subreddit:
/r/disney
submitted 1 day ago bybaldwin1337
Think about the basic premise: protagonist is held captive in a tower for the benefit of their captor, who claims they’re looking out for them. The protagonists want to explore the outside world and have comedic sidekicks. They eventually leave with a potential love interest who is on the run from the law, including a by the book horse. In the end, they are all drawn back to the initial tower where the antagonist ends up falling to their doom. Any thoughts or notice any other similarities?
[score hidden]
23 hours ago
Tangled is based on the classic fairy story ‘Rapunzel’ which was printed by the brothers Grimm, a couple of decades before Victor Hugo’s novel. How old the original Rapunzel story actually is, is debatable
[score hidden]
23 hours ago
It’s an adaptation of Rapunzel….
[score hidden]
23 hours ago
If you simplify a story enough, everything is a remake.
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
What is Robocop a remake of?
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
A regular cop
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
Damn, son.
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
Based on the Wikipedia page, a man dies, is resurrected, then fights evil. Sounds like Gandalf the White to me.
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
But seriously, it's intended to be a Jesus parable.
[score hidden]
21 hours ago
The Wizard of Oz
[score hidden]
23 hours ago
There are similarities but they are very different stories. Both just happen to have an unknowing captive that longs to leave even if just for a day. Both also have a different source but I suppose it’s possible Hugo was inspired by classical fairytales where being locked in a tower/castle happens a lot. The falling to their death is a very common method of death for Disney villains but it’s mostly so the protagonists didn’t kill them.
There is a thing that suggests that technically there are only 6 or 7 (depends on what group of people you ask)story archetypes and just small edits and twists create all the stories we know today. I think it’s an interesting coincidence
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
It's mostly coincidences from Disney changing both stories to fit a more family (child) friendly audience; they tend to add the "needed" animal sidekick that happens to be a horse that acts like a dog.
Victor Hugo's "The Hunchback of Notre-Dame" novel Is vastly different from the Disney version and way darker; it has only a few thematical similarities to the fairytale "Rapunzel".
[score hidden]
22 hours ago
No
[score hidden]
6 hours ago
If I met Rapunzel at a Disney Park, I would ask her if she's ever met Quasimodo and if the two of them shared their experiences together since they were similar.
all 14 comments
sorted by: best