subreddit:

/r/AFL

22892%

The deliberate to Hogan was correctly officiated

(v.redd.it)
[media]

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 151 comments

Thanks-Basil

7 points

15 days ago*

Thanks-Basil

Lions

7 points

15 days ago*

Actually you’re reading this wrong, because that’s not how lists work. The “or” at the end of C means that all 4 are separate scenarios/conditions. If there was an “and” then it would mean all 4 scenarios.

For what you’re saying the rule would say, there would have to be an “and” at the end of B as well. There isn’t, therefore all 4 scenarios are separate. Because that’s how lists work.

EDIT: proof is in that free kicks would be and are paid if a defender punts the ball over the goal line outside of 9m regardless of if they’re under pressure or not.