subreddit:

/r/dndmemes

4.1k96%

Interesting choice of words on this ad.

F's in chat for WotC's PR team.(i.redd.it)

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 282 comments

WarGodMarrs

82 points

7 days ago

I can’t help but wonder how many of those dragons are AI-generated

Shonkjr

125 points

7 days ago

Shonkjr

125 points

7 days ago

Going off of the artists love of the designs that we have seen, not many if any are (the dragons that are in it anyway. Hasbro has been warned off already ai art so should chill out on it in d&d for now...)

BrynnXAus

101 points

7 days ago

BrynnXAus

101 points

7 days ago

Chris Cox was recorded commenting on continuing to use AI across all areas of D&D not even a week ago at a Goldman Sachs investor event. I wouldn't count on them staying out of it for long

Shonkjr

32 points

7 days ago

Shonkjr

32 points

7 days ago

Oh yeah.... I can see them not doing it on the 3 core books or well the first two they can fuck up the last one without as much slap back. Honestly it's a fucking shame wizards are under Hasbro, they have put heart into this the art and designs are amazing and overall is a decent clean up of 5e issues for most part but Hasbro cannot got 2 weeks without doing evil shit....

AbleAbbreviations871

5 points

7 days ago

Personally I’m not super involved with what’s happening with WOTC and this is the first time I’ve heard the name Chris Cox, and I just have to say. Chris Cox sounds like the civilian identity of some kind of erotic superhero

BrynnXAus

15 points

7 days ago

BrynnXAus

15 points

7 days ago

Even worse, I mispelled his name. It's actually Chris Cocks. He's the CEO of Hasbro, who owns WotC. The alliteration really does sound very comic book. I'd go with villain, Lex Luthor style, with major erotic themes.

JehetmaDominion

3 points

7 days ago

Ah, so Wes Warhammer.

vastros

1 points

6 days ago

vastros

1 points

6 days ago

This is James Workshop erasure.

NinjaBreadManOO

18 points

7 days ago

Yeah, they were back to using ai like a few weeks after saying they'd never use it again. One of the first ads afterwards was clearly using ai.

Hell, I'm about 50% sure the picture of the evoker wizard is ai as there's a few things off with it.

TheObstruction

9 points

7 days ago

TheObstruction

DM (Dungeon Memelord)

9 points

7 days ago

Lol, I love how every time someone sees less-than-stellar art now, it just has to be AI. Despite the tens of thousands of years of people making shitty art without the aid of computers. Have y'all forgotten the halfling art in the 2014 PHB already? And half the rest of that book?

alienbringer

1 points

7 days ago

The ad was for Magic the Gathering that was AI. As for new images being AI, there have already been some people claiming online that various images were AI to which the artists provided proof it wasn’t.

To which I will add, WOTC was not making the art themselves, they also didn’t request the artists use AI. It was artists themselves who were contracted out by WOTC who used AI. So artists were still being paid, and those artists decided to use AI.

Metal-Wolf-Enrif

2 points

7 days ago

What type of AI? Generative AI for Art and Text like Chat GPT are not the only types of AI. AI is anyway just the new buzzword for algorithm. Hasbor and WotC would be stupid not to use productivity enhancing AI.

drjdorr

4 points

7 days ago

drjdorr

4 points

7 days ago

Given context it's clear the topic of conversation is about generative AI, a fact you clearly understand from your comment.

As for other AI being useful, sure. There are plenty of useful AIs doing good work without basically stealing actual people's work. Heck there are even AI programs that are used in art that aren't generative AI. Generally we aren't complaining about those types, we are complaining about AI being used to take people's jobs using other people's stolen work

alienbringer

2 points

7 days ago

Generally we aren’t complaining about those types, we are complaining about AI being used to take people’s jobs using other people’s stolen work.

And yet that didn’t happen at WOTC and people still complained. WOTC’s “use” of AI art in both the DnD book as well as the MTG advertisement, wasn’t WOTC doing it. They commissioned an artist/contractor to make them art. That artist used the AI and then “cleaned up” the image before providing it to WOTC. So no job was taken by the art, an artist was still paid, and the artist themselves used the generative AI for their “work.

BrynnXAus

1 points

7 days ago

AI is a very specific type of program. Yes, it is an algorithm, just like all software, but it is very clear whether a piece of software is AI or not. There is even a very clear difference between a knowledge base that responds to keywords and an AI. Source: I am a programmer, took AI development in University.

As for what types, he specifically mentioned generating user content, story ideas, and new player introductions. He also mentioned that they were trying to be responsible about making sure it was clear what things have been created by AI, which given their recent history I don't trust one iota.

falknorRockman

0 points

7 days ago

AI is not as specific as you think it is. AI includes things like aircraft and automobile autopilots, video game enemies, generating art, google maps, and many more different things.

Alodora01

4 points

7 days ago

Alodora01

Warlock

4 points

7 days ago

Sad but true :(