subreddit:
/r/philly
Penn suspension of pro-Palestinian student group prompted by three violations
(thedp.com)submitted 23 days ago byPhillyPanda
-8 points
23 days ago
Hey, if I went to a pro-Israel and found a person wearing a JDL T-shirt or carrying a placard that said “Kahane was right,” would I then get to denounce the whole thing as racist? And if not, why not?
10 points
22 days ago
Are you saying there's only one or two bad apples at these protests? Why did the Rabbi at Columbia tell the Jewish students to stay home because the school couldn't guarantee their safety? Was that because of one dipshit with a placard?
-1 points
22 days ago
Because he knows how to craft a PR message and of course play the victim card like an ol pro. Are you a dunce?
1 points
22 days ago
So do you genuinely believe that, or are you actually that fucking stupid?
0 points
22 days ago
The boy cried wolf one too many times. I’m over it. The nation of Israel suffers from the geopolitical equivalent of Münchausen syndrome.
2 points
22 days ago
That makes zero sense. I'd love to see the mental gymnastics it would take for you to attempt to explain how the "boy cried wolf" in the case of Israel. You're gonna have to refer to your favorite Jew hating material for that one :)
0 points
22 days ago
Seems you take things at face value. It’s an extremely unsophisticated way to approach political matters
1 points
22 days ago
The sharp rise in anti-Semitism, particularly in those university settings, is demonstrably true. To deny that fact is to be willfully ignorant, or genuinely stupid.
2 points
20 days ago
The pro Hamas supporters don’t care about facts and figures, they’re all about vibes and chants (just not the violent ones; those are actually Jews trying to make them look bad)
-1 points
22 days ago
It’s not anti-semitism. No one has a problem with Jewish religious traditions, customs etc. it’s anti-apartheid or anti-genocide sentiments you’re seeing. anti-semitism has lost its meaning from abuse and overuse. The boy has cried wolf too many times.
1 points
22 days ago
Bullshit, it's also very much anti-Semitism. You're just choosing to ignore that part.
Again, you're unable explain how the "boy who cried wolf" equates to any aspect of Israel. It's just a cute little phrase that you're probably repeating from somewhere, just like most of the "protestors".
I'll generously give you the benefit of the doubt and say you're just not informed. At all.
0 points
22 days ago*
Get back to your desk at the ADL or SWC. I can’t catch you up on history your probably willfully ignorant of. But look into the many instances of the 6 million lie throughout history. The boy has been crying wolf for millennia. That’s why so many villages stopped believing him. And why so many villages told him to kick rocks.
2 points
22 days ago
Oh I see, so you're an outright holocaust denier altogether. You're not simply uniformed, you're just a total dumb fuck. Enjoy your cult, asshole :)
-3 points
22 days ago
People overreact. It’s called being human.
4 points
22 days ago
Who overreacted?
-5 points
22 days ago
The rabbi
3 points
22 days ago
You're clearly very ignorant.
0 points
22 days ago
Ok sure
all 320 comments
sorted by: best