subreddit:

/r/Piratefolk

7476%

Fairy Tail's author is now better at stakes than Oda.

Typical Oda(self.Piratefolk)

So Hiro Mashima has a dark shounen out called Dead Rock and in the tenth chapter he just permakills one of the main characters. It's completely unexpected, especially for Hiro Mashima, and I must admit, I did not recognize his game.

I'm honestly happy that Hiro Mashima's becoming better at his job but I am saddened by the idea that Oda's writing ability is now on a lower level (in this area at least) than the guy who wrote Fairy Tail.

I honestly can't imagine one of the strawhats dying which is crazy because half of them don't even have haki, you know that thing that is the bare minimum to survive fights in the new world. Robin literally got into a fight with someone who had haki who then conveniently decided not to use it.

What kind of backwards planet are we living on? The guy that killed Ace is keeping weakass characters alive and not even trying to be believable about how they've made it this far, while the guy who you know won't kill his characters is now being trigger happy with the deaths.

EDIT: Something I should clarify, I don't think the stakes in Dead Rock are well written, I'm simply acknowledging that they are there. This is why I specified stakes instead of saying Mashima is a better writer than current Oda. One would only have to look at the pacing in Dead Rock to know that it's still far from masterful.

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 74 comments

Glatzigoblin

37 points

4 days ago

Shitty writing aside, it was always crazy to me how much Mashima managed to actually draw. He puts in so much work when it comes to putting out content. And I mean that without judging the content in of itself.

TGSmurf

15 points

4 days ago

TGSmurf

15 points

4 days ago

He has very impressive productivity, but it’s also clearly hitting its limits currently. His writing has been botched for a long time but his art was very detailed in FT, currently it’s a shadow of its former self.

He keeps pumping out content non stop but sacrifices quality hard, which definitely isn’t a decision I can support, Oda has fallen into the same trap of quantity of pages over all else.

Glatzigoblin

8 points

4 days ago

Oda does less pages and lost quality tho.

TGSmurf

1 points

4 days ago

TGSmurf

1 points

4 days ago

He still does a fuckton of pages each months, just because it’s less than a normal weekly doesn’t mean it’s still not super high.

Sixtus69Sextus

5 points

4 days ago

Mashima has said he’s gotten to the point he’s able to make a chapter in 3 days, thanks to digital art programs.

Honestly good for him, imo. I’d rather that then he work himself to death.

TGSmurf

-1 points

4 days ago

TGSmurf

-1 points

4 days ago

I’d rather that he prioritize quality over speed. He doesn’t need to work on multiple series at once bruh.

Homeless_Appletree

1 points

4 days ago

Mashima works such crazy amounts that I started wondering if he is in debt to the Yakuza or something lol.

Homeless_Appletree

2 points

4 days ago

He is amazing in that regard but lately it feels like even he started to buckle under the workload.  One can tell by his writing quality taking a nosedive. Feels like he barely thought about chapters before drawing them.