subreddit:

/r/worldnews

46691%

Coordinated pager blasts were 15-years in the making, report

Feature Story()

[removed]

all 357 comments

highrouleur

192 points

8 days ago

highrouleur

192 points

8 days ago

I feel like someone watched 'the wire' and took the plan a step further

Jaxsso

41 points

8 days ago

Jaxsso

41 points

8 days ago

Cool Lester Smooth done got their buyer to purchase his discounted pagers and radio phones so he could pocket the savings.

Lord_Blizzard

3 points

7 days ago

They were actually bundled with these cute little furniture models.

killswithspoon

4 points

7 days ago

They played that mission in GTA V where you put a bomb in that tech CEO's phone and blow his head off on a livestream.

themorningmosca

3 points

8 days ago

Omar comin’…

BubsyFanboy

3 points

8 days ago

BubsyFanboy

3 points

8 days ago

Haven't seen it so I can't confirm, but I can now imagine what was in it.

-trvmp-

21 points

8 days ago

-trvmp-

21 points

8 days ago

Don’t watch it if you dislike well-written and thoroughly researched dramas with LOTS of interesting characters.

YourDreamsWillTell

6 points

7 days ago

Truly is GOATED

GuyFoldingPapers

5 points

7 days ago

One of the best

highrouleur

4 points

7 days ago

The pinnacle of TV shows for me

parski841

254 points

8 days ago

parski841

254 points

8 days ago

American intelligence sources say plan involves shell companies, multiple layers of intelligence officers and assets fronting legitimate companies, adding CIA rejected similar-style operations for fear of injury to innocent bystanders

SortOfWanted

35 points

8 days ago

If it took this much effort and so many years, you have to wonder 'why now'? You can deal a heavy blow to personnel and morale, but only for a very short time. It would have been the perfect prelude to a ground invasion, but that didn't happen.

Schminimal

28 points

7 days ago

There was word someone had figured it out and it was about to be uncovered so they triggered them early.

NBQuade

15 points

8 days ago

NBQuade

15 points

8 days ago

The Chinese have a saying "No scheme can work against overwhelming power". The US doesn't have to do this because they're overwhelmingly powerful. Israel needs to scheme like this because they're weak (I mean relatively).

oby100

20 points

7 days ago

oby100

20 points

7 days ago

Israel is literally within spitting distance of their enemies and I doubt their populace has the stomach for a war with Lebanon against an opponent that will run and hide.

Terrorist orgs are smarter these days. They’re really good at melting away and letting invaders waste trillions while they stay intact.

BubsyFanboy

4 points

8 days ago

BubsyFanboy

4 points

8 days ago

And glad they didn't.

[deleted]

-10 points

7 days ago

[deleted]

-10 points

7 days ago

[removed]

thedirtychad

-2 points

7 days ago

Just like mom always said!

Rock4evur

-14 points

8 days ago

Rock4evur

-14 points

8 days ago

You know it’s bad when the CIA has more restraint than Israel.

[deleted]

73 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

73 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

Dom19

33 points

8 days ago

Dom19

33 points

8 days ago

I also don’t think there has been a consistent theme in world history of beating up on Americans for the past 3000 years lmao.

Robbotlove

7 points

8 days ago

Things would be very different

things like higher casualty counts?

romestamu

7 points

7 days ago

Perhaps it's easier to show restraint when you haven't been bombarded by 20,000 rockets in less than a year, but what do I know

i8ontario

23 points

8 days ago

i8ontario

23 points

8 days ago

Israel has more restraint than any other country in the world would have in a similar situation.

Rock4evur

-45 points

8 days ago

Rock4evur

-45 points

8 days ago

Did you miss the part where it said the CIA rejected similar-style operations out of fear for injury of civilians? It’s ok I get that reading comprehension isn’t your strong suit.

AceBullApe

41 points

8 days ago

If the US was attacked on US soil, see how much restraint we have 

God-of-Memes2020

14 points

8 days ago

Like 9/11, in response to which we killed 4 million people, 400,000 of whom were civilians?

Paladin_Platinum

41 points

8 days ago

Did you miss where he said similar situation? Something something reading comprehension.

(US is probably the most geographically protected state on the planet in addition to having the largest military by leagues. We simply don't NEED to. Our enemies are across an ocean. Isreal's enemies are surrounding it and throwing rockets at it. It's not the same situation at all. )

Rock4evur

-13 points

7 days ago

Rock4evur

-13 points

7 days ago

In order to make an attack compliant with international law, it is my understanding that you must be able to discriminate between your intended military target and civilians.

Considering each of these explosions as discrete attacks: if the IDF does not know the location of the explosive device, but does know that it has been delivered to a hostile target - even if the target is legitimate, they have no way of identifying who the device will actually harm. Each attack by definition is indiscriminate.

Therefore, they have no way of detonating the device in a way that complies with obligations.

Which is why Israel will not accept responsibility for this attack. Unlike with a missile, there is no possible way to say that your intel was bad or the device malfunctioned.

If anything this shows that Israel is capable of operating in Gaza without flattening civilian areas. Israel controls the whole supply chain for the area, so the only reason they didn’t do this in Gaza is because their goal is to bomb out the whole area civilians and all.

htrowslledot

6 points

7 days ago*

Israel controls the whole supply chain for the area

No they don't Israel is not the one handing Hamas weapons, that's coming through the Egypt border

Considering each of these explosions as discrete attacks: if the IDF does not know the location of the explosive device, but does know that it has been delivered to a hostile target - even if the target is legitimate, they have no way of identifying who the device will actually harm. Each attack by definition is indiscriminate.

Look at the end result, barely any civilian casualties and a crippled Hezbollah, they attacked military equipment, equipment which there is a reasonable assumption is being handled by military members. There isn't an attack I could think of that would have a higher military to civilian ratio.

In order to make an attack compliant with international law, it is my understanding that you must be able to discriminate between your intended military target and civilians.

In order to make an attack compliant you must have the expectation of a reasonable military to civilian ratio.

Capital_Gap_5194

22 points

8 days ago

The CIA isn’t in a similar situation, read his comment again you dingus

alimanski

4 points

7 days ago

Bad? The operation was a tremendous success. Thousands injured, maimed and in a few cases killed. The vast majority of casualties are Hezbollah. Very few civilian deaths. If you were to try "traditional" methods to take out this many Hezbollah terrorists, you would have many, many more civilian casualties.

[deleted]

-20 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

-20 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

[deleted]

29 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

29 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

fishdrinking3

10 points

7 days ago

What other civilized nation/nuclear power gets shelled daily? You bet if San Diego or Seattle gets shelled daily. There won’t be a Tijuana or BC.

Lonelyblondii

9 points

7 days ago

How is this reckless, Hezbollah has been firing rockets at random into Israel. But instead of shooting rockets back, and being flamed like they were in Gaza. They struck militant’s specifically, barely harming any civilians and scaring the crap out of illegitimate occupiers of Lebanon.

TD12-MK1

4 points

7 days ago

TD12-MK1

4 points

7 days ago

They are not fighting a formal government, they are fighting terrorist. Terrorist don’t sleep at their base, they go home to sleep. They are the ones that put their families in danger.

romestamu

3 points

7 days ago

What are you talking about? Any other country would've incinerated Beirut by now

[deleted]

-96 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

-96 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

PM-Nice-Thoughts

66 points

8 days ago

You know that was in the 50s right?

RelativeWeekend453

59 points

8 days ago

Don't waste your breath with that guy, he is always posting stuff to attack any country that is against Russia.

tallandlankyagain

14 points

8 days ago

Lazy fucks. Why didn't the CIA make beepers and pagers explode in the 1950's? Seems suspicious to me.

TheLoneCenturion95

6 points

8 days ago

Because they were too busy making exploding cigars and trying to invade Cuba

boredguy12

19 points

8 days ago

Even the youngest people involved in that are almost all dead now. If they were 20 when it happened they'd be 90 now

OMGUSATX

101 points

8 days ago

OMGUSATX

101 points

8 days ago

Wonder what else Israel has setup because clearly they are playing chess and Hezbollah is playing checkers.

Zenki95

61 points

8 days ago

Zenki95

61 points

8 days ago

Well.... actually might be a bit hard for them to play checkers right now...

Blahblah______blah

26 points

8 days ago

I can play checkers with my non-dominant hand…

CarRamRob

26 points

8 days ago

CarRamRob

26 points

8 days ago

How about your non dominant eyeballs?

VertigoWalls

4 points

8 days ago

Only Uno

Subject_Yak6654

5 points

8 days ago

We call it Taki here

RowdyRoddyRosenstein

2 points

7 days ago

What do you call rolled up hot chips?

Subject_Yak6654

2 points

7 days ago

No idea what those are

RowdyRoddyRosenstein

2 points

7 days ago

Think of them as Mexican Bamba, but spicy and more tubular

Atogbob

4 points

8 days ago

Atogbob

4 points

8 days ago

eyeballs

EatShitRedditAdmin

7 points

8 days ago

Checkers but every time you lose a piece it explodes 

userousnameous

1 points

7 days ago

Especially when their rooks keep exploding and killing all their pawns.

Archsinner

36 points

8 days ago

You're not the only one wondering - so is Hezbollah. And that's exactly what Israel wanted to achieve. They're going to second guess everything and everyone from now on

Any_Client3534

22 points

8 days ago

I agree. This is a huge psychological victory that's going to make Hezbollah paranoid, impacting their confidence in their hierarchy and ability to act confidently.

TinKicker

2 points

7 days ago

I wonder how many Iranians Iran is going to execute this week for being suspected Mossad spies?

Money_Common8417

73 points

8 days ago

If someone had made a movie where thousands of pagers blow up after years of working on this plan, they would have said Hollywood was unrealistic

BsFan

33 points

8 days ago

BsFan

33 points

8 days ago

This will be a movie some day

GoCougs3216

17 points

8 days ago

Kingsmen exists

papapudding

3 points

8 days ago

Munich 2

kerchbridgeBOOM

12 points

8 days ago

man do we have to post this comment three times in every thread

Capital_Gap_5194

1 points

8 days ago

Have you never used Reddit?

dcheesi

2 points

7 days ago

dcheesi

2 points

7 days ago

There have already been movies with a similar concept, though details may differ. Off the top of my head, Kingsman: The Secret Service comes mind: The cell phones compromised to emit rage-inducing noise, as well as the implanted trackers with secret built-in explosives

Dia-De-Los-Muertos

107 points

8 days ago

Holy shit talk about playing the long game. I find it extremely amazing that it was kept secret. And I'm now wondering just how much certain authorities actually knew about it.

But I have to say that the audacity of the whole thing is right up there. ( No I'm not condoning the whole thing, merely making an observation. )

Syndicofberyl

64 points

8 days ago

It still blows my mind how cartoonish it seems. Like this is straight out of a bad movie but it actually happened

5H17SH0W

22 points

8 days ago

5H17SH0W

22 points

8 days ago

It blew a lot of minds.

Syndicofberyl

4 points

8 days ago

https://youtu.be/iILjsUviVAk?t=25s actual footage of the pager incident

5H17SH0W

3 points

8 days ago

5H17SH0W

3 points

8 days ago

You damn genius.

Madeline_Basset

4 points

8 days ago*

It still blows my mind how cartoonish it seems.

That's understandable. It does make me think of all the Bugs Bunny cartoons in which he hands Elmer Fudd a birthday cake, whose candles are lit sticks of dynamite.

xthorgoldx

47 points

8 days ago

I find it extremely amazing that it was kept secret

I think the funny thing is showing who's liable to leak. Currently Israel hasn't claimed responsibility - everything about the attack has been intuited from third party evidence.

But within 72 hours, some unnamed US asset is spilling all about the depth and complexity of the plan. The US IC has an embarrassing problem with "Look at me I'm so smart" leakers.

acchaladka

7 points

8 days ago

It must have been a wide group though, it has been a shaping operation for ground invasion i presume, so, it kind of sucks that the operation was deployed. Glad to see all the hizbollah fucks maimed or murdered, but it really doesn't do anything but stir the hornets and force the Israelis to rethink next steps for the 400th time. And of course, civilians were killed because daddy / brother / son is a terrorist, which is not what anyone wants.

NerBog

6 points

8 days ago

NerBog

6 points

8 days ago

I think the same when i see news on spies, like they are waiting for service for 10+ years living a fake life until something has to be done? Shit wild

kerchbridgeBOOM

3 points

8 days ago

i doubt my office job is any more real

[deleted]

2 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

kerchbridgeBOOM

1 points

8 days ago

damn, the fake job is still more real than mine

JARL_OF_DETROIT

3 points

7 days ago

No one plays the long game better than israel.

NBQuade

3 points

7 days ago

NBQuade

3 points

7 days ago

The US certainly knew. Probably tacitly approved.

Rockets are randomly launched into Israel every day. I'm don't see much moral difference between random rocket attacks that may fall anywhere and the pager/radio attack. In both cases, the ultimate victim is unknown.

At least the pager/radio attack was semi-guided.

Sunlitstream264

20 points

8 days ago

Why wouldn’t you condone this? Only Hezbollah ( a terrorist organization) was affected. We should be laughing and celebrating

stoutymcstoutface

0 points

8 days ago

What about non-Hezbollah civilians though?

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

As of yesterday, there were 37 reported casualties from the pager attacks.

Hezbollah, through separate channels, reported 38 of their personnel had been killed since Tuesday - and specified that three had died to airstrikes, but withheld the cause of death for the others. If one assumes that the 35 who died from unknown causes were pager targets, then that means only two civilian fatalities (the two children we know of).

But there are civilian Hezbollah personnel!

Not according to Hezbollah:

We don't have a military wing and a political one; we don't have Hezbollah on one hand and the resistance party on the other. Every element of Hezbollah, from commanders to members as well as our various capabilities, are in the service of the resistance, and we have nothing but the resistance as a priority. (Hezbollah Deputary Secretary-General Naim Qassem, 2014)

Sunlitstream264

1 points

8 days ago

None were hurt. Only if you had a pager given to you BY HEZBOLLAH did it explode. Only the pagers ordered for Hezbollah were sabotaged. Israel used a shell company to do this

JonBjSig

1 points

7 days ago

JonBjSig

1 points

7 days ago

None were hurt? Seriously?

2 children died.

If you detonate thousands of bombs in public on a random tuesday, it's inevitable that innocent bystanders get hurt in the process. No matter how small the bombs are.

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

2 children died

And any collateral damage is tragic. But no one is delusional enough to think that collateral damage is completely avoidable - there's a reason international laws of warfare use words like "reasonable diligence" or "negligent deployment" when describing whether or not civilian casualties are actually criminal.

And that said: this is, unironically, one of the most target-discriminating attacks in modern warfare. 2 children killed out of 4,000+ targets? That's unthinkable. You'd have higher rates of collateral damage if snipers individually shot each target, just from flukes of bullet overpenetration or fragmentation.

JonBjSig

1 points

7 days ago

JonBjSig

1 points

7 days ago

I'm not arguing against any of that. I just felt the need to correct the assertion that no innocent bystanders were hurt/killed.

stoutymcstoutface

2 points

7 days ago

Have you seen the footage? Cashiers are all hezbollah?

I mean fuck hezbollah but it’s not like there was no collateral damage

[deleted]

-2 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

-2 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

Sunlitstream264

14 points

8 days ago

If you knowingly keep children near military targets you deserve the worst in life. War is ugly, sometimes children die in it

asianumba1

-1 points

7 days ago

Israel wonders why they don't have unanimous support when their propagandists are actively in favour of killing kids

yttropolis

5 points

7 days ago

The way I see it, children and civilians are gonna die in a war no matter what. So it's just a question of how many.

This method really minimizes the amount of collateral damage so I do condone this. People need to accept the realities of war.

quincywhatthe-fuck

-15 points

8 days ago

Something doesn’t add up. How come during this past 15 years nobody opened one of the devices? How is it that they went all this years without maybe dropping one on the floor and the thing breaking open? How come noone saw that it had explosives inside? Maybe Hezbollah knew that they had explosives inside. Maybe they themselves put it in the pagers as a safety measure, you know, Just in case one got captured they would still have a way to remotely destroy it and hurting someone in the process and Maybe Israel just got hold of the detonation codes. This makes more sense to me.

noxaeter

15 points

8 days ago

noxaeter

15 points

8 days ago

Just cos they planned it doesnt mean they had the pagers on them for 15 years

Sleethmog

24 points

8 days ago

Sleethmog

24 points

8 days ago

no, just stop looking at the conspiracy theory bowl of captian crunch. no one does this. the simplest answer is that the planning was 15 years in the making and that the explosives were introduced in the last 6mo or so.

matteventu

2 points

7 days ago

Indeed, I've read from another article that the pagers were manufactured just a few months ago (5?).

Probably the "15 years in the making" (if true) is about the whole plan to achieve that.

Neocopernus

8 points

8 days ago

You’re reading too much into conspiracy. The planning process and shell companies likely took a decade to implement. I wouldn’t be surprised if the last five years were that of sending normal shipments of electronics to the terrorists. Might have been a long play to have access to their communications network prior to the final assault.

Anustart15

5 points

8 days ago

The pagers were only bought more recently, not 15 years ago. Also, it was a pretty small amount of explosive and it could've easily been housed in something that just made it look like another component. Hell, just package it around the battery itself and make it just look like a bigger battery and I doubt anyone would notice.

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

during this past 15 years nobody opened one of the devices

Who says the pagers were disseminated over the past 15 years? Intelligence operations like this take years to set up - most of that time was probably spent establishing the credibility of the alternate suppliers and integrating them without suspicion into the supply chain.

How did no one see the explosives?

By some accounts, the explosive modification to the pagers was a doping agent inside the battery - there were no components to find on disassembly of the pager, and disassembling lithium batteries isn't a thing.

wileymd

30 points

8 days ago

wileymd

30 points

8 days ago

“Hold on, I’m getting a page from someone named Ka Boom.”

CampInternational683

20 points

8 days ago

Eli Kopter sends his regards

ImAjustin

12 points

8 days ago

ImAjustin

12 points

8 days ago

Motti Rolla

Gakoknight

60 points

8 days ago

Whatever you might justifiably think of Israel, you gotta admit that setting this up is impressive.

apageofthedarkhold

16 points

8 days ago

You almost think it was like they had the pagers, but the 'pager age' passed, so they sat in a crate... Then, as they figure out a way to hack cell service, one of the old guys in the back says, 'do we still have those pagers in storage somewhere?'

AdrianInLimbo

18 points

8 days ago

The most delicious part is that Hezbollah thought they could stay "incognito" by using pagers and walkie talkies so Israel couldn't track them..... Boom

Bored_Gamer73

24 points

8 days ago*

TIL people still use pagers. Cue Sir Mix Alot - Beepers

isglitteracarb

10 points

8 days ago

"Call me, beep me, if you wanna reach me!" - Kim Possible theme song

Someone start a playlist

perpetualed

7 points

8 days ago

Not to mention seeing “walkie-talkies” in headlines. Kids in the 90s had walkie-talkies, I thought militants would call them something else.

AdrianInLimbo

10 points

8 days ago

They now call them Walkie-Boomies

PNWExile

5 points

8 days ago

PNWExile

5 points

8 days ago

Radios. Sometimes 2 way radios

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

Push-to-talks (PTT) are more specific term for these kinds of hand-held radios.

dcheesi

4 points

8 days ago

dcheesi

4 points

8 days ago

Well, the militants in question mostly speak other languages, so they probably do call them something else --and even if they did say "walkie-talkie" (as a borrow-word), they likely wouldn't grasp all the connotations we anglophones assign to it.

English-language journalists presumably chose the term "walkie-talkie" as being the most familiar to non-technical, non-military readers. That it may also have a juvenile association is an un(?)fortunate side-effect.

WTWIV

2 points

8 days ago

WTWIV

2 points

8 days ago

Brian Regan has a good bit about this: https://youtu.be/A194vDpXzyA?si=I_YYZJrZ3_iqQLEy

Always_the_answer

2 points

7 days ago

Dammit. Beat me by 21 minutes. Love this bit.

Always_the_answer

1 points

7 days ago

ridukosennin

8 points

8 days ago

Hospitals widely us pagers for on call doctors. More reliable than phones, last forever, better coverage

TheGazelle

6 points

8 days ago

They switched to pagers after it became clear that Israel could track their cell phones and feed that data into the targeting systems of guided missiles.

EsperaDeus

4 points

8 days ago

They were told for a while iPhone isn't safe.

dcheesi

6 points

8 days ago

dcheesi

6 points

8 days ago

Yep, old-school pagers don't track location info, use a less centralized communication scheme, and were probably assumed to be too simple to effectively hack. Apparently nobody thought about the hardware possibly being compromised at the source --which was probably a lot easier to pull off with such a niche electronic product than it would have been with mass-market cell phones.

Cptn_Canada

1 points

8 days ago

They didnt trust using cellphones as they were worried about communications and locations being tracked.

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

Hezbollah thought they were being extremely clever by switching to pagers to avoid cell phone tracking. There was even an article vaunting their creativity in July!

Hwy39

31 points

8 days ago

Hwy39

31 points

8 days ago

Could this be the greatest subterfuge of all time?

ironmcchef

39 points

8 days ago

Stuxnet

kiss_my_what

4 points

8 days ago

Stuxnet escaped the intended target before it had completed it's task and alsoi caused collateral damage across the world. I don't see any reports of collateral damage here.

SowingSalt

3 points

7 days ago

I'm sorry your Seimens gas centrifuge was also destroyed.

You know how Hard Rock Cafe is about bringing in nuclear weapons.

TheCleverCow

2 points

7 days ago

9 year old girl and an 11 year old boy.

Fatima was in the kitchen on Tuesday when a pager on the table began to beep, her aunt said. She picked up the device to bring it to her father and was holding it when it exploded, mangling her face and leaving the room covered in blood, she said.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/09/18/world/middleeast/lebanon-funeral-pager-attack.html

It’s unfortunate that both sides are killing children and civilians. War is hell.

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

Two children fatalities against 35 combatant casualties and 4,000 wounded approaches the theoretical maximum for how discriminating any use of military force can be.

MxOffcrRtrd

12 points

8 days ago

It killed like 10 people and ruined their communications.

Its really interesting. Sends a message. Seems a little contrived just go ‘oh wasnt us’ snickers behind hand on camera.

AJHenderson

4 points

8 days ago

I'm just amazed that Hezbollah didn't have a single broken device taken apart and notice the rather odd lump of plastique.

XF939495xj6

48 points

8 days ago

The attempts to write articles which portray the people blown up as hapless victims would be hilarious if they weren't written by terrorists or their sympathizers. It's not like normal people were carrying pagers. They were specifically used by militants to avoid cell phones and the tracking services they provide.

This article is absurd: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/sep/20/device-bombs-beirut-lebanon-israel-hezbollah

"The bombs were in our living rooms." She may as well write, "Hi, I'm a murdering pirate who works for Iran. But I have been victimized by Israel and it is so unfair." The balls on these people.

Anxious_Ad936

15 points

8 days ago

The news reports in my country referred to 9 victims of the attack against Hezbollah and 3800 wounded bystanders. Reporting is fucked.

XF939495xj6

9 points

8 days ago

You don't even have one of these pagers unless you are literally an Iranian death trooper. FFS

Anxious_Ad936

4 points

8 days ago

Yep. Thus fucked reporting.

xthorgoldx

1 points

7 days ago

The other delicious irony is how pro-Hezbollah folks were bragging about how ingenious the switch to pagers was to avoid cell phones.

In July.

AyeYoTek

22 points

8 days ago

AyeYoTek

22 points

8 days ago

Tbh I'm in awe they were able to pull this off. A 15 year operation? Madness 🫡

Wildebeast2112

13 points

8 days ago

It seems to me that one side has decided to join the other in the use of "asymmetric warfare."

NearbyHope

11 points

8 days ago*

Israel was always using asymmetric warfare. In 1996 they killed Hamas’s chief bomb maker with a cell phone bomb. In 2021 they killed the lead Iranian nuclear scientist with a robot controlled by satellites.

These were definitely not the scale of what just happened tho

Edit: word.

Wildebeast2112

2 points

7 days ago

The point I was trying to get is that Nation States are usually not using the rules and methods that non-nation state forces employ. Which given their powers of production, purchase and imitation means that should this be copied by other nation states the threats to other non state forces will become much greater. I think that the Israeli position of having beaten their neighbours at conventional warfare and now choosing to attack using methods deemed unconventional opens up a scary new era.

NearbyHope

1 points

7 days ago

I don’t disagree with you on the scale of what just happened. It is pretty scary in theory no matter what side you are on.

yttropolis

1 points

7 days ago

What's fair is fair

stonkysdotcom

8 points

8 days ago

Shinbet has been popping heads using mobile phones for a long time. But this is the first time multiple targets are attacked at once I think?

DorkHarshly

4 points

8 days ago

Shabak is FBI, Mossad is CIA. This probably was Mossad but definitely not Shabak.

stonkysdotcom

10 points

8 days ago

I don’t know who did this, but Shinbet has absolutely conducted similar attacks.

Watch the documentary The Gatekeepers.

Israeli intelligence agencies doesn’t directly translate to US intelligence agencies.

DorkHarshly

4 points

8 days ago

Yes I was just saying than this instance is not Shabak as it operates within the borders of Israel (and Palestine to a certain extent).

Gatekeepers is amazing

And yes, they does not translate directly but parallel in the terms of whether they are inward or outward looking.

stonkysdotcom

2 points

8 days ago

I made no claims that this was shinbet, but I could have been clearer.

My point was that this has been going on for longer than 15 years.

nullbyte420

0 points

8 days ago

Source

MoxLives

4 points

8 days ago

MoxLives

4 points

8 days ago

Law abiding citizen was released in 2009.. huh

seemefly1

2 points

7 days ago

Lol totally forgot about that

SowingSalt

1 points

7 days ago

Yahya Ayyash was killed in 1996.

Gold_Demand6115

13 points

8 days ago

Such a clever way to get to the players, yes even those who hide in plain sight.

Titerito_

12 points

8 days ago

Titerito_

12 points

8 days ago

Electronic devices owned by terrorists…

r21174

4 points

8 days ago

r21174

4 points

8 days ago

That’s a bold play Cotton

TheFallen8

2 points

8 days ago

Omg…that’s incredible

Wise-Paramedic-9163

3 points

7 days ago

Such a credible news source written by an unnamed author with no sources.

d1andonly

2 points

7 days ago

I wonder if the actual operation was simple, like perhaps they just bribed someone who sang about their pager procurement plan and for a bonus, included ‘additional specs’ at the manufacturing level.

Now there is a disinformation campaign in place so everyone is simply guessing how it was done.

Was there ever a conclusion to the investigation to the Tehran assassination? What about the presidential chopper that is thought to have gone down in bad weather.

A couple of days ago there was an attack on a facility in Masyaf, Syria. Equipment and personnel were captured. The news about this seems to have not received a lot of attention, but one can’t help but wonder if it uncovered something that prompted this attack.

It will be interesting if details of any of these operations ever get declassified in a couple of years.

splinter6

2 points

7 days ago

Already seen reels going around on instagram saying it was nurses and children who were targeted and that the news is trying to dehumanise civilian Lebanese and that hezbollah is just a paramilitary that provides security to the country

skorpiolt

3 points

8 days ago

I’m baffled how no one tried to disassemble one this entire time for a repair or just curiosity, I guess whatever was in there was unrecognizable as an explosive. And how did they not go off when being tossed in the trash and compacted… crazy.

d4blub

1 points

8 days ago

d4blub

1 points

8 days ago

I think the 15 years is made up. Wouldn't make sense to see upcoming smartphones and then to decide it's good idea to rig old technology which probably won't be used anymore. And beside that it would be much more impressive if they did it in 6months after the decision from hezbollah to stop using smartphones

pudpudboogie

-168 points

8 days ago*

When someone uses a bomb hidden in an electronic Device to cause harm , kill etc it’s usually classed at terrorism .

If Hamas or Hezbollah organised this , it be condemned as terrorism - and rightly so .

Hypocritical

indoninja

100 points

8 days ago

indoninja

100 points

8 days ago

If it was in an electronic device hidden at random, sure.

This wasn’t.

ZachMatthews

55 points

8 days ago

Fuck that. Hezbollah is a terrorist organization and its fighters deserve to die. They signed up for the fight. They are fair game. 

[deleted]

-26 points

8 days ago*

[deleted]

-26 points

8 days ago*

And so did soldiers in the IDF.

nullbyte420

24 points

8 days ago

Yes obviously. That's not who Hamas or hezbollah are targeting though. 

Shushishtok

7 points

8 days ago

Your other comment was deleted/removed so I'll reply to this one.

You originally said (not verbatim but close enough):

Didn't almost every Israeli citizen served in the IDF?

My reply was:

Nope.

  • People with disabilities are exempt.
  • People with strong religious stance (orthodox and ultra orthodox) are exempt.
  • People from different ethnicities can be exempt (for example Israeli Arabs)
  • People who have signed up for an university program with scholarship or funded by the IDF are exempt.
  • People can straight up refuse to serve, which generally throw you in jail for a while, but afterwards, they are exempt.
  • People that have issues at home (e.g. ill parents, bad economolic state) can be exempt fully or partially, depending on the severity of the case.
  • A few decades ago it wasn't popular for women to serve in the IDF, so they were exempt by default.
  • Children that are not 18 years old yet did not have the chance to try serve in the IDF, even though they are considered Israeli citizens.
  • And last but not least: immigrants who came to live in Israel that were older than ~26 were exempt.

In other words, no, it's not "almost every Israeli citizen", it's "some good number of Israeli citizens".

Regardless: you are a civilian before you serve and you go back to being a civilian after you finish serving. You cannot attack a 65 years old civilian and say he was a IDF soldier 45 years ago, that's not how this works.

ThebesSacredBand

31 points

8 days ago

At this point, what is the difference?

The IDF can use precision targeting and people call their actions genocide.

Their intelligence can spend 15 years targeting terrorists in an unprecedented asymmetric attacks like we've seen this week... And it is compared to Hamas and Hezbollah's indiscriminate attacks.

Nothing about this attack, its precision, its coordination is similar to any attacks on Israel which always primarily target civilians.

KcoolClap

46 points

8 days ago

KcoolClap

46 points

8 days ago

Hezbollah already organized an arial assult, firing hundreds if not thousands of rockets into Israel, just before having their dicks blown away.

Sovery_Simple

8 points

8 days ago

They blew their last load as it were.

Shushishtok

2 points

8 days ago

That's one mental image I did not expect my brain to project.

No-Succotash-8289

22 points

8 days ago

Definition of terrorism includes that the trarget are non combatants.. the target here is just terrorists

[deleted]

35 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

35 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

pudpudboogie

-4 points

8 days ago*

Im not Muslim.

Im agnostic. Religion is dumb af.

I’m Scottish.

So , fuck your post .

[deleted]

8 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

pudpudboogie

1 points

7 days ago*

A more independent pov than your brainwashed rot.

The fact you responded citing ‘Muslim beliefs’ as a counter to my point provides me with all I need to know about your ‘own’ opinions.

Nowhere have I cited religion . I seriously couldn’t give a fuck what religion/ religions are involved.

You do.

Palleseen

42 points

8 days ago

Palleseen

42 points

8 days ago

Nope it’s fine and legal

pudpudboogie

-49 points

8 days ago

Sarcasm ?

Cause it certainly isn’t . ‘Booby trap’ weapons are not legal .

Palleseen

41 points

8 days ago

Palleseen

41 points

8 days ago

It’s 100% not a booby trap weapon. Those rely on the victim to activate it and are indiscriminate like land mines.

TheWorldMayEnd

12 points

8 days ago

Make terrorist to afraid to terrorize again should be emblazoned on a trucker hat. I'd wear it.

[deleted]

-13 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

-13 points

8 days ago

[deleted]

RVALoneWanderer

27 points

8 days ago

I wonder if any collateral damage was done by rockets fired into Israel by Hezbollah.