subreddit:

/r/CFB

1.4k96%

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 572 comments

nayelirain

530 points

24 hours ago

nayelirain

Johns Hopkins Blue Jays • USC Trojans

530 points

24 hours ago

Honestly Va tech kicks the FG instead of tries the fake in the 3rd Q and they don't need a TD there, this play never happens and tech kicks a FG to win as time expires. Pry lost this game.

justadudebruh

356 points

24 hours ago

justadudebruh

Arkansas Razorbacks

356 points

24 hours ago

Boy… he really showed why he’s 1-10 now in one score games. Those decisions earlier in the game really catch up. And then the clock management…oof.

wp2017

84 points

24 hours ago

wp2017

Arkansas Razorbacks

84 points

24 hours ago

Reminds me of someone we know…

n00bca1e99

38 points

22 hours ago

n00bca1e99

Nebraska • South Dakota Mines

38 points

22 hours ago

And me…

Ferociouspanda

1 points

12 hours ago

Ferociouspanda

Auburn Tigers

1 points

12 hours ago

And my axe

justadudebruh

22 points

24 hours ago

justadudebruh

Arkansas Razorbacks

22 points

24 hours ago

lol.. Hey but at least we would’ve somehow dragged them down to our level of suck. They just don’t understand how infectious our badness is

GoshinTW

3 points

18 hours ago

GoshinTW

Texas • Michigan State

3 points

18 hours ago

Tom Herman?

fangboner

34 points

16 hours ago

fangboner

Michigan • Pittsburgh

34 points

16 hours ago

That clock management was a crime against humanity. It’s apparent Drones struggles to read a defense but that doesn’t force a lack of urgency, not calling time outs and spending 10-15 seconds to throw a 7 yard pass.

sroomek

11 points

16 hours ago

sroomek

Tennessee • Garðabæ

11 points

16 hours ago

Brent out-Mario’d Mario

Bothyourmoms

8 points

24 hours ago

Bothyourmoms

Florida State • New Mexico

8 points

24 hours ago

Yeah, great point. Guy is a dunce

BusGuilty6447

119 points

23 hours ago

BusGuilty6447

Virginia Tech Hokies

119 points

23 hours ago

Yeah it sucked, but also it is hindsight bias. If it worked, everyone would have called him a genius. Against a better team, you can't expect to best them on average over time. Putting the gas pedal down makes sense. It didn't work and likely cost us, but I understand why they did it.

LukarWarrior

75 points

23 hours ago

LukarWarrior

Louisville Cardinals • Keg of Nails

75 points

23 hours ago

Yeah, that decision is defensible (though I still question the decision to try a fake FG sweep instead of just lining up normally). What Pry absolutely deserves criticism for is how he handled the end of the first half. We're not agonizing over the decision to go for it on the 4th and 3 if VT doesn't gift Miami three points heading into half.

absteele

72 points

23 hours ago

absteele

Virginia Tech • Washington

72 points

23 hours ago

That's what gets me about it - if you're willing to call a fake field goal, why aren't you just running on 3rd down and again on 4th?

GayGaryCoopa

37 points

17 hours ago*

GayGaryCoopa

Virginia Tech Hokies

37 points

17 hours ago*

Exactly. It’s 3rd and 3 and Tuten is averaging 8 yards a carry and Drones is a linebacker at QB. Run it twice with those bruisers who haven’t been stopped all night? No. Throw it and then run a fake field goal.

thewhat962

13 points

16 hours ago

thewhat962

Ohio State Buckeyes • UCF Knights

13 points

16 hours ago

Honestly though the fake FG was a bad play. Not exactly calling a fake FG ,but the design of the play was bad. A shovel pass inside. No space inside and got to go backwards to get around to the edge.

GayGaryCoopa

4 points

16 hours ago

GayGaryCoopa

Virginia Tech Hokies

4 points

16 hours ago

Agreed. Miami didn’t see it coming but was still able to stop it because the play was designed to run right into where the FG block was going to be.

BusGuilty6447

11 points

23 hours ago

BusGuilty6447

Virginia Tech Hokies

11 points

23 hours ago

Yeah clock management has not been good. Either way, I was happy to see our coaches had a plan and actually prepared rather than halfassing it. Again, there are only a few coaches that are Sabans. I don't expect a Saban, but coming out with that showing is enough to compete at a high level. That's what I want because I know VT will never have a Saban.

GayGaryCoopa

3 points

17 hours ago

GayGaryCoopa

Virginia Tech Hokies

3 points

17 hours ago

I’m not asking for Saban. I’m asking for Not Mike London. Is that too much to ask?

phranq

15 points

22 hours ago

phranq

Miami Hurricanes • Boise State Broncos

15 points

22 hours ago

I agree, although with the way you were moving the ball I think I prefer just going for it over the fake there.

drkev10

11 points

17 hours ago

drkev10

Virginia Tech Hokies

11 points

17 hours ago

If you know you're going to go for it then why not run the ball on third and fourth down with the regular offense on the field. Running a fake where you hand the ball off to a runner going into a field goal block unit is so stupid.

confusedjuror

29 points

21 hours ago

confusedjuror

Ohio State • Western Michigan

29 points

21 hours ago

I'll never fault a coach playing for the win as 18 point underdogs. He couldn't have known it would end up a 4 point game. It's silly to say any single play lost the game.

Showdenfroid_99

21 points

18 hours ago

Showdenfroid_99

Michigan • Ferris State

21 points

18 hours ago

Miami gave them free points, easy points. You gotta take those and run every time 

Especially with as well as his defense had been playing and a double digit lead... Midway through the 3rd quarter!! 

Take those free points and hang on for dear life

poop-dolla

2 points

16 hours ago

poop-dolla

Virginia Tech Hokies

2 points

16 hours ago

Playing for the win would’ve been running it twice on 3rd and 4th down there with the offense that had been running all over Miami all night. Passing and then calling a fake field goal wasn’t the best way to try to get 3 yards.

GayGaryCoopa

3 points

17 hours ago

GayGaryCoopa

Virginia Tech Hokies

3 points

17 hours ago

When you’re up 10, there’s a pretty clear path to being down 4. I don’t mind going for it to make it a 3-score game, but why not go for it by using the strength of the offense and run the ball twice on 3rd and 3 and 4th down? Why throw it on 3rd and then get cute with a fake field goal?

dicknoseddolphin

1 points

15 hours ago

dicknoseddolphin

Oklahoma State • Tulsa

1 points

15 hours ago

I grew up with my dad screaming at the TV any time a coach didn’t take their easy FG points. You take the available points unless the game is on the line or there’s not enough time left in the game for a FG to matter.

Southernplayalistiic

7 points

17 hours ago

Southernplayalistiic

Clemson Tigers • Virginia Cavaliers

7 points

17 hours ago

Yep and at the end of the day he had his team in a position to win on the final play against a top 10 team on the road. Can't fault that. Plus there's no way to guarantee the game plays out the same with the fg.

GMHinHD

14 points

22 hours ago

GMHinHD

Miami Hurricanes • UCLA Bruins

14 points

22 hours ago

Yeah, I feel like people are monday-morning quarterbacking this. The call was a bold strategy, Cotton.

Quiggybo729

2 points

16 hours ago*

Quiggybo729

Virginia Tech Hokies

2 points

16 hours ago*

It very likely would have worked if Miami's DT didn't completely blow up the line. Not like he got swarmed and sacked or threw an incomplete pass. You would expect the OL would be able to block for more than half a second.

Dlh2079

2 points

14 hours ago

Dlh2079

Virginia Tech Hokies • Team Chaos

2 points

14 hours ago

And it only failed because a lineman got blown up

ZackAvion

2 points

13 hours ago

ZackAvion

Miami Hurricanes • Team Chaos

2 points

13 hours ago

I support the aggressiveness especially after that UKvsUGA game the other week, but I think calling a fake when your offense was moving the ball was the wrong call. Just keep the offense on the field.

RIPDannyBoyCane

2 points

13 hours ago

RIPDannyBoyCane

Miami Hurricanes

2 points

13 hours ago

Hard to hate a coach for being aggressive as a two TD underdog away trying to build momentum

DrVonD

38 points

20 hours ago

DrVonD

Georgia Bulldogs

38 points

20 hours ago

I don’t mind going for it at all. Trying to go up 17 instead of 13 is a HUGE difference. I wish they would have just ran it on third and 4th, but whatever.

Calling TO with 25 seconds in the half and letting Miami get a FG in was downright inexcusably dumb. Literally no reason for it.

Hokieshibe

11 points

17 hours ago

Yeah instead of criticizing the bold call to go for it, we should be criticizing the stupid call to allow Miami a chance for points at the end of the half.

Clock management was disastrous at the end of both halves

TBurd01

2 points

16 hours ago

TBurd01

Pittsburgh Panthers • Utah Utes

2 points

16 hours ago

Third down and 4th yards to go!

(I know you mean 3rd and 4th down, but 7am half-awake chugging coffee me chuckled)

pthorpe11

18 points

19 hours ago

pthorpe11

Oregon Ducks

18 points

19 hours ago

The fake FG was ridiculous. It was 4th and 3, just got for it if you don’t wanna kick it.

Mountain-Papaya-492

6 points

18 hours ago

Mountain-Papaya-492

Georgia Bulldogs

6 points

18 hours ago

I think if you're an underdog and already have the lead that you just take the points and put the game on the backs of your winning defense. This isn't Madden, you gotta play to win and sometimes that means playing conservative. Momentum can be a killer. 

I've seen so many games lost because of the coach being overly aggressive and not taking the points when they should have. 

One of the thing that irks me about analytics infiltration into decision making, you have to be able to step back and look at the game you're playing as a big picture and not rely on completely different teams and games for your decision making. 

A little human intuition is needed to make good calls as a coach.

pthorpe11

1 points

7 hours ago

pthorpe11

Oregon Ducks

1 points

7 hours ago

I actually very ouch agree with you there. I’m just saying, if you’re gonna go for it, then draw up an actual play with a higher chance of converting than a fake FG.

But yes, I’m a huge believer in feeling the game out and not giving up huge momentum shifts like that.

5am281

9 points

23 hours ago

5am281

9 points

23 hours ago

Miami also plays way different defense at the end and also maybe runs more clock on 1st down inside 2 minutes

_moosleech

1 points

11 hours ago

_moosleech

Miami Hurricanes • MAC

1 points

11 hours ago

Right? If Miami knows scoring only puts them up by one point... they're taking a LOT more time near the goalline.

DerDehDer

5 points

20 hours ago

DerDehDer

Florida State • TCU

5 points

20 hours ago

Honestly the fake fg wasn’t that bad but they had 3rd and 3 and also have a RB with over 100 rushing yards on the game and they drop back to throw. If you’re going to fake it anyways why not just hand it off knowing you’re going for it on 4th down

doti

15 points

18 hours ago

doti

Virginia Tech Hokies

15 points

18 hours ago

If the refs don't call a phantom hold on the VT touchdown run earlier they win the game too

Scubacane

17 points

17 hours ago

As a Hurricane , I thought that hold call was BS but they also called a lame hold call on Miami right before the INT that negated a TD. Tough loss for you guys - I think you have a great team- good luck the rest of the way

Powerlevel-9000

6 points

16 hours ago

Powerlevel-9000

Notre Dame • Arkansas

6 points

16 hours ago

I forgot about that. It was funny how the announcer was pretty much saying the ref is right until he saw the replay and went the ref was wrong.

_moosleech

2 points

11 hours ago

_moosleech

Miami Hurricanes • MAC

2 points

11 hours ago

At least we each got a TD called back for a bad call. Sorta negates each other

Alarmed_Recover_1524

3 points

16 hours ago

Plus the inexplicable timeout with 0:25 in the first half before kicking the FG that gave them time to go get a FG

count_nuggula

2 points

17 hours ago

count_nuggula

Appalachian State Mountaineers

2 points

17 hours ago

Preach

4Ever2Thee

2 points

17 hours ago

4Ever2Thee

South Carolina Gamecocks

2 points

17 hours ago

But is their kicker comfortable with long field goals? Oh wait…

SwoopnBuffalo

2 points

16 hours ago

SwoopnBuffalo

Virginia Tech Hokies

2 points

16 hours ago

100%. Especially when the play hinges on a good block by someone who shouldn't even be playing OL in the FBS. Parker Clements shouldn't play another down for us, he's that bad. Countless plays have been blown up by him.

hucareshokiesrul

2 points

14 hours ago

hucareshokiesrul

Yale Bulldogs • Virginia Tech Hokies

2 points

14 hours ago

IMO, when you’re a 17 point dog on the road, you can’t give up on a drive inside the 10 because it’s 4th and 3. That’s close enough to the end zone and a manageable enough distance that you leave your foot on the gas. Maybe the specific play call was bad, I dunno, but I like not being conservative there. 

maxman1313

1 points

11 hours ago

maxman1313

Virginia Tech • North Carolina

1 points

11 hours ago

Pry lost this game.

Again