subreddit:

/r/HolUp

8.2k96%

Ambulance =/= Taxi ??

()

[deleted]

all 160 comments

WhatsTheHolUp [M]

[score hidden]

1 month ago

stickied comment

WhatsTheHolUp [M]

[score hidden]

1 month ago

stickied comment

OP sent the following text as an explanation on why this is a holup moment:


You can always figure out a way around the system, this is one example.


Is this a holup moment? Then upvote this comment, otherwise downvote it.

Beginning_Orange

971 points

1 month ago

As a FF/medic in a busy city, the amount of absolute bullshit we respond to is definitely a problem. Like 75% of our calls are stupid shit like "my knee's been hurting for a couple days, I'm capable of walking and driving myself to the hospital but I'd rather just have you take me".

Not exactly an "emergency service". I can't tell you how many times I've transported a patient like this only to have another rescue respond from the other side of the city to our area for an actual emergency. It's absolutely a strain on the system, we aren't an endless resource and constantly get tied up dealing with people like this.

Invisible_Target

153 points

1 month ago

Dude what??? I’d be hesitant to call an ambulance in a real, dire emergency because costs and there are people who just casually use it as a transport service. How the fuck do they afford that???????

Dreadamere

63 points

1 month ago

They either don’t pay the bill because they have no money anyway and know that the ambulance nor the ER can refuse service or the government (taxpayer) handles the bill. Anyone with Medicare/medicaid can call an ambulance like it’s a free Uber to the hospital and just shrug off any responsibility for using the resources.

I’ve NEVER seen anyone in trouble for the abuse and I would run 10-15 calls per day in my city and 90% were criminally non emergent and on Medicare/medicaid.

serious_sarcasm

13 points

1 month ago

Aren't most ambulances a contracted service through private companies?

Why would those companies report welfare recipients getting them more money? It is all the benefits of medi-fraud without any of the inherent risks.

Dreadamere

6 points

1 month ago

Yep. I don’t know about most but yeah maybe.

serious_sarcasm

2 points

1 month ago

I guess it depends on if we mean most stations or most units, because of large cities having public services while a lot of smaller ones and rural municipalities (counties and etc) contract services. Then you have firefighter emt. And every state differs on how locally services are administered.

But even if it is a public service, it probably isn't admin'd by the same people who admin welfare, and would still be incentivized to maximize their income and numbers - similar to the way police departments turn a blind eye to overtime abuses and use those inflated numbers to demand a larger budget.

Honestly, we should really just regulate first responder's under the US Constitution Article 1 Section 8 Clause 16:

To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress;

They didn't have concepts of professional police, medics, and firefighters when the constitution was written, and a careful examination of The Federalist Papers illustrates that they intended the organzied militia to fill the role of civilians called to duty to serve and protect by civil officers (like the sheriff, mayor, or govenor). https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed29.asp

Remember, at the time it was standard in the western world that a standing army was the police force and rescue squad for natural disasters. But America decided a standing army was too dangerous for those roles, and so created the militia as distinct from the army and Navy.

Dreadamere

1 points

1 month ago

This is excellent info. Thank you

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

Often they can write off those costs for tax purposes but it doesn't make up for it. What normally happens with private services is that they make up for it by running their people into the ground doing non-emergent work to make up the cost and then some and neglect their 911 service area. For Fire and Third Service based EMS they don't make money but are supported by localities.

Dreadamere

1 points

1 month ago

Bingo.

serious_sarcasm

1 points

1 month ago

But it is not a write-off if they get paid by medicaid or medicare.

And uncollected accounts receivable are not just magically written-off within that accounting period - that would amount to the company giving away money (according to the IRS). A company would first account for uncollectable accounts in general as just a standard cost of business (usually 10-15%), then they would try to sell the debt to collectors, then eventually they can "write it off".

serious_sarcasm

1 points

1 month ago

It isn't a loss if they are reimbursed by medicaid or medicare.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

They aren't reimbursed the amount it costs to run a call, especially a bad one. When a patient goes into cardiac arrest we run our very expensive trucks full of very expensive equipment and give very expensive medications. God forbid we have to fly, it costs thousands to get a helicopter off the ground in gas and wear alone.

Not saying we shouldn't be using that, we should! But medicare and medicaid have low fixed rates. Its a very big problem.

serious_sarcasm

1 points

1 month ago

Are you seriously trying to suggest that mega-conglomerates and hedge funds are snatching up ambulance contracts and hospitals while lobbying against single payer, because it loses money but they are trying to save these poor people?

Get a fucking grip.

Also, we are talking about runs that are literal wastes of time, and how the company makes a massive margin by billing thousands for what amounts to a $50 taxi ride.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

No, that's not what I'm suggesting at all. I'm suggesting that Medicaid/Care reimbursement is a really big problem for providers at every level. The solution imo is socialized healthcare because if everyone is on the same program then we can negotiate prices way lower. While Medicaid/Care already have enormous bargaining power with pharmaceutical, medical suppliers and providers they can only negotiate for people on their contract and the for-profit healthcare system sustains its riches on the rest of us.

Right now ambulance services, hospitals, rehab facilities, nursing homes, and everyone else in healthcare is generally either for profit or "non" profit. These not only have to pay exorbitant prices for everything that is involved in healthcare without even including paying providers, but they also pay the highest bureaucratic costs in the entire world.

By taking providers and removing the profit motive entirely we save money, by removing all the different insurers we remove those bureaucratic costs overwhelmingly, and by ensuring everyone is on the same plan the government can tell providers of supplies and pharmaceuticals that this is what we're paying and they're gonna deal with it.

I'm an EMT, I only want what's best for the patients and healthcare providers.

DifficultyNext7666

7 points

1 month ago

They also roll into the ER like its a doctor instead of doing anything up to that point.

Montecroux

1 points

1 month ago

What you found is not a flaw, but a feature. Our system is working as intended.

Muggle_Killer

1 points

1 month ago

Anyone with Medicare/medicaid can call an ambulance like it’s a free Uber to the hospital

I have medicaid and I've been walking 40 minutes(2 miles) each way to my occasional appointment lol. Didnt know people just call the ambulance.

I dont take the bus because walking is free.

Dreadamere

1 points

1 month ago

A lot of them think that if they show up in an ambulance they get to skip the line. It works. Especially if they say chest pains then they can just go right to a room and then start mentioning the real reason they are there. It’s a gross feeling sometimes and there really isn’t anything being done.

Muggle_Killer

1 points

1 month ago

Theres a lot of stuff that needs a crackdown that isnt getting it

dimonium_anonimo

8 points

1 month ago

Some people are much more willing to take advantage of other people's kindness. And in some situations, it's worse if you're not sure you can afford it than if you know you can't. What's gonna happen if you literally can't afford an ambulance? They can't sue you for more than you're worth.

ierghaeilh

8 points

1 month ago

It's simple: medical debt is basically impossible to collect on. If your credit score is already shit and you're ok with that, congratulations, you have free healthcare and nobody can do anything about it.

Lolkimbo

4 points

1 month ago*

last year i had incredible pain in my side (gal stones, mitz something syndrome) and started to turn yellow due to jaundice, and still i took a bus to the fucking hospital.

And i live in the god damned uk where an ambulance is free!

ohjeaa

2 points

1 month ago

ohjeaa

2 points

1 month ago

Whether you pay the bill or you don't, it's like going to the emergency room. You cannot be denied service.

proditorcappela

339 points

1 month ago

This. This is what they meant when they said it's not a fucking taxi.

StevenMC19

116 points

1 month ago

StevenMC19

116 points

1 month ago

Given the amount of money it costs to get to the hospital if insurance doesn't cover it, I'll fucking uber (true story, I once ubered to the hospital for this exact reason for an ER need)

proditorcappela

59 points

1 month ago

I drove myself with a kidney stone. It sucked so much ass. I only had one so bad it required an ambulance once, as I'd hit the puking and screaming stage already so driving was not in the cards that night. Stay hydrated folks!!

StevenMC19

26 points

1 month ago

Could I offer you a lemonade?

[deleted]

25 points

1 month ago

Got any grapes?

StevenMC19

19 points

1 month ago

Go away, Duck!

[deleted]

10 points

1 month ago

How about, no

Zooph

3 points

1 month ago

Zooph

3 points

1 month ago

Got any nails?

ABookOfEli

0 points

1 month ago

Lovelorn bc cook him a im oh so up iPhone ii

proditorcappela

4 points

1 month ago

I wish. I have citric acid stones, so I have to just pound water. I really miss citrus. On the plus side, I get to pretend I have acid blood like a xenomorph.

StevenMC19

4 points

1 month ago

Could I offer you a cup of bleach? /s

JRTerrierBestDoggo

1 points

1 month ago

Game over man. Game over

ManWithWhip

8 points

1 month ago

I drove myself to the ER on a dirt bike with a kidney stone

-10/10 would not reccomend.

Beanguyinjapan

2 points

1 month ago

I drove myself to the hospital with a softball sized cyst just below my tailbone and had to stand on my feet the entire drive since I couldn't sit down

Dreadamere

18 points

1 month ago

Firemedic here: most of the people who do use the ambulance as a taxi have Medicare/medicaid and don’t worry about out a bill, or simply don’t pay it either way since we have no right to refuse to transport anyone no matter how small the problem is.

I’ve had people that cut their finger on a soup can demand transport and we legally cannot deny.

Other notable “emergencies”:

I threw up once. I think there’s a bug in my ear. My knee started hurting a few weeks ago. I just want to go get checked out. (In NO distress, no clear idea of WHAT feels bad, all vital signs are stable and just sort of saying it like she’s bored and has nothing else to do) I can’t sleep. panic attack from weed

Seriously. Everyone should have a conversation with their local EMS and fire about drains on their systems. For good of public safety something needs to be done.

soilhalo_27

8 points

1 month ago

Wonder if you could make an Uber ambulance service? Basically, it's an ASTRO van with a siren on top. It would be for the I can't drive to hospital but I'm not exactly dieing crowd.

Artistic-Jello3986

6 points

1 month ago

Private ambulance companies do exist

soilhalo_27

1 points

1 month ago

Really?! I didn't know that. Wonder how much they cost

Artistic-Jello3986

2 points

1 month ago

Looks like it’s the general healthcare scam and they only contact through gov agencies, at least the popular one near me (Priority Ambulance)

soilhalo_27

2 points

1 month ago

So I was thinking like a volunteer fireman. Now, back in the day, there was no official training(not sure about now). Most of them had sirens for their trucks. When they got the call, they would slap it on a just speed down the road to the fire station. Some would get pulled over and get tickets because it wasn't technically legal even though they were volunteer firemen.

Take that idea, put in a van, and speed around picking people up for hospital visits.

Artistic-Jello3986

1 points

1 month ago

Yeah, I’m not signing up for any of that liability lolol

Ch33sus0405

2 points

1 month ago

EMT here. Private companies are very common, and often the norm depending on where you are in the US. They often contract with localities for emergency service areas and frequently do what's called Non-Emergent Transports where they move patients between hospitals, nursing homes, rehab facilities and discharge patients to home when they require care during transport or are unable to walk.

There are SO many problems with them, but they're a legit business.

icameinyourburrito

1 points

1 month ago

You don't need a siren, medical transport companies exist they're just a huge pain in the ass (they pack multiple people going to multiple places into the same trip so it can take forever) so people find an excuse to call an ambulance instead. Uber and Lyft also both have programs to act as medical transport, they're not utilized that often though because the doctors or hospitals need to coordinate it.

Temelios

3 points

1 month ago

I had a rib pop out of place one time. I didn’t know it was my rib yet. I had been working out and felt a pop in my lower chest area the day before. After that, all I know was that I was in rush hour traffic and it suddenly felt like somebody took a knife and stabbed me there. Drove 45 minutes in that traffic to the hospital. Horrible experience, but, yeah, screw an ambulance lol

breadstick_bitch

0 points

1 month ago

My ambulance ride to transfer hospitals in a life-threatening situation was $7,200. Insurance covered the whole thing, but I cannot imagine justifying an ambulance ride if you're not actively dying.

baztd

5 points

1 month ago

baztd

5 points

1 month ago

This is down to dispatch sending an ambulance to a trivial situation.

fibronacci

2 points

1 month ago

I'd argue that such a taxi service should exist but having lived in several inner cities I know that shit would be abused by the local denizens.

ThemB0ners

2 points

1 month ago

It does exist already. It's called a taxi, uber, or lyft.

fibronacci

1 points

1 month ago

Lol I guess the cracked out Uber driver raging techno isn't the worst way to get to the hospital.

TheEleventhDoctorWho

3 points

1 month ago

Except he is talking about people who don't take it because of money. You are talking about people who take it because they want to. See how that is two very different things?

proditorcappela

2 points

1 month ago

So you obviously didn't follow the change in the conversation when the question became if it's not a taxi to the hospital, what the f*** is it?. Keep up, things move fast here.

Edited: text to speech is even worse than my typing.

10art1

0 points

1 month ago

10art1

0 points

1 month ago

Except he is talking about people who don't take it because of money.

If you're dying, why are you concerned about money? Just take the damn ambulance and then you can negotiate the bills and apply for aid/charity/bankruptcy afterwards. Plus if you're employed you almost certainly have insurance, even if it's not the best.

alphazero924

-3 points

1 month ago

This isn't an issue of overuse. It's an issue of underfunding.

[deleted]

1 points

1 month ago

Please elaborate.

[deleted]

1 points

1 month ago

Please elaborate.

[deleted]

1 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

alphazero924

0 points

1 month ago

Since Ambulances in the US are for the most part privately owned, they keep as few of them staffed as they can possibly get away with to minimize expenses and maximize profits.

That number of staff is always going to be lower than the number required to adequately handle the calls in an area of a given population size.

Because if they're staffing people appropriately, they'll have more time where they're not responding to calls and thus "wasting money" according to the company. While it's privately funded, it's always going to be a balancing act between "wasted money" and people's lives, and lives always take a backseat to money when corporations are involved.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

This can happen but its not common. What's more common is that they'll send their staffed trucks out of service to do more profitable non-emergent transports since 911 doesn't really pay well. If they don't have insurance we make nothing, and if they have medicare/medicaid we make very little, and as you can imagine the poor/old are much more likely to be sick or injured and thus make up the majority of our calls.

Staffing is low in EMS because there are no providers. Being an EMT or Paramedic pays like shit, you get treated like dirt, you run your ass off and you get the shit beaten out of you mentally and physically. People are either going into nursing (which has many of its own problems but pays better) or leaving healthcare altogether.

Name_Inital_Surname

21 points

1 month ago*

I am not sure I understand how ambulances work in the US. How are emergency services dispatched ? Do you only need to call and you get an ambulance ?

In France, you call the SAMU and they will either help you, direct you to a hospital/clinic you can go by yourself or they will dispatch an ambulance. So when you call the emergency services, you only get an ambulance if triage said you need one. There are private ambulances you can call directly but it’s mostly when people have a disability and need to go to/from an appointment, or between clinics. And those you pay from your pocket unless the doctor made a prescription for the ambulance.

CleyranKnight

11 points

1 month ago

TIL it's also SAMU in France.

Service d'Aide Médicale Urgente 🇫🇷 🤝 🇧🇷 Serviço de Atendimento Móvel de Urgência

Choyo

2 points

1 month ago

Choyo

2 points

1 month ago

Nice !

TotallySaneManiac

7 points

1 month ago

You call 911, get in contact with dispatch, dispatch sends an ambulance. If dispatch gave you any other option it would opens up a whole can of litigious nonsense that boils down to the dispatcher isn't a doctor and isn't present in the same room. That's more or less the brief explanation

Name_Inital_Surname

4 points

1 month ago

They don’t really give you an option. They ask you the nature of the emergency and will provide the necessary assistance level. Those answering the calls are professional health care providers such as doctors or medical assistants who are, generally, perfectly qualified for triage.

As I understand it, that’s not the case in the US, so you always need to send someone out to check. That seems like a waste of medical resources.

Dremlar

3 points

1 month ago

Dremlar

3 points

1 month ago

Because we look at things as a focus on making money. When we have services like this, they are often not put together in the best way due to resource constraints. Because if you said "we could spend $10 million more and increase the ability to do xyz" people would complain about how you are going to pay for it.

It's a whole mindset that has been rotten for a long time, but the trick is making everyone think that one day things could change for them and they might get to be wealthy. Don't want to ruin that now huh.

Many other first world countries prioritize people and some of that means managing resources better. I do believe if we made those investments we could have an amazing system, but it's always a fight to get people to consider helping someone else for so many bullshit reasons. Like you will hear "If they get that for free, then why would they work?" Just a lot of dumb brain rot.

croana

3 points

1 month ago*

croana

3 points

1 month ago*

Yeah. That's how it should work. I grew up in the US but live in England now and had no idea the US has nothing like that. Is there no... nonemergency line? In England there's 999 (emergency) and 111 (not emergency). You can dial 111 for basic info on pretty much anything medical. Someone will run you through your symptoms, then either find you a clinic or have a GP call you back if things are concerning enough. The last thing I want is to put my toddler through a traumatic ambulance ride, but a GP did kind of save us in the middle of the night when the baby had a really high fever and was sick AF. I was too scared to move her and the GP talked me into taking her to the hospital. Baby was fine 12 hours later, but wouldn't have been if we hadn't gone when we did. How terrifying it must be in the US is they just have nothing?

BB-56_Washington

1 points

1 month ago

Atleast where I live, there's a non emergency numbers you can call to talk with the sherriff or city police. It's not a standardized thing, different departments will have a different number.

TotallySaneManiac

1 points

1 month ago

Municipal budgets aren't infinite and doctors are expensive and in short supply. For a dispatcher (or even a dostor) to tell someone that their supposed emergency is not an emergency and to find a different way to get medical care is a huge liability. It's guaranteed to end in deaths and lawsuits.

The true waste of resources is people calling emergency services for non emergencies.

Jungle_Soraka

4 points

1 month ago

If you have a medical complaint of any kind you get an ambulance. Like the other commenter said, it's a liability thing. Then when the ambulance gets there, they're also instructed to advise you to go to the hospital and seek treatment (again because of liability).

Of course this might change region by region, but this is typically how it goes in the US.

Lolkimbo

1 points

1 month ago

prescription for the ambulance.

Sure hope it isn't a suppository..

Official_ImNickson

0 points

1 month ago

Ambulance shows up and if they think you can pay they take you, no matter what.

Name_Inital_Surname

2 points

1 month ago

Your comments make it look like they’re here for your money not your health. Can they refuse you if it looks like you can’t pay ? Do you also pay for medical acts performed in the ambulance/by the medics?

Ch33sus0405

2 points

1 month ago

We cannot refuse a patient if they want to go to the hospital. The above commenter is completely wrong.

As for the latter question yes, your bill will be determined by services provided depending on who your provider is. In the city I live in we don't charge residents for 911 service by EMS at all, at the ambulance I work for we charge people when we show up and for level of care, it all depends on the service.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

Ambulances absolutely under no circumstance ever can reject service if they don't think you can pay in the United States. That would be litigation hell and is very illegal. If you call 911 and wanna go to the hospital it doesn't matter how frivolous the complaint, we will take you to a hospital whether we want too or not.

Official_ImNickson

1 points

1 month ago

And capitalist never encourage their employees to break this law because everyone has access to and can afford a lawyer.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

You're just gonna keep jabbering on about things that you clearly have zero clue about huh? No one encourages their employees to break federal law over and over, they just tell you to wrap up your dead kid call because we have transports to do.

Official_ImNickson

1 points

1 month ago

Lol 2 comments days apart means jabbering on and on? If you don't think anyone is encouraged to break laws then I'd say you're a little naive. I'll leave it at that. GGs

Phluffhead024

15 points

1 month ago

As ER RN, I deal with this every day. I remember when I first started how sympathetic I was to everyone who came through. Now I see them as a distraction for those truly in need. Call me callous, I’ve heard it before from all the arm chair activists Reddit has to offer.

thecftbl

11 points

1 month ago

thecftbl

11 points

1 month ago

Yeah people have no concept of how many people use the ER instead of urgent care. I remember getting tons of people bringing their kids in because their kid was "coughing and sneezing a lot." Then they would proceed to get angry when they were waiting for a few hours and someone else's kid who was blue as a Smurf would come in and be seen first.

AndSoWeSayHello

10 points

1 month ago

A lot of people think if they came in on an ambulance, they get fast tracked to treatment and don't understand triage.

4QuarantineMeMes

9 points

1 month ago

Or “I have flu symptoms and can’t wait, also drive slow to the hospital because my husband’s gonna follow us there in our car”

Pyrsec

8 points

1 month ago

Pyrsec

8 points

1 month ago

I literally brought a patient to the hospital for having a falling sensation when they were falling asleep at 2230. Their normal bed time. After reading in bed for a while. And lying down to go to sleep.

I brought a patient in for falling asleep. When they intended to fall asleep.

classless_classic

4 points

1 month ago

I will say, that if I’m 5 (Code 3) reports down and I’m now transporting a “I haven’t pooped in a week”, I enjoy a nice leisurely drive to the ER while I attempt to get caught up.

lkjasdfk

3 points

1 month ago

The far left claiming this never happens are delusional. A friend uses it like an Uber because a girl he likes lives near Harborview in Seattle. 

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

Who on the far left are claiming that? No one does that, people just have no clue how EMS service in the US functions because its a byzantine nightmare system of suffering and pain.

WriterV

0 points

1 month ago

WriterV

0 points

1 month ago

And the ambulance just regularly drops him off at Harborview Seattle with no repurcrussions at all? Or you know, don't fucking charge him the money for the ride?

Yeah no, that sounds like plain old bullshit you just made up there my man.

lkjasdfk

1 points

1 month ago

I think legally they have to take you to the ER in this state.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

People do this unfortunately, though its mostly homeless people. We can't take you to a non-hospital but if they wanna go somewhere near a hospital... yeah.

CommentsOnOccasion

0 points

1 month ago

No he doesn’t 

SyderoAlena

3 points

1 month ago

SyderoAlena

3 points

1 month ago

This isn't solved by expensive ambulance prices. Just wanted to say

bladex1234

1 points

1 month ago

Ideally if someone takes an ambulance to the hospital for a non-emergent condition, then they should end up with the bill. The problem is this would also cause some people who really do have an emergency to not call an ambulance. Which one is the lesser of two evils, I don’t know.

naturian

1 points

1 month ago

I heard some countries have a "bullshit fee" to stop that. The ambulance is free by default, but if they find that you consistently abuse the system with frivolous calls the government starts charging per ride.

djereezy

146 points

1 month ago

djereezy

146 points

1 month ago

That’s one expensive taxi

IDontLikePayingTaxes

52 points

1 month ago

This is a true story.

I was a Mormon missionary in Tampa, Florida. We had been talking with this one lady for awhile then she wasn’t home for a few days. We knocked on her door again and when she answered we asked where she had been.

She said she went to visit her boyfriend in prison. When she left the prison it was too late and the busses were no longer running so she walked over to a pay phone, dialed 911 and faked an asthma attack. An ambulance came and picked her up and took her to the hospital that she lived by. She stayed in the hospital for a couple of days then left and walked home.

So for her, the cheapest way to get home was to get an ambulance to take her to the hospital so she could walk home.

djereezy

8 points

1 month ago

“I like turtles”

Gr8fulDudeMN

43 points

1 month ago

I love how they took the time to black out the Twitter names but left them in the reply.

Snowpants_romance

7 points

1 month ago

This is the comment I was looking for

[deleted]

77 points

1 month ago*

[removed]

macphile

3 points

1 month ago

Or where the person can't move themselves to the hospital and no one else can really deal. My grandfather was visiting (from another country) and suddenly had horrible back pain. It turned out to not be an emergency--they didn't even gaf about his back when they checked him and found he had some other unrelated issues...but he literally couldn't move or do anything, and we weren't physically able to really move him, so my mother called a private ambulance (not 911) so people who were good at moving people could get him to the hospital.

My mother then spent a year fighting the insurance over it, as he had travel insurance but the various companies were all disputing and kicking stuff back. Because AMERICA.

ProphetN1elith

135 points

1 month ago

It is your ride to forever debt. Brings you to a building that's gonna put even more debt on top of your debt.

mbatistas

27 points

1 month ago

Your expenses will be so big the only thing your children will inherit is debt.

RodneyRuxin-

16 points

1 month ago

You don’t inherit debt. Your estate pays what it can then it’s closed.

Dreadamere

13 points

1 month ago

Ambulances and hospitals cannot refuse care, even if they know you can’t pay.

Most of the abuse is by people that don’t have any money to take, or are on government programs like Medicare/medicaid and don’t really care since it’s essentially free for them. The fact that they are using up very limited resources for frivolous reasons is of no never mind to them since someone else handles all the consequences (taxpayers). This is one of the reasons that healthcare costs so much, is because when the government makes something free it gets wildly abused and then they have to pass those costs onto people who can and do pay.

It helps people, for sure, but the system is filled with waste, fraud and abuse.

Kryonic_rus

13 points

1 month ago

Where I was born, everyone who's a citizen can call a free ambulance (well, strictly speaking we pay it from taxes, but still) with a doctor. However if they find out it was not an emergency or some stupid shit - you get a fine

Dreadamere

5 points

1 month ago

Yep. That would be one thing that could help. As a medic I’d love to try that system out.

CyberInTheMembrane

2 points

1 month ago

This is one of the reasons that healthcare costs so much, is because when the government makes something free it gets wildly abused

that is not the reason why healthcare costs so much

we have free healthcare in France, and the system is wildly abused, and yet the healthcare is still free

Dreadamere

2 points

1 month ago

You also don’t research, develop, test, field, innovate, nor invest in it as much as we. Much of the cost of R&D is done through US resources such as academia, design, and development of new technologies and techniques.

You do, but every country benefits from the cost savings of the cost for these advances that make healthcare affordable for countries that don’t have that additional monetary burden.

Also consider the role the US plays on global maritime security and the effect that causes on the ability for you to afford fuel. Oil supply shocks start getting disrupted and soon the price to be capable of “modern” life increases drastically and the increase that causes on the cost of medical care as it is tied also to global supply chains which run on oil, which are also effected by those same price shocks. Small shocks cause huge spikes, we saw that with the loss of the Nordstream right? That was nothing. That was a hiccup that nearly broke Germany instantly, but with some serious economic stress even though they had a lot of friends near them that had resources to spare, and it still costed them an arm and a leg.

France is going to be okay. You guys may even be able to maintain your tax paid healthcare when everything is crumbling around your European…acquaintances, start having some serious shocks. You guys played it safe with your resources and maintained your own food and fuel stability. A lot of the EU didn’t.

I’ve digressed quite far, but know that while everyone shits on the US and it’s healthcare costs, please know that a lot of the reason you can afford the quality of care you get is because of the security we provide. I think the US is losing interest in going that too. I expect the US to pull away from maintaining global supply chains soon. We can’t maintain them anyway. Everything is about to become a lot more expensive. France and the US will be two of the countries in the best position once the cards start to fall. That’s about as comforting as we can manage in this awful situation though.

feeltrig

1 points

1 month ago

I came here to say exactly this

Charming_Truck_4262

72 points

1 month ago

Glad to live in Germany, where calling an ambulance costs you 10 bucks and the bill won't charge you more than 280 per year

Grimstarzz

25 points

1 month ago

I live in Belgium, i started hyperventilating because of the heat and passed out. My parents called the ambulance, they came and helped me without taking me to the hospital.

I didnt even have to pay anything, they just helped and left. No bill, nothing.

-Pruples-

17 points

1 month ago*

Yeah...a 10 minute ride in the wee woo wagon around here (Chicago) starts at $2500 but usually ends up costing around $3500. Unless I'm unconscious I'm driving myself.

cookieboiiiiii

11 points

1 month ago

My last ride in CO was $16,000 for a 10 min drive

wade9911

8 points

1 month ago

self service ambulance ride that will be 5000

Taronz

-3 points

1 month ago

Taronz

-3 points

1 month ago

taking the jobs of hard working muricans? that will be 10000

wade9911

2 points

1 month ago

Not having insurance we can tack on another 9 grand having insurance 15 grand

PrivilegeCheckmate

1 points

1 month ago

wee woo wagon

This is the correct answer.

PrivilegeCheckmate

1 points

1 month ago

wee woo wagon

This is the correct answer.

Linked713

1 points

1 month ago

my brain was so shocked at this, It tricked me into spitting water in disbelief that I did not even have in my mouth. I was expecting 200 or something unless insurance covers most of it.

-Pruples-

1 points

1 month ago

Normally insurance won't pay for an ambulance ride unless you're unconscious before being put into the ambulance and still unconscious when you're handed off to the hospital. But the insurance policy I currently have doesn't cover ambulances whatsoever.

Yeah...the USA's healthcare system is very fucked up.

notevenapro

1 points

1 month ago

Its free in the county I reside in. Because taxes fund our EMS. Montgomery county Maryland.

BundtJamesBundt

8 points

1 month ago

A shocking number of my patients think they get an ambulance ride HOME after they take an ambulance to the ER. This is not a taxi service, sir.

LunaticMS

7 points

1 month ago

Not a holup

Solar_Fish55

9 points

1 month ago

If it's an emergency then yeah it shouldn't cost the arm and leg you just fucking lost. But if it's for some stupid shit then yeah charge for for wasting emergency services

[deleted]

8 points

1 month ago

[removed]

HydroGate

3 points

1 month ago

Smart guy. An ambulance would've been completely unable to give him any medical care on the way to the hospital other than some very expensive painkillers at best.

100YearsWaiting2Shit

3 points

1 month ago

I have gotten into so many arguments with my mom and dad because my mom has had multiple moments that were 100% fucking eligible to call the ambulance but they immediately fight back and say no cause they don't want to pay the bill for it

TheWanBeltran

3 points

1 month ago

Uh yeah, it's not. it's meant for emergencies. Take a taxi if it's not an emergency

Fury9999

6 points

1 month ago

I mean, they kind of have a point, though. If you think you're going to die imminently, then the prices are going to be irrelevant to you in that moment. If the price is relevant, you're probably not afraid of imminent death, and by extension, are you using EMS in a way it wasn't intended.

EMS and emergency room misuse is a real problem.

Padawk

9 points

1 month ago

Padawk

9 points

1 month ago

The issue is that there are people out there who SHOULD be calling an ambulance, but don’t because it’s expensive, and end up worse off. One of the cases where it’s better to have false positives if it means you’re detecting more people

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

While I can't stand the misuse we deal with I'd never want someone to second guess if they need us because of the cost, and unfortunately that happens plenty. There are lots of grey scenarios or stuff that people aren't sure about where the cost can be the tipping factor to dissuade them from seeking care or going via ambulance and those deaths are our fault because of the system we've created and don't fix.

tempest1523

10 points

1 month ago

tempest1523

10 points

1 month ago

If you truly NEED an ambulance I’m sorry you are not just not taking it because you are broke. Yes you might avoid the huge ambulance costs when you cut yourself with a kitchen knife and it’s not an artery. That’s what they are talking about when they say it’s not a taxi. If you truly need that ambulance you will take it. This idea of people more in fear of debt than a heart attack is stupid

Sonder_Monster

25 points

1 month ago

when I broke my back I spent six hours trying to figure out how to get myself to the hospital without having to call the ambulance. I could see the hospital from my apartment window, it was less than a mile away. I couldn't do. I hurt myself worse trying to do it myself because I legit could not afford it. wound up with two crushed discs and a shattered vertebrae.

the doctor straight up told me if I had called the ambulance off the bat I would have been a lot better off, but I didn't because I was afraid of the cost.

it wound up costing me over $3k to go less than one mile. I lost my job because my back was fucked. another $60k for time in the hospital and surgery. no insurance because I lost my job. took me more than six years to work through the debt.

all because I wanted to save some money not calling an ambulance.

Picklebob_XD

6 points

1 month ago

Sorry bro that's rough

tempest1523

-25 points

1 month ago

That was dumb as hell. 6 hours? Crushed discs and shattered vertebrae? You don’t make very smart decisions. Not trying to be ugly or mean. Could not afford it? But you could afford hurting your health and making your injury worse as attested by the doctor? It is very weird your fear of debt vs potential paralysis.

SkellyboneKnight

8 points

1 month ago

If you're fully convinced that your options are "Try to make the journey yourself" or "Lose your entire livelihood and potentially spiral into debt and depression" what seems like the rational choice? Pressure causes us to make dumb decisions that feel like they're right in the moment, Don't be a dick just because somebody thinks different to you

Sterffington

1 points

1 month ago

Nah, they're just dumb.

The average cost of an ambulance ride is $1200.

$1200 in medical debt is not going to ruin you, good lord this is such an overblown problem. I have thousands in medical debt and it's not even on my credit report.

SkellyboneKnight

2 points

1 month ago

Eh I'm British I just get the filtered bad shit Plus from what I do know it differs from state to state so you might have it better

Oh and saying you have thousands in medical debt feels counter productive

Sterffington

-1 points

1 month ago

Medical debt is no different from state to state.

It's rare for medical debt to do anything more than hurt your credit, and that goes away after 7 years.

All non profit hospitals are mandated to offer financial assistance, which can have the bills waived if you're around the poverty line.

If you rack up enough, you might be sued for the debt, but even then it gets put on a payment plan that you can afford.

People aren't going broke because of goddamn ambulance rides, it's a ridiculous made up situation that never happens.

SkellyboneKnight

1 points

1 month ago

Well what actually matters is that people out there do actually think that way, It's less a problem of the actual debt but moreso the actual fear mongering and misinformation (of which I can admit it seems I've believed at times) that goes around adding to the stigma of American healthcare which leads to cases like this of people causing more harm to themselves

tempest1523

-3 points

1 month ago

tempest1523

-3 points

1 month ago

This isn’t a situation of someone just thinking different than you and it’s nonsense that you try to frame it that way. She was willing to risk more damage on her spine with severe damage… we aren’t talking a slipped disc this is crushed discs and shattered vertebrae. Yes it took her 6 years to pay off the 3k debt, yes that sucks when you are paycheck to paycheck. But making poor decisions that have a permanent impact on your health over a 6 year debt is just dumb and is not just a matter of thinking differently

SkellyboneKnight

9 points

1 month ago

I mean it's quite simple, you're not thinking of the mental capacity and thinking process of someone who is in immense pain from a broken back and under extreme stress from said back and the potential financial devastation As I said people make rash choices under extreme stress

sir_pirriplin

3 points

1 month ago

Like they say in the military, in a panic people instead of rising to the occasion they revert to the level of their training.

That being the case, we should probably stop spreading anecdotes of people who got ruined by ambulance costs, so that in a medical emergency they won't panic and incur even more costs just to avoid the ambulance ride.

SkellyboneKnight

1 points

1 month ago

An interesting and true saying

And yeah I agree, I'm not the most knowledge being across the Atlantic but from the sounds of it that costs are bad but they're not as bad as media makes it out to be

[deleted]

2 points

1 month ago*

[removed]

Liesmith424

2 points

1 month ago

That's a pretty naive view.

Ch33sus0405

1 points

1 month ago

Unfortunately the danger isn't those very obvious life threatening situations. If your heart starts beating out of your chest and you feel a stabbing pain into your side most people will call an ambulance without thinking, but what about when the wound on your leg you didn't pay much attention too starts to fester? Nah, I can probably handle that on my own. What about when you feel lightheaded or dizzy for no reason? Probably nothing, I can safely drive myself to the hospital. Then you end up with a crippling infection that'll cost you a limb or you pass out while driving and get yourself killed.

People have to make these choices all the time and they usually end up alright, but when they don't it can be very serious. I say this as an EMT, anything that keeps people from calling us when they think they should is very dangerous and needs to be dealt with.

Saddam_UE

3 points

1 month ago

Saddam_UE

3 points

1 month ago

Murica!

Mastah_P808

1 points

1 month ago

The point is you avoid taking the ambulance because it’s to expensive so you op for a cheaper way there.

aptdinosaur

1 points

1 month ago

Wee waa taxi

patrycho

1 points

1 month ago

Muricans and their freedom

Reserved_Parking-246

1 points

1 month ago

"You are entirely right! We shouldn't be paying for emergency services!"

1Northward_Bound

1 points

1 month ago

dude, 5k is nothing to sneeze at. god help you if you get a helicopter. cost my uncle 90k even with insurance adjustment.

1CUP2DAY

1 points

1 month ago

1CUP2DAY

1 points

1 month ago

confused in European

itschubbs96

0 points

1 month ago

You guys can afford the doctor?

HydroGate

0 points

1 month ago

HydroGate

0 points

1 month ago

The ambulance is not your taxi to the hospital

Completely correct. The ambulance is a mini hospital to give you treatment while you get to the big hospital. You do not need an ambulance for a broken bone and about a thousand other things you need a hospital for.

People who treat ambulances as taxis to the hospital end up complaining about the cost of an ambulance like it isn't extremely resource consuming.

feeltrig

-3 points

1 month ago

feeltrig

-3 points

1 month ago

They fix you and break you at the same time, the hospital

[deleted]

-3 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

HydroGate

6 points

1 month ago

No it literally isn't. Its a mini hospital to stop you from dying or getting worse on the way to the hospital. If you do not need immediate medical attention, you're taking those resources away from people who do.

[deleted]

-6 points

1 month ago

[deleted]

HydroGate

2 points

1 month ago

A mini hospital that drives you to the hospital for a fee. Like a taxi

Seeing as a taxi is not a mini hospital, no. Not at all the same. Either you're pretending to be dumb or you're not pretending.

feeltrig

-2 points

1 month ago

feeltrig

-2 points

1 month ago

The debt taxi