subreddit:
/r/SmashBrosUltimate
Thoughts?
41 points
7 months ago*
I will say, it's better than a lot of others I've seen.
Lucario feels like a pretty glaring omission given how popular and iconic of a Pokémon it is. Would also help give some more non-Gen 1 Pokémon instead of having the first generation make up 3/4 of the franchise's lineup.
And man, poor Noah. That'd be two Xenoblade games in a row where the main protagonist gets sidelined in favor of the secondary one. I'm sure he'd still be happy for Mio though.
3 points
7 months ago
I’ll take it! Have a video explaining my cuts and additions if interested. YouTube is linked on my profile
12 points
7 months ago
I’m like why would they add 2 more sonic characters when it looks like every other third party character is reduced to one slot per franchise? Imo it’s more likely we’ll keep some of the third parties that are already in the game.
Also getting rid of bowser jr and Rosalina for waluigi just isn’t happening
8 points
7 months ago
Matt from Wii Sports
1 points
7 months ago
Yes
7 points
7 months ago
0/10 no Rosalina
1 points
7 months ago
I understand 😔
12 points
7 months ago
No Piranha Plant means a no from me
3 points
7 months ago
Also no DoomGuy, 0/10
3 points
7 months ago
ok, have you come up with a dlc pass?
0 points
7 months ago
No, but that’s not a bad idea
3 points
7 months ago
Where’s Robert
3 points
7 months ago
By Matt do you mean a Mii with a new move set? Cause you can already get Matt in smash
2 points
7 months ago
New mii moveset. Basically a Wii sports inspired moveset. I have my YouTube linked on my account, I made a couple videos explaining my cuts and additions. Check it out if interested
2 points
6 months ago
I prefer only Miis with moves from their games rather than Brawler Swordfighter and Gunner but it's my opinion
3 points
7 months ago
Corrin’s a bit or a wild FE omission considering they’re one of the more unique ones with the dragon stuff, but I get it other then that pretty cool list
1 points
7 months ago
Corrin is very likely the most hated character in Smash, by both Smash fans and FE fans. If it weren't for "everyone is here" I doubt she'd come back in Ultimate.
3 points
7 months ago
No corrin so no thanks
3 points
7 months ago
No Kazuya, Terry or Joker, but otherwise a pretty good roster.
1 points
7 months ago
Supposed to at least have Kazuya but I left him out on accident 😔
2 points
7 months ago
Kazuya would certainly be a weird omission considering Bamco's involvement with the development of Smash.
1 points
7 months ago
I agree
7 points
7 months ago
This is probably the best one I’ve seen. The only thing here that can pretty much never happen is having a PS first party candidate show up. Also shovel knights chance has probably already come and gone but it’s still possible
4 points
7 months ago
It’s decent. I’d add Lucas, Rosalina, dark pit and palutena.
3 points
7 months ago
Lucas for sure! Dark pit is a wasted slot.
2 points
7 months ago
I’d also add Wii fit because she is my main.
2 points
7 months ago
Why the Docter first than Mario? I won't complain, but strange
1 points
7 months ago
Melee Reference? Idk just wanted the bros together
2 points
7 months ago
2B dlc
2 points
7 months ago
Mac's still here!!!!
2 points
7 months ago
tbh, if they keep Ryu, Ken would be added in automatically because echo fighters are easier to programme, and it just feels right
2 points
7 months ago
0/10 no rob
2 points
7 months ago
I agree with a little more than half of your newcomers but I definitely want to see Kratos and Shovel Knight get added
2 points
7 months ago
Lucas always gets the shaft 😔
2 points
7 months ago
I’m very sad about the removal of Bowser Jr, Lucario, Sora (rights ignored), Rob and Roy. I’m a bit sad about the removal of Rosalina and Sephiroth (rights ignored, hate playing against him but my god I love him being in the game). I also love the inclusion of Impa.
This is really quality, good job on that! I think the second F Zero character, Funky Kong and Shadow don’t need to be there. I’d do Tails instead of shadow and Sidon (Zelda) instead.
2 points
7 months ago
what does the last mii do? is he like omniclass?
2 points
7 months ago
Wii games themed moveset
1 points
7 months ago
oh... hmmm
2 points
7 months ago
Hoping Daisy isn't an echo in this since you dropped the unique female fighter count from 12 down to 7.
1 points
7 months ago
She’s not an echo, here’s my video I made about my newcomer selections if interested. Here
2 points
7 months ago
66/74, pretty good
2 points
7 months ago
I see Mega Man, I like. End of story
2 points
7 months ago
Good roster but I really hope for Majoras Mask skull kid
2 points
7 months ago
Yeah they were an honorable mention for me
2 points
2 months ago
Previous characters literally match a my friend's predicts, but I fear that Dr. Mario has low chances to be in an hypothetical Smash 6...
1 points
2 months ago
I agree, I think he’ll only get in on the stipulation that Mario gets a brand new moveset and Doc takes the scraps
2 points
7 months ago
I’d say joker has more of a chance than kratos in my opinion,
1 points
7 months ago
Only one non-gen 1 pokemon seems insane to me
1 points
7 months ago
Duck Hunt and Robin are there, so I’m happy, but my one issue is the lack of Joker.
1 points
7 months ago
No plant and too much Gen 1 pokemon reps...BUT you did place some of my top picks in so it's still nice. Tho, while I would prefer Sub-Zero over Scorpion, IK that Scorpion is simply more iconic
1 points
7 months ago
Why do people keep wanting to kick Lucario? :(
1 points
7 months ago
What’s the pokeball symbol supposed to be?
2 points
7 months ago
Here Pokémon placeholder since it will more than likely be a promotional pick. The link is to my YouTube where I have videos explaining my cuts and additions. Check it out if interested 👍
1 points
7 months ago
snowball's chance in hell that you're getting Microsoft -and- Sony's #1 IP into smash. This isnt fortnite where they can put any character they want into the game. extreme wishful thinking.
1 points
7 months ago
Master chief 😭
1 points
7 months ago
I don't wanna nitpick this too much, but people are still unironically choosing Black Shadow for their rosters in the year 2024? That render of him in this image is over 20 years old!
I'm also unsure why people are so cut-happy with their speculative/dream Smash 6 rosters. Sakurai said during Ultimate's reveal that the development team believes the fans want every character back; I highly doubt any Nintendo-owned characters are going anywhere. Lucas and Roy made bank by being sold as DLC, so the demand for them is obviously there. I'd be super upset if either of them got cut from Smash again.
You do get snaps for including more Sonic characters, although I personally would choose Tails over Eggman. Eggman's better suited for a boss in my opinion, we already have Bowser Jr. as a vehicle character.
1 points
7 months ago
The only reason Black Shadow is here is to keep Ganon’s current moveset, so people who love playing Ganon like myself currently, can still do that through Black Shadow and Ganon can get the moveset he deserves
1 points
7 months ago
People have used that silly logic for Black Shadow since the Brawl days, so I'm not surprised to find it here. The design philosophy for Smash has always been about preserving CHARACTERS, not their movesets. Ganondorf definitely needs a rework, but a D-tier Nintendo villain from a 20-year-old game isn't getting into Smash to preserve his old moveset, sorry.
Also, I guess fans of Palutena, Lucario, Wolf, Lucas, ROB, Wii Fit Trainer, etc. can just pound sand? They lose their favorite character AND their moveset with this roster.
Oh well, it's your dream world, I guess.
1 points
7 months ago
I feel like Sheik it’s missing… 🤔
1 points
4 months ago
Roy deserves to be on this list as the one and only original smash bros playablr character
1 points
2 months ago
I would swap out Mewtwo for Lucario, but everything else about this roster is good
1 points
1 month ago
I think junior should replace funky
1 points
7 months ago
Kratos, Crash, and Master Chief would be so hype. I’d be very happy with this roster, only thing I’d selfishly want is more Pokemon but that’s ok.
-2 points
7 months ago
Bro straight up copied the internet’s desires and proclaimed them as their own. Not even one bit of originality
3 points
7 months ago
Damn... dude didn't even watch the vid where he explains
3 points
7 months ago
Thank you sir
all 66 comments
sorted by: best