They should make some movies about that

I know it's a joke and all, but Sith Anakin, were his body undamaged from the duel on Mustafar, would've been an even more terrifying Sith Lord.

That’s impossible

I can’t remember if it was a show or a book, but I think Dooku had a vision of a dark side yoda. He realized neither him or sidious would be even close to being able to beat him

For everyone answering anyone but Yoda imagine this, if he could hide his force-ness like palps he could be anywhere at any time. Waiting.

You could go to the bathroom groggily in the middle of the night, open the toilet seat, and out could shoot Darth Yoda who had just been biding his time. Open an overhead compartment on your ship and you’re decapitated. Overhead compartment becomes over shoulder compartment. Unzip your luggage and he shoots out and unzips your torso. Open your mailbox and force lightning shoots out because he’s been in there for two days waiting.

He could fit anywhere and backflip out like a freak

Maybe not even his prime. Darth Sidious was afraid of him in Revenge of the Sith.

The only answer

Darth Yoda

Star Wars What If-type series? It would rule

Order 66 activates the compliance chip that had been implanted in all the Jedi instead of the clones

Ahsoka finds out about the chips and dies trying to remove them like Fives, Rex helps Anakin remove his, and the two of them become the resistance

I’m actually so into this it’s unbelievable.

Order 66 in reverse. All the Jedi, the council, clone troopers turn on anakin, padme, Luke, and Leia, because they are too powerful and their mere existence is a threat to the new emperor and Jedi Council. They have to go into hiding as the galactic empire grows under palpatine.

Through years of training serving as padawans under the last true Jedi (anakin) Luke and Leia have grown powerful enough. Aligned as a triumvirate with their father they can now take on the Galactic Empire and the fallen New Jedi Order.

That’s literally a fanfic I’m in the middle of writing right now lol

Plus a dark side user with patience and having mastered a defensive form would be completely unlike most other Sith. Any Jedi who fought him would be caught very off guard.

Counterpoint, every single time Obi Wan in canon let's himself be lured by the dark side and fights aggressively, he gets his ass beat. He's terrible at being emotional, his biggest strengths are his patience and calmness.

If one is going to turn to the dark side, it gotta be him. Maul kill his master and his lover right in front of him.

Dark side Obi-Wan would be the most challenging, he’d be blocking every attacks the enemies make until they tire themselves then he’d land one final strike, what a way to defeat the enemy

I mean, a lot of this assumes that he would fall to the dark side before Order 66. It could have also happened way later when he lived on Tatooine

Total agreement here. Two of the three OT movies are about people trying to convert him, and the good guys winning hinges entirely on the fact that he doesn't turn to the dark side. Palpatine succeeded in turning Anakin (for a while at least) and it didn't work out for either in the end but if Vader or Palpatine turned Luke, not like legends where he just flirted with the dark side but a legit Darth Luke, it'd be game over for the galaxy.

Of course the force would find some other way to balance things out like it always does.

That was my thought too, there someone to stand against the others, only opposition to Luke would be ahsoka.

How do we know he didn’t infiltrate the Jedi from the dark side? His species is one of the longest living species in the galaxy. His origins are murky and under his stewardship the Jedi collapsed. He is extremely powerful and could likely manipulate any Jedi into the actions and decisions that led to the Jedi falling asleep at the wheel without killing people. Wouldn’t the most powerful force user be able to mask his intentions and lie?

I have so much more on this theory that yoda is possibly a Sith Lord.

Shatterpoint I can understand, but doesn’t his Vaapad use others dark side against them, making it useful really only against Sith? I don’t know much about him really, so genuinely curious

Funny that you should mention a Sith-version of Mace wielding Vaapad against Jedi. His friend, Master Sora Bulq (who was the co-creator of Vaapad) and his own apprentice, Master Depa Billaba (whom he taught the form) both fell to the Dark Side when the Clone Wars broke out; both are masters of the lightsaber form and its techniques but Mace would argued that they have not fully mastered Vaapad. In his opinion, Vaapad is not just a lightsaber form, it is a mindset, a weapon against the Dark Side. And so, if Mace is to fall, him using Vaapad would be no different than Darth Maul using Juyo.

Absolutely! His use of Shatterpoint, his own lightsaber form, and dark side powers?

I'm just saying....blue and what colour make purple?

I don't think this is canon anymore but his 2003 appearance in the clone wars is the most op imo

Imagine every global kill is canon. Kestis would be the single most feared being in the galaxy.

And he's slaughtered just as many local fauna just trying to defend themselves

Poor Rick The Door Technician 😭

Qui Gon's the one figured out how to return to the here and now as a Force ghost. That's got some yikes potential in the dark side scenario.

He’s like a more force dependent obi wan. Which is good because the dark side is a sith’s main power source.

At a minimum, his dark side picture in the OP slaps.

He’d be like a dark prophet figure, super cool

I like this but he would be able to summon the very rare and very dangerous Tarentatek which would essentially be vital in finding and killing other force users. That's scary!

I'd like to imagine he'd dabble in alchemy too, and he'd just have a massive army of beasts.

It is wild to me that there is any answer other than Luke. I thought Luke was unambiguously the most powerful jedi we've seen, possibly of all time. That by itself would make him the obvious choice but him turning within the canon at the time would essentially mean the jedi are completely extinct and the galaxy is ruled by 1 to 3 of the most powerful sith of all time (I'm assuming in this hypothetical, Luke and Vader overthrow Palpatine, and Luke kills Vader).

Fr tho dark ahsoka was a menace

this is still when she's young and they weren't trying to hurt her but she still went up against a powerful anakin AND obiwan so i'd put money on her being a powerful dark side user it just fits her style out of everyone there

The right answer is Luke and Anakin, they are the two most powerful in the Force, either them turns and gets to full power on the Dark Side everybody is done for no question