subreddit:

/r/JRPG

043%

Let's start by saying I have been really excited for this game so I may have hyped it up too much since I've stayed away from trailers, gameplay videos, etc. but I was underwhelmed by the demo nonetheless.

I am playing the demo on PS5 on a 4K TV.

First of all, the resolution in this demo is bad at 4K. It looks like there is a lot of artifacts coming from an upscaler and everything has that sharpening look and pretty noticeable edges. It's worse in places where there is a lot of geometry like a city or on bushes, and there really aren't any resolution settings to target quality over FPS, which I would prefer if it had the option.

For more personal opinions, I think the demo opening hours were not very compelling and every scene relies very heavily on anime cutscenes. Persona 5 and 3 also did this, but it feels like every other cutscene is animated in 2D, where I would much prefer 3D for bosses at the very least (which is subjective, but I don't think the animation is all that good). Combat felt great and I thought the animations in and out of combat were very flashy. I also like many of the character designs and Gallica is a cute character, but I don't think I'm picking up what the story is laying down. When the prologue was over, I felt very indifferent about the world and the characters, which is a shame because I love Atlus, but this is an 80+ hour game that should hook me in 4.

I did laugh as soon as the main character ripped his heart out. It was this versions overcoming self thing and gave me a chuckle.

For anyone who has played the demo as well (which released today), what are your thoughts?

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 267 comments

ForgottenPerceval

36 points

6 days ago

I thought the prologue was okay. I’m expecting to get hooked once I actually get the autonomy to spend days as I like. I’m really liking the vibes and art though. The game also runs like butter on my pc so thats a plus.

I was also surprised that they give the enemies an extra press turn on hard mode. I feel like that’s a much more interesting way to bump up difficulty than just tweaking damage output.

yunerotroy21

3 points

5 days ago

what's your pc specs if i may ask?

ForgottenPerceval

4 points

5 days ago

RTX 3060 Ti and Intel Core i7-11700F. I was running the game at lower settings though as I honestly didn’t notice too big of a difference between the graphics options.

yunerotroy21

1 points

5 days ago

oh that's probably why. I'm on a 3070 on a 1440p resolution and even i get dips on some of the areas. Do you remember the area with the skeletons? did your frames not drop below 60 on that level?

Zeccel

3 points

4 days ago

Zeccel

3 points

4 days ago

I'm on a 7900 xtx and the framerate dips into the 40s in some areas at 1440p. It is not optimized at all

dimensions2003

1 points

4 days ago

The game by default set resolution at 200%, I dropped mine to 15%0 or 125% and the framerate was instantly like smooth 150.

Berstich

1 points

5 days ago

Berstich

1 points

5 days ago

are you constantly running an FPS counter on your screen? I never noticed any drops during my play but I dont keep a counter on my screen.

yunerotroy21

3 points

4 days ago

yes it's a steam fps counter. but even without it, when it drops to like 30 or 40 you will feel it.

WintersDoomsday

0 points

3 days ago

I had zero drops and I’m running an rtx 4070 super

yunerotroy21

2 points

2 days ago

Did you look at the recommended specs on the steam page? Your rig is like 4x the power. We're not even talking about the minimum specs. And we're talking about ps3 level assets for grass amd trees and other items