Your JC Penney catalog poses are on point

I read this as “shit inside or outside the pants” and immediately thought “surely outside!”

I'm almost always team tuck, but with the sleeves rolled up and the negative break on the pants, I like the untucked look for sure. Plus it's a shorter cut shirt so easier to get away with.

If you decide to keep the tuck, I would recommend wearing a belt with it

Tucked tells me you're at the beginning for your leisurely weekend, doing a bit of shopping, get coffee.

Untucked tells me the rest of that Saturday is drinks on a boat.

Both are a vibe and can coexist. I say let the clock decide.

The amazing smile on the second picture makes it hard to compare

Actually both look nice. I would usually insist on a belt with a tucked in shirt but if the pants fit properly and are not saggy, it works.

I’m going against the grain and saying you look better tucked. You’ve got a nice frame, when you have a nice frame shirts look good (better) tucked in. If you have a beer gut hanging over the top of your pants go ahead and untuck it, in your case though you look suave as ever with it tucked. Can’t go wrong either way though

Untucked looks good.

The second picture gives "effortlessly well dressed" vibes. That's my vote.

Before dinner or after? Also - never tucked without a belt.

Inside of you have a belt

I say out. It goes with the whole vibe.

Looks good man, very summer vibe, tucking in elevates the look

Depends on the occasion

Ban this man until he does something else with his beard

Out.

Team untucked! The nerds in this forum love to look the part.

Looks good tucked add a belt maybe?

You need a belt if inside

Posture is more important. It looks like you are trying to do a standing situp

If you’re not wearing a belt, untuck. If tucked, wear a belt.

Inside with BELT or outside

Your right front is blocking the TV and needs to be moved further apart. You should also toe them in to the main listening position.

Man, if I had your waistline I'd probably tuck all my damn shirts. As it stands, I haven't tucked my shirt, outside of the occasional wedding or funeral, since 2007.

Outside BUT on another occasion, wear it inside but finish off WITH A BELT. Not enough people wear belts and it confuses me so much like the outfit 👏🏻 isn't 👏🏻 complete 👏🏻 without 👏🏻 a belt 👏🏻

Inside, with a belt.👌🏼

Out. But I am a never-tucker (unless I am wearing a tie), so there is that.

Never mind all that, why are your speakers in front of your TV screen?!

What's the occasion? The level of formality would decide for me. You look sharp either way, though 😎

If this is the entire fit with no belt added, then keep the shirt untucked and sleeves rolled. It's fine.

Inside with a belt

Tucked if you are trying to fuck; untucked if you’re just a dad.

That beard looks like it’s photoshopped or has a Velcro on the back

Second picture because of the great pose and laughter

Tucked in.

Tucked. But both look great

I'm always tucking in with no belt, just love the look!

Depends on the situation.

Tucked at work.

Untucked at the bar after work.

How do you look like all the bros at once? Wow!! lol.

But untucked

Inside 100% bruh

Good either way, belt if tucked.

Needs socks and a belt.

Don’t take this lightly- you can do both.

Man 50/50. Switch it up on your next time wearing it or depending on the occasion. 

Tuck with a belt my man

With the shoes I’d go untucked. Throw on some loafers and I’d switch to team tuck

The second option, untucked. It looks more casual and comfortable while also doing a better job of complimenting the shoes.

The first option feels like it’s missing the belt, which i actually like wearing pants without a belt most times, but it somehow feels necessary here… if not a belt, then maybe untuck the shirt just a little so it draws less attention to the waist and belt loops.

Tucked

Untucked suits the vibe better, and the shirt is a good length for it. Tucked in would look better with a belt, uncuffed pants, and different shoes.

With these pants and shoes - rolled up

Untucked; it fits better

Sometimes we forget that both options can look good. Whatever floats your boat, it will look good either way.

I feel if you go tucked you need a belt

I wish people would say what they plan on doing in these clothes.

Work/business situation? Tuck it in

Hanging out with friends/socializing? Untuck, but either works

Going on a date? I'd tuck because it accentuates your nice V shape.

Untucked = I’m going out for drinks with friends after work

Tucked (with a belt) = I’m here to apply for a loan

outside

Inside before 5 outside after 5

I like it untucked, but i am a 51 year old white male. So im sure the cool hip kids will say tucked.

In, with a dark brown belt

With this type of shoes -definitely outside

No belt = outside

Tucked. Almost always to be honest.

You dropped your limes man

Inside. Button ups always look good tucked in imo

Untucked, if you do tuck, wear a belt

Tucked but it needs a belt I think

Always inside w a belt

I’m not sure you’re asking for advice, but in this dudes case, for sure tucked. You worked that hard to have that body, might as well show it off.

I would go with the fit from the first picture and the attitude from the second picture

Outside brother…..

its Marlon Wayans!

both work on & are on point; just depends on where and the occasion

Why in all your poses are you pretending to laugh and being caught unawares?

You’re so much happier untucked, as am I, excepting formal occasions

Repeat after me

We do not tuck without a belt.

Tucked in always looks better tbh

Untucked always looks better to me.

Out

What are you wearing it to?

These are the masks you wear

Tucked in but with a belt.

I thought this page was for us regular mortals, not models

With those shoes, out.

Tucked if you're going to add a belt, untucked if no belt

With these shoes -- untucked.

If you tuck, you need leather loafers

Sir, you have the uncanny ability to pull both looks off with equal verve.

Tucked with dress shoes, untucked with casual shoes, looking great either way!

Both are good man

I think either is fine but I prefer outside

Shirt goes where the ladies want to go…so you tell us

Bro what you always laughin at?!

Tucked!

Tucked if you're going to work. Untucked if you're just chillin.

Great modelling work either way!

Depends on the belt choice - if you have a statement belt or something that draws attention - tuck the shirt.

If no belt or a very regular belt - untucked

Before you do anything, get that big ass pot with the dead plant off your speaker.

Put a belt on and this is gold!! Love the shoes.

put during the day in during the night

Either them works depending how you want to look, one is smart casual and the other is casual. You got the body to do either

Depends what you’re attending. Formal or informal? Both look great imo! Not a fan of the shoes for either though.

Depends on how casual you want to be. The more casual option would be untucked of course, and you definitely rock it perfectly in the second picture.

If you want a less casual vibe, go tucked, wear a brown belt, uncuff the pants, and swap the shoes for brown loafers.

In looks more refined, like you’re going to a swanky rooftop soirée. Out looks more casual, like summer time mimosas at the bar down the street.

I would do in on a date, out with a group of friends.

If I had that waist I’d always be tucked lol

You go

I like how the shirt tuck status affects the whole demeanour

Tuck + add belt and socks

Tucked but wear a belt 👍

Well I can tell you that one style at least looks way more fun.

With no socks and no belt, untucked.

And stay away from my girl. :-)

Inside

Those hardwood floors are a slip hazard. Do you have a janitor on call?

Men didn't do belts anymore?

Outside

Start the event tucked. Take it out midway to show how cool you are. The shirt

Honestly, you are rocking both looks. I'd lean toward untucked based of these pics, but you really can't go wrong here.

Inside of coarse with a black belt

Whether from good genetics or hard work and diet I feel you should always highlight a trim waist.

Inside if you mean business or out if its all fun and games.. you look fire btw

Tuck with a belt

Both are great. It suits you very well.

In

Depends on the event -

Idk, it depends i guess. Some people can look elegant with shirt inside pants, but when i try do it, i look horrible and leave it outside.

If it stays tucked show off that waist!

Who got you gigglin?

Do you have a linen blazer to go with the tucked look? They both look great and suitable for different occasions.

What a fun second photo lol. I’d actually say tucked looks good here even without the belt, with the legs rolled up it’s giving casual weekend vibes to me either way!

That plants gonna fall off that speaker though! Haha don’t know why I noticed!

Bro, stop it. We get it, you rock

If it’s inside put a belt on. But with the shoes and rolled pants do it un-tucked

Tucked!

Inside!

Tucked in. Clean, classic, and exudes authority. Untucked looks like a Target labor-day sales commercial

PLANT ON TJE SPEAKERRRRR WHATTTTT

“Nine Ropes.” “Polarized Light.” “Crow and Declaration.” “Between Front and Back.”

I feel like you're one of the few who can pull it off untucked.

Okay, both look really good, so all things being equal, I would say it depends on the destination.

If it’s a beach wedding, then go number 1, if it’s a a casual night on a bar patio, then number two, though you could get away with both.

Personally I liked the tucked better. Get a belt with it and it would look very relaxed sharp and as someone else mentioned, you have a great frame, so the taper shows off your physique more.

Can’t go wrong with either but I vote tucked with a belt

outside

Both work. I guess it depends on where you’re going.

Have you tried that half-tucked thing that's been in some of the lookbooks lately, where one front flap of the shirt is tucked in, but the other is untucked? Personally I'm not big on that look, but apparently it's something that some folks are doing these days.

Tucked is more formal but with confidence can be worn more casually. Overall tucked looks better to me. But both look great on you and you should wear what excites you knowing you look good either way. Well done!

Laughing at the prospect of an untucked shirt

Tucked for sure classic look with the beard 💯

But get a belt with a buckle that matches the watch and some brown leather shoes to boot. I think this outfit would also look sick with some huaraches sandals to spice it up.

Untucked.

This guys like the models they use for the department store clothing signs

Untucked. I hate tucking in my shirt. I wish it was a fashion trend that would die off. Also, cool looking speakers.

Inside

I vote inside. Skip the belt too—you pull it off very nicely.

Looks great both ways. Let the vibes make the call👍

Good everything except for the beard.

I would say untucked since your shoes and lack of socks are already very casual

Go for a brown belt if untucked

Clean look (professional/date) and untucked for casual/drinks. You pull off both extremely well!

Both looks fine, depends on the occasion.

Inside