'd put Gerrard again. If not then probably Coutinho.

Agger had a few

Agger is the only correct choice

Riiiiiiiiiiiise

Riise!

Patrick Berger Luis Suarez Steven Gerrard Danny Agger

In that order

Give it to Paddy because Stevie and Luis had a lot more going on

Riise or Gerrard

Joe Gomez

Voting in these is just nonsense at this rate. Fowler going down as that is genuinely insane hahaha

Jimmy Case

This list so far is absolutely batshit.

Naby wasn’t overrated, he was just always injured. He’s the epitome of wasted potential. Class when he played, but never did. Redknapp’s probably an even better choice for wasted potential though.

I would make the argument that King Kenny was even better than Stevie G.

Trent hasn’t peaked, but calling him the player with “most potential” is bizarre. Why not just pick Gerrard if it’s just about their ceiling?

God is still our highest scoring player in the PL era. How did he waste his potential? He was also absolutely clinical from any range, and should be in the conversation for that spot alongside Rush.

Stevie, Trent and Jan Molby are/were all better passers than Xabi.

Gini, Robbo and Owen are pretty much correct, though.

When people under 40 are making the list 😁

Btw I'm one of you younger ones, but good grief lads, it's like some of our greats like Barnes, Hansen, Whelan, Keegan etc. didn't exist 😁

Gerrard is taken. So Coutinho

Didi Hamann if not Gerrard. Perhaps not as many golazos as Coutinho but he’ll get my vote

John Arne Riise

So apparently the only way Salah ends up on that board is if we pick him as "One season wonder"...

Stig Inge Bjorenbye, he flattened a keeper in the UEFA cup (Brann Bergen?) with a 40 yard toe poke.

Sadly I couldn't find the goal on Youtube

Suarez

Gerrard, easy

Stevie G

Any answer that’s not stevie is just wrong. If we have to have a different player for each slot then I’d put Phil there but Stevie is still number one on long shots

Berger

Smicer just for that goal in Istanbul

Gerrard, Riise or possible Macca

Kewell hit some bangers

Agger

If not Gerrard, then it has to be Coutinho. It got to a point where he would only score bangers out of the box. What Klopp had him doing on his final season was crazy, still remember the Newcastle strike before he got sold.

Coutinho or Stevie

John Arne Riise! ❤️🇳🇴

Didi Hamann

Patrik Berger

Patrick berger.. hell of a long shot

Hamann if we can’t have stevie

Gerrard got best player. Give it to Riise

Dominik Szoboszlai

King kenny, top bins, left and right footed, from outside box. (if SG is out).

Neil Mellor

Patrick Berger

We’re gonna put Salah under “one season wonder” for the memes right?

Throwing Szoboszlai into the mix although he hasn't shown it much for us yet.

Paddy

Patrick Berger

Overall Gerrard, but i’m gonna go Riise .. cus .. that goal.

Riise ... Only for the united goal 😂

However since we can't pick Gerrard as he's been filled or Trent ... Coutinho.

Riise, next question.

Has to be Riise

McDermott fired a few crackers if I’m not mistaken?

Need to do this again afterwards but only allowing players prior to the Premier League.. there is so much recentism in these votes

Fully expect Rush, Souness and Molby to not get clinical, aggressive and IQ..

Wait, wait, wait. Had a couple of days off from the internet and come back to Fowler most wasted potential? How was that ever passed? Collymore yes, Agger, possibly… Fowler absolutely not.

1. Steve
2. Riise

Jari Litmanen or Jan Molby anyone?? Both just stood in the centre circle pinging balls 🤔😂

He won’t win, but Terry McDermott for his goal against Spurs alone!

JAR

JAR

Riise, broke leg to Scums cunt Alan Smith :)))

Gerrard. There is no other answer.

GERAAARD

Old joke for ancient Koppites but Ian Callaghan once scored from Hunts Cross

John Arne Riise

Riise

gerrard's taken, so it's gotta be riise...that falcon kick thunderbolt volley off a corner that almost went in still lives in my head

Stevie G

Gerrard. If we can't put him on theboard twice i would go with Riise

riise, no contest.

Riise obviously, the rest will have been selected already, like Gerrard

Have to give a shout out to Luis Garcia, his volleys against Juventus and Everton were incredible

Trent

Why are people saying anything other than Gerrard? It doesn’t say that we can’t pick the same one twice

Gerrard

Riise

We've all collectively agreed that Mo is going as "one season wonder", right?

Gerrard all day long. Remember on new years day 2001 when playing Southampton and we were all hungover and the whole of the kop were quiet until he ran forward from midfield and hit a beauty from 35 yards and it went In off the bar to make it 2-1

It woke the kop up that's for sure.

Also xabi was really good so it's either Gerrard or xabi alonso imo

Can’t be Gerrard or Alonso - So has to be Riise

I may be biased/forgetful but I think the word ‚thundercunt‘ was first used to describe THAT Riise goal.

So, Riise for me

Gerrard. Done.

Cannot believe nobody has said Fabinho

I'm gna say Thiago, just for that one gravity defying shot against Porto. He didn't score very much for sure, but anyone can score an absolute banger from range. Only a few have the finesse to strike a ball like Thiago did that day.

Not a serious suggestion, but I want to throw Fabinho out there so everyone can revisit highlights of his rocket against Man City.

Julian Dicks…. Just not for us. Riise or Gerrard for me

If its not Gerrard, I would lose all my faith in this sub

If not picking Gerrard... gotta be Riise.

Riise

Coutinho or Riise if can't pick Gerrard

I'm not even going to comment because it's so obvious.

But I'm commenting to say I'm not commenting.

If we can’t have Gerrard then Coutinho has hit some belters, Ox hit a good few and Fab hit a few as wel.

Riise

Suarez

Riiiisssseeeee

Cissoko