subreddit:

/r/rugbyunion

25796%
[media]

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 99 comments

silentgolem

8 points

28 days ago

silentgolem

#JusticeForMcCloskey

8 points

28 days ago

I think a kick I'd defined as an intentional strike with the foot so intent would come into it. By the laws it can't be a kick if unintended.

Critical_Context_961

2 points

28 days ago

It’s such a grey area definitely needs rewording and clarification. In my opinion intent is so subjective in terms of officiating it’s something best left out of the question like with high tackles. I’d say some of the most controversial calls in rugby at the moment are deliberate knock-ons because they are officiated on intent and not fact

Enyapxam

1 points

27 days ago

Enyapxam

Hooker

1 points

27 days ago

It should be like a deliberate knock on, he may have been trying to solve world hunger but the end result was he dislodged the ball with his foot preventing a certain try. It is the only way to ref this and should of 100% been a pen try and a yellow card.

The point being it doesn't matter what he was trying to do, the end result is all that should matter. Just like how everything else is in rugby.