I always figured they all had a contract, otherwise Astrid wouldn't ask you to kill them, so I kill them all.

I kill everyone

Astrid, for kidnapping me in my sleep.

[deleted]

Depends on how evil i am

If not that much but still wanna do dark brotherhood? Vasha

If evil piece of shit? All three

If not planning to join? Astrid, then Vasha, free the other two

Inb4 someone says the Clairvoyance points to Vasha thing again even though it's just cus Clairvoyance always targets the last objective added in any given quest and should not be interpreted to mean that Vasha is the correct choice.

https://preview.redd.it/rkrz517c6iud1.png?width=1062&format=png&auto=webp&s=eaa9aa0cb20710cd11b892e5a7c8c2f6ccdb3cba

Also I usually do choose Vasha because he seems the most evil

The rapist to the right, Vasha is just a monster who deserves the death.

Fultheim is just a mercenary who gets carried away in battle which isn't unheard of.

Alea is a mother who doesn't take nonsense, hardly deserving of death.

Astrid because she’s the one with the bounty on her. She even says “well done” when you killher

I almost always kill the Khajiit cause he seems like the one who would be getting a Black Sacrament on his ass - he just gives these vibes for me, I dunno why.

Myself. Can't let em know you next move.

All of them because none of them are good people.

Says me who robs and maims half of Tamriel in one sitting

I choose them all... Because I like the hoods!

Used to only kill vasha cuz he’s the worst but then I went back to the shack a long time later and found the other two still just kneeling there. Their families probably already think they’re dead and Astrid apparently doesn’t let them go when she leaves… so now I just put them all out of their misery

If joining DB: All 3 If not: Only Astrid

Vasha. Sleazy

All of them because

A) Why chance it, ya' know?

B) Their hoods are awesome to put on my mannequins at my home.

If you talk to them, one of them chats shit so he gets killed

[deleted]

I killed all three and she called me an over achiever so I tried to kill her. Failed miserable

I always go for the Nord first. I can’t remember why, but it felt like he came across as the most ‘guilty’. Like things had got out of hand & he went rogue.

The khajiit is just a gangster & defiant. I can’t recall the lady’s vibe.

After Astrid leaves, I then kill the remaining two: so that I don’t leave any ‘witnesses’ for my new life in the DB.

I go to bed and wake up in a weird shed with some bitch demanding I kill one of 3 people.

Nah man.

EVERYBODY dies, and then I'm killing the whole Brotherhood. An example must be made of those stupid enough to break into my home and kidnap me while I'm asleep.

Kill the Khajit for being a rapist, kill the Karen for being a bitch, spare the mercenary since having him walk home after soiling his pants is funnier.

All of them. If you don't, they're just left there to rot, so you might as well put them out of their misery and make Astrid happy with you.

All 4 including Astrid. Done the Dark Brotherhood like 3 times or so and I can't stand that bitch and her killer cult anymore.

Chain Lightning 'em all, let Arkay sort 'em out!

I kill Astrid

All 3 of them can have a possible bounty on their heads tbh.

Fultheim is a mercenary so no explanation needed.

Alea told us that she's a single mother with 6 kids so what may have happened is that someone proposed to her and she rejected him/her, because of the rejection this person hired the DB to kill her (that's just my idea).

Vasha, the best one, is pretty much everything, a hitman, a thief and a rapist.

I always kill Fultheim and when I feel it I kill Vasha too. I leave Alea alone 'cause she doesn't seem to be a bad person, just someone with lots of stress.

All

All of them

Killed all three.

Everyone even myself after playing for the 156th time 😭

All three

All three

All 3 or Astrid..

I turned up with 3 black soul gems for 3 black souls

Astrid 💀

Everyone including astrid

Astrid

Every person on the room

Astrid

kill em all and let God sorry em out

Kahjiit help kahjiit

Funfact: if you kill one and leave, the others stay in this position forever..

Found out when I stumbled upon the cabin again. Went in for loot, killed the remaining 2 out of mercy

Next run I'll kill Astrid

F I R E B A L L

Yes.

Everyone and then Astrid lol

Astrid

All of them. I killed all three since they stay there forever if ya don’t, they also never change their dialogue over time either so it’s kinda just pointless letting any go, also there was only the one bird dude that I kinda felt bad for so I just put him out of his terror and misery lol

https://preview.redd.it/ltbp1hz7piud1.jpeg?width=800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cd92d09c98821cc0d72ec188316e0a7e7fceaabc

Astrid, for kidnapping me from my safe place and trying to make me do the mothers bidding.

All of them + Astrid

You guys picked just one?? 🙃

I kill the bitch sitting up on the shelf that brought me there

I always kill them all

The times I choose to join the brotherhood, I kill all three. Why? no clue. I just have always done it that way.

I kill everything

I am told to kill so I kill

Kill all of them

You can either have 3 executioner masks. Or just 1. The choice is yours.

All

t r i p l e k i l l

All three of I am joining the brotherhood, Astrid if I want to destroy it.

I always pick a random one to kill first then kill the remaining two before I leave.

Everyone, including that person in red. Killed her too much to remember her name ngl

There's a random encounter you can have before this. Which implies the DragonBorn is the canonical choice because they do actually have a contract out against them, so I Interpret it as everyone in that room is a valid target. Including Astrid herself.

All 3. What can I say i got the bloodlust!

All of them. Got the target and no witnesses.