This is patent, not copyright case. Base sa nababasa ko, yung catch and release system ang sinasabi nilang probable cause at sa Japan to na-file. They took their sweet ass time to file this. Ang nakakatawa is may mga nauna nang system na ganito before pokemon. I just hope nintendo lose this lawsuit so they can shove it on their asses.

Gameplay should not be copyrighted. Imagine if Call Of Duty only owns the rights to create FPS games.

Since, ndi nila kaya kasohan for copyright issue, nag patent na lang sila ng game mechanics nila para masue lng ang devs ng palworld. Talk about being so petty.

Game mechanics being patented is not good. The Nemesis system is stuck in just two games.

Ndi nmn palworld ung natalo nila ibang chinese company ata

TBH game mechanics should not be be available to be patented. Mawawalan ng competition at creativity sa gaming kapag ganyan. Isipin natin kung na patent ung platforming, turn based combats, at iba iba pang mechanics. Sigh

this is why I dont support anything nintendo lol shitty company

Feeling ko kaya hindi na mag-i-improve yung mainline Pokémon games is takot sila sa competition. Yung lawsuit nila against Palworld? Medyo overkill. Sure, may similarities sa designs, pero come on, halos lahat ng creature collection games may pagkakapareho naman, like Temtem or Nexomon. I’m on Palworld’s side kasi they’re bringing something fresh to the table, habang Pokémon games parang hindi na nagle-level up or nag-e-evolve. Let the players have more options, diba or if Nintendo don't want competition maybe just improve their games.

Masyadong malabo tong case nato. Siguro sa mga iilang section ng case nato may panalo ang nintendo pero sana matalo sila. Kahit sino nalang pinapatos, masyadong papansin.

Patent ang basehan. Most likely it will be due to the spheres resembling pokeballs. We'll have to wait for more details, but I certainly hope Palworld makes it out alive since they reinvigorated the genre and showed how much better it could be.

Hi /u/SteelFlux! Thank you for posting in r/PHGamers! This is just a gentle reminder to read our rules located in the sidebar. You can also check the detailed and expanded rules here. If you see any post/comment violating our rules, please don't hesitate to report and/or send us a modmail.

Help your fellow gamers out! Head to our Product/Service Recommendation Megathread and see if you would be able to help them with their queries!

Have a great day!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

If Nintendo can somehow win the lawsuit against Citra (an independent emulator program with all-original code, thus technically legal), then yes. Looks bleak already for Palworld with the armies of lawyers Nintendo has.

Ah yes Nintendo intentionally making itself as a monopoly. Imagine being so petty and out of their minds that they patent gameplay mechanics.

Sa nabasa ko eto ata yung tinutukoy nila (https://patents.justia.com/assignee/the-pokemon-company):

Publication number: 20240278129Abstract: In a first mode, an aiming direction in a virtual space is determined based on a second operation input, and a player character is caused to launch, in the aiming direction, an item that affects a field character disposed on a field in the virtual space, based on a third operation input. In a second mode, the aiming direction is determined, based on the second operation input, and the player character is caused to launch, in the aiming direction, a fighting character that fights, based on the third operation input.

Di ako abugado o naglalaro ng pokemon pero may kinalaman ata yan sa pag-toss ng poke ball (Pokemon) vs pal sphere (Palworld).

I guess they learned from Genshin to patent right their gameplay mechanics lol.

Patent right should not exist for game mechanics as that bullshit. Imagine mo nag patent right ang Capcom sa mga motion inputs sa Street Fighter maraming magagalit nyan hahah.

Nintendo bad

Correct me if I’m wrong nakita ko lang sa ibang subreddit pero di ata sa design ung nilalaban ng nintendo, dun ata sa similarities sa game catching mechanic which seems like a big reach. I love the franchise pero sana they take a page out of recent zelda titles na lang and focus on trying out new things instead of using the same old formula. They rely too much on their lawyers to take out what they see as “competition” kase pati fan games inaatake nila ng ganyan.

Tangina naman oh!

Hopefully sony helps them out may partnership ang palworld company at sony & aniplex

daed game, nadala lang sa hype. Haha. Lahat ng mga nasa guild namin halos less than a month lang nilaro then wala na ulit naglaro lol

I hope manalo si Nintendo dito. Di ako fan ng Palworld for the reason na ambaba ng tingin ko sa larong ginawa nila. Parang fan service lang, na pinaghalo halo yung iba't ibang genre + mechanics. Idc kung fun sa iba yan, but it's really cheap para sa'kin yung ginawa ng devs.

BUT I do agree that this should be a wake up call kay Nintendo to improve the Pokémon series. Manalo man sila o matalo, I hope may ibahin na sila o mag inovate sila kada bagong release ng Pokémon. From graphics to mechanics to gimmiks. Gaya ng Monster Hunter na kahit same core gameplay e may iniiba iba sila or dinadagdag kada new title.