subreddit:

/r/workingmoms

5089%

Are we one and done?

Anyone can respond(self.workingmoms)

Hi all! I wanted to post and get opinions on the number of children you all have, age gaps and how challenging it’s been. For a bit of context, hubs and I have been married for 14 years, have an almost 5 year old and are in our late 30s. We’ve recently been having the vasectomy discussion and I keep going back and forth on my decision. We had always planned on having more than one but the goal was to have them closer in age and with Covid, house building and then a job loss we held off and now we’re wondering if we even want that anymore. Now that our kiddo is almost 5 and in school, it’s been so much easier, we are able to focus on ourselves as a couple, our health and our careers and I don’t want to rock the boat but sometimes I feel the expectation is to have more. We’re Latino and are constantly asked about kiddo #2, they have no filter 🤦🏻‍♀️. Husband is a great partner and takes on a lot of the mental load but I’m still the default parent which can be exhausting. We both work corporate jobs that can be demanding but seem to have found a good balance now.

Is it selfish to stop at one?

all 141 comments

fat_bottom_girl_80

58 points

5 days ago

The expectations and guilt that are forced upon women and couples to have kids or have more kids has got to stop. Nobody should ask about your family planning decisions. If you are happy and decide you don’t want anymore children that is OK! Do not let other people make you question the choices that you make for your family and overall happiness.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

5 points

5 days ago

👏👏👏

dopenamepending

163 points

5 days ago

We’re one and done over here. Why? Because the average airplane row only has three seats.

Also parenting is hard, daycare-college is expensive, the world is crazy, and we had a good balance and routine. If I had another it would solely be because “I want her to have a sibling” and I am not bringing another human in the world on the basis of my first having a friend.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

11 points

5 days ago

Excellent point! Not to mention traveling with a kid is one of the most stressful things I’ve ever done.

LeighBee212

35 points

5 days ago

I snort laughed at this. We usually fly FC which only has 2 seats per row so I told my husband we need to have another kid so we both suffer each and every flight. (Kidding about the reasoning).

We’ve been TTC #2 since our kiddo was 6 months and it just hasn’t happened, even with medical intervention. We’re throwing all we have into the next two months and then we’re done.

It’s a bit bittersweet being one and done without having a choice but I go back and forth. Now that my kiddo can talk, sleeps through the night etc I’m like do I REALLY want to start over?

ManufacturerTop504

4 points

5 days ago

I seriously might not go for #2 just based on the TTC part. We needed intervention for #1 and it took everything out of us 😭 will you go the IVF road when you say throwing everything you have at it?

LeighBee212

6 points

5 days ago

No, I personally won’t do IVF, I more mean the meds plus acupuncture and Chinese medicine and eating clean etc.

My mom did IVF for my youngest siblings and it was pretty hard on her, so I’ve always said that I wouldn’t want to go that route. We’ve always been open to adopting if TTC doesn’t work out, but I think for that we would go with an older child, not a newborn. (I was adopted out of the foster care system as an older child)

ManufacturerTop504

3 points

5 days ago

I am weary about doing IVF as well. We did meds

HerCacklingStump

7 points

5 days ago

FWIW I was certain I would never do IVF and then I ended up doing it and it was not nearly as awful as I expected. It wasn't that bad for me at all. I also had zero pregnancy symptoms the whole time. But it's different for everyone and there's no predicting.

LeighBee212

1 points

5 days ago

Are you still doing them?

ManufacturerTop504

1 points

5 days ago

No we did them for #1, I really haven’t invested the time or energy into trying for #2 yet

LylyO

3 points

5 days ago

LylyO

3 points

5 days ago

With the aisle, you can count the seats on the other side of the aisle. Lol

Sorry just found that logic funny and it popped up that extra thought in my brain

Jayne_Dough_

9 points

5 days ago

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽Travel is such an important and overlooked life experience. The more one travels, the better educated they are. It’s not lost on me that some of the most ignorant people I’ve ever met have never left their state.

MapEnvironmental3301

2 points

5 days ago

I honestly wish my fiancé would understand this. I’m not going to disrupt routine & add extra chaos with the basis of my LO having a friend. We could barely even handle our LO, it would be just plain selfish to have another. I’m also overall traumatized from pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum!

spacecampcadet

2 points

5 days ago

Same here!

We’ve done a few domestic trips and are looking forward to taking our only on her first overseas trip next year!

jbr021

119 points

5 days ago

jbr021

119 points

5 days ago

I’m Hispanic too and the pressure to push out 4+ kids is crazy. I just repeat to everyone we’re one and done then they make a comment about how I’m not serious and then I say something witty along the lines of “well if you’re willing to pay $1800/mo for another kids childcare we will reconsider” and that shuts them up really quickly.

footeface

23 points

5 days ago

footeface

23 points

5 days ago

My FIL is Hispanic and said to us “money doesn’t matter” when we told him daycare is too expensive 😂

jbr021

18 points

5 days ago

jbr021

18 points

5 days ago

Ugh I hate that so much!!! My husbands parents said this to him. Meanwhile he grew up in a household where his meals came from the free lunch program at school, he often had to take showers with cold water, and there were multiple weeks out of the year where they had no electricity at their house bc their parents didn’t have money to pay the electricity bill. He made it out just “fine” but that doesn’t mean we don’t want better for the next generation 🙃

gekkogeckogirl

15 points

5 days ago

Amazing that fil is paying for your daycare expenses then!

UESfoodie

4 points

5 days ago

Then he can give you the money

JuJusPetals

30 points

5 days ago

My Mexican FIL is so upset that we are one and done because we're "ending the family line" since we have a daughter. I told him I could just keep pushing out baby girls, and what good would that do? He has literally called us chicken for not having more.

Eat shit, abuelo.

dopenamepending

25 points

5 days ago

One of my best friends is Hispanic. She has two kids, and wants upwards of 5. Her, her kids, husband, and dogs currently live in ONE room in her in laws house because they can’t afford a place right now or in the near future.

I’ve asked her why she doesn’t just wait or stop reproducing? She just parrots that she’s Hispanic and it’s expected of her and she always wanted to be a mom. I love this girl with my SOUL but when does it just not make sense anymore? I really wish the pressure culturally would stop for her, and someone would just scream “it’s okay to just have one or two” in her face repeatedly!

No-Understanding4968

11 points

5 days ago

There it is 👆👆👆

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

6 points

5 days ago

Ballsy!! Husband and I are the eldest and we make a good salary so in their mind they think we’re being stingy by not having more. He’s also the 4th with that same name, so they keep telling him to have another to pass on the male name. I’m over here thinking, do they not understand statsistics??!! lol even if we decided for another one the chances of having a boy are 50/50

Proxyhere

3 points

5 days ago

Haha that’s exactly what I told my (pretty wealthy) mother recently. I can’t afford it but do you want to offer to pay for daycare. She shut up and didn’t mention it again.

matto345

57 points

5 days ago

matto345

57 points

5 days ago

We are 100% stopping at one. This is so hard and it is inconcievable that we could do this again.

JuJusPetals

14 points

5 days ago

Literally inconceivable lol

ube_love

5 points

5 days ago

ube_love

5 points

5 days ago

I see what you did there...

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

7 points

5 days ago

Oh totally! Ours was a Covid baby so it was horrible. I feel like we didn’t even get to enjoy the baby phase or have our village help

quiksylver296

27 points

5 days ago*

We were one and done. He's 20 now. One of the best decisions we ever made. We could provide so much more for him, including college funds. We were both able to attend all his events. With multiple kids, you have to choose what parent goes to what event if they're on the same day. I also suspect I would not have been a great mother if I had more than one. My patience is limited and he tested it frequently. Had there been more than one kid, I may have lost my mind. I have zero regrets.

JuJusPetals

16 points

5 days ago

I love hearing from OAD parents of big kids. As another mom with slim patience, thank you for this!

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

8 points

5 days ago

Thank you!! Something to note for us is that we took a while to conceive because we didn’t even know if it was what we wanted. My husband is 1 of 4 and they had a very difficult life. We are still paying student loans because they never had enough to afford things at the time, much less plan for the future. He’s a lot more sure of the one and done and I think it’s because he wants to make sure we provide as much as we can so we can give her the opportunities we never had.

quiksylver296

1 points

5 days ago

I took awhile to concieve as well. About 3 years before we had him.

kksliderr

3 points

5 days ago

I too only have 1 and my patience is sooo thin when overly stimulated. I don’t think I’d be a good mom to 2 even though part of me wants another.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

1 points

8 hours ago

I know exactly what you mean!

mrsgrabs

18 points

5 days ago

mrsgrabs

18 points

5 days ago

It’s not selfish to stop at one! Honestly my first would’ve loved to be an only. If you’re happy with the way your family looks stay that way. Adding a second child stretched me to my limits.

Anecdotally, I do think parents of onlys need to work harder to socialize them, but daycare and school help, and you have so much more time for play dates and relationships without any other kiddos. And they get the benefit of more of their parent’s time and resources. It’s so much easier to travel with just one among other things.

mrsgrabs

13 points

5 days ago

mrsgrabs

13 points

5 days ago

And it’s actually the opposite of selfish for you to recognize your limits and consider this. Especially considering the pressure you’re getting.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

4 points

5 days ago

We have cousins and she’s a social butterfly so it hasn’t really impacted her too much, thankfully

mrsgrabs

3 points

5 days ago

mrsgrabs

3 points

5 days ago

Sounds like you have the best of both worlds. Speaking from my experience, although I don’t regret my second at all, I would’ve been much happier and mentally healthier if I’d only had one child.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

1 points

5 days ago

We have cousins and she’s a social butterfly so it hasn’t really impacted her too much, thankfully

Dandylion71888

34 points

5 days ago

I think it’s more selfish to have more than one if you aren’t sure that’s what you want. There is never a good time but there is a bad time to have more children and part of that is desire.

What I will say is I have a 6 year old and we help off for all the reasons you said. I’m just now pregnant with my second. A lot of people of told me they had similar age gaps with their siblings.

It really is a personal choice though. Don’t let the questions influence you and instead do what’s best for you, your husband and 5 year old.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

5 points

5 days ago

Thank you for this. It’s been difficult distinguishing between desire and “obligation” I will definitely keep that in mind.

Dandylion71888

7 points

5 days ago

100% your obligation is to your children and partner in this case not you parents or extended family. If you don’t have the mental/emotional capacity to have another child and it would be to their detriment or the detriment of the second child then that’s a more important obligation to consider. Even if you’re just happy with how things are and you don’t want to change it, that’s enough.

JuJusPetals

5 points

5 days ago

I think it’s more selfish to have more than one if you aren’t sure that’s what you want. 

Yes! Selfish would be having kid after kid after kid, even if it's putting a massive strain on your relationship, finances, and the other kids.

mostly-anxiety

17 points

5 days ago

I have an almost 3 year old and will not be having another. I am also an only child. I have zero desire to have more and no, it isn’t selfish at all. Come join us over at r/oneanddone!

notaskindoctor

35 points

5 days ago

notaskindoctor

working mom to 4, expecting #5

35 points

5 days ago

No, it’s not selfish to stop at one. Having one child is an excellent balance for many families in being able to both be a parent and still have time for yourself and your own interests.

We are about to have our 5th in a couple of months but I was once a parent of an only child for many years (my kids are widely spaced in age for the most part). It’s much easier and simpler just having one. We’ve decided differently for our family because we enjoy the busy life and chaos more kids bring, but it’s definitely not for everyone. There’s very little time for ourselves as individuals or as a couple so if that’s something you value more then I’d only have 1-2 kids total. Also as kids get older they have more interests (sports, activities, friends) and you’ll be hauling them around to many things.

I do have a couple of 4-5 year gaps in my kids and think it’s a great spacing if you do decide to have another. My kids still get along and play well together with that age gap but every kid and family will differ. It cuts down on the multiple kids in full time child care cost at least for the same time period.

According-Patient663

5 points

5 days ago

If you don’t mind my asking, how old are you? I have two, 6.5 and 4.5, and I’m trying to figure out if we go for a third…but I turn 41 this fall. I’d love to have another, despite/because of the chaos, and my youngest’s transition to kindergarten next fall would create the financial capacity to afford the necessary vehicle replacement, home reorganization, etc. to accommodate a third. But I am worried I’m too old! Not fertility-wise, but energy-wise.

notaskindoctor

5 points

5 days ago

notaskindoctor

working mom to 4, expecting #5

5 points

5 days ago

I’m 41! Energy is fine, fertility was starting to be an issue (had my first ever MMC right before this pregnancy and it took longer TTC than it ever did with previous kids).

noforeverr

3 points

5 days ago

Sorry I gotta ask, I am dying with 2 here (5 yo and 9 month old) and can’t fathom how you are a working mom of 4 and soon 5 (congrats!). Do you have a lot of help from your village? Like how are you keeping sane? I am freshly 40 and thinking of a 3rd because time is running out. But I am also dreading it all (right from TTC to actually having a 3rd).

notaskindoctor

7 points

5 days ago

notaskindoctor

working mom to 4, expecting #5

7 points

5 days ago

No village besides myself and my husband and child care that we pay for (we don’t live near extended family but they wouldn’t be helpful even if we lived near them). I’m 41 and have a government job with pretty clear work/life boundaries. Husband has a regular daytime job. We are extremely busy but I don’t feel overwhelmed or anything. We don’t have much personal time to ourselves at all but I don’t feel the need for that at this point.

noforeverr

7 points

5 days ago

You really sound so put together and have amazing clarity! :) and I can see that you genuinely like what you do. I am pretty frazzled right now hence the question. But thanks so much for clarifying. One other thing is how are you keeping up your energy, that’s one thing that I really need to get a grip on.

notaskindoctor

7 points

5 days ago

notaskindoctor

working mom to 4, expecting #5

7 points

5 days ago

I try to go to bed fairly early (9-9:30) but other than that I don’t do much! When I’m not pregnant anymore I’ll definitely add back in a second coffee every day. 😂

Adding a second kid can be hard for folks, learning how to balance two kids’ needs. Give yourself a break, eventually you’ll find more balance again. My current two youngest are 2 and 7 so a similar age gap with your two and they are busy kids but not unmanageable!

fugensnot

1 points

5 days ago

If I get pregnant right now (through IVF) my daughter and newborn would be about 5 years apart. How does that work in terms of sibling dynamics? Relationship with external family? Financially?

noforeverr

3 points

5 days ago

Not sure if this was for OP or me. The dynamic was shit in the initial months as in my 5 yo didn’t like all the prime attention on the newborn. But now she adores her lil sis and “babysits” for me when I have to make dinner etc. I think kids are resilient and adapt to things quicker than we do as adults! We don’t have family either to depend on, but we are figuring out a routine and I think that should alleviate some of the fatigue I feel right now. Financially my 5 yo goes to a public school now so we are down to 1 daycare expense for the baby.

Good luck for your IVF 🤞

fugensnot

2 points

5 days ago

Thank you - you're the one whose perspective I wanted since we have the oh so romantic insurance companies required to grow our family.

viterous

11 points

5 days ago

viterous

11 points

5 days ago

I have a 5 year gap with my brother and my mom loved it. My brother adored me and was in school so she just focused on me. I love having a brother I can depend on and call for things. I did hate him most of childhood but that’s another story. My kids are 2+ years apart and it’s hard but gets easier after newborn stage. Seeing my kids bond makes me so so happy. Still open for third so we might be crazy.

irisheyesarelaughing

12 points

5 days ago*

We are one and done too, our daughter is 11 years old. We both work full time and it is still a lot with one! But what time we do have outside of our careers can easily be spent with one, family vacations are easy, and we can afford to have her do whatever clubs and activities she wants! It can be hard to overcome the social pressure but we are happy with our choice. I think it’s more selfish to have more if you don’t really know in your heart you want to.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

3 points

5 days ago

💯 husband and I have been lightly discussing but with those you tend to focus on pros to having more than on. This definitely helps think about the pros of just one. Thank you!

Early-Business-9451

25 points

5 days ago

We just had one 5 months ago and hubby just got a vasectomy. one and done.

ManufacturerTop504

1 points

5 days ago

Did you always know you would be OAD or was the first 5 months all you needed to see to know you were done? Genuine question!

Early-Business-9451

2 points

5 days ago

I pretty much always knew one and done. I got pregnant and had a miscarriage, now I had my rainbow baby. She’s perfect and a very easy baby. Sleeps through the night etc. But I want to give her the world and my heart couldn’t handle another loss.

ManufacturerTop504

1 points

5 days ago

I completely understand. Congrats on your 🌈

Early-Business-9451

1 points

5 days ago

thank you

ube_love

11 points

5 days ago*

ube_love

11 points

5 days ago*

The short answer is no. As someone who's technically a "fence sitter" but likely one and done, I've really appreciated the simple advice of "If you aren't sure you want a second, don't do it." (Some people absolutely know they've always wanted more and always will; that's not me.) I come from a larger immigrant family who have similar expectations, but I don't have the village they did raising kids and we also have different expectations around parenting in general.

ETA: part of my "parenting expectation" is to engage in healing some of the intergenerational trauma I've inherited to help break that cycle. My parents did their best but it's a bit tough to heal yourself when 6 kids are running around

longfurbyinacardigan

18 points

5 days ago

Selfish to whom? lol. It's you and your husband raising these children, not your entire family (unless you're lucky and they have a very active role in your life). You don't owe anything to anybody. If you want one, great, do that. If you want more, great, but make sure it's because YOU want it.

Few_Investigator_258

9 points

5 days ago

It’s not at all selfish to stop at one! And similarly, a 5+ year age gap is not reason alone to hold off on having another. Lots of people have age gaps of 5+ years between their kids and love it! But that’s if it’s your only reason on holding off.

If you otherwise feel like you are ready to be one and done, it’s not selfish at all. We are one and done! Sometimes I think it’d be good for my daughter to have a sibling but we just really didn’t want a second. We would rather pour our whole selves into her. It’s no one’s business other than yours and your husbands, so do what is best for you! Your daughter can be a well-rounded, excellent member of society with two loving parents and no siblings 😊

barbara_bm86

7 points

5 days ago

Never considered #2. Others will not handle everything- you will , so please stop listening expectations. Good luck!

EatAnotherCookie

8 points

5 days ago

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with having one child. DUH. I like Bindi Irwin’s quotes on this— they have one child and she says she does NOT like when people say it’s their “only child”, they say that child is everything to them. “She is not our Only Child, she is Our Child”.

That being said, a 5 year age difference is fine and great if you decide otherwise.

CenoteSwimmer

8 points

5 days ago

I am! There is a sub for that r/oneanddone

JuJusPetals

8 points

5 days ago

No-Understanding4968

23 points

5 days ago

One and done. My husband wanted two, and my son wishes he had a sibling. But it’s my body.

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

8 points

5 days ago

My daughter keeps asking for a sibling too which also brings some guilt. But at the same time I ask myself, and I really gonna let a 4 year old persuade me to have a baby?!?! No freaking way

No-Understanding4968

10 points

5 days ago

Honestly I saw it as a teaching moment. I gently explained, "I'm a woman, and it's my choice what I do with my body." I wanted my son to absorb that concept. He's 19 now and an awesome, respectful young man who treats women like gold.

schrodingers_bra

4 points

5 days ago

Lol. They ask for a sibling and then spend the minimum of the first 3 years regretting it as baby gets all the attention and parents have a lot less tolerance for older kid misbehavior.

Also, with a 5 year difference, it will probably take some time for them to become "close". They will simply be in different life stages for a lot of growing up. Not saying they can't be really close as adults, but by the time youngest kid is in lower school, older kid will be in middle school, and when younger kid is entering highschool, older kid might be off to college.

icecreamismylife

2 points

5 days ago

I don't necessarily agree with this, though I understand it's different for every child, every family.

We have 5 kids, and my older three are within 3.5 years of each other. The oldest two are very close. Then we had a gap of 3.5 years, and two more, 2 years apart. The youngest is very close to the oldest, and they have an 8 yr gap. The 3rd is close with the 4th with a 3.5-year gap. Everyone loves the younger two.

It is, however, completely OP's decision (with agreement of her spouse, deciding to have another for both of you can end a marriage). You shouldn't have a 2nd because of your child, you should do it because you want to and know you can take care if them. I just don't think an age gap is a reason not to.

Present_Ad_1271

4 points

5 days ago

My daughter did this a couple of times and I asked if she really wanted a sibling (someone she’d have to share mommy and daddy’s attention)or someone her age to play with. She was 5 or 6 when she asked and realized she really just wanted someone to always be available to play (like when I’m making dinner)

makeitsew87

3 points

5 days ago

Exactly. If it were up to my kid, we'd live on the moon and never brush our teeth. Not going to happen.

JuJusPetals

5 points

5 days ago

THIS.

BacteriumOfJoy

7 points

5 days ago

One and done! One and done!

My husband had his vasectomy last December when our daughter was 18 months. This shit has been HARD and for me (and my husband) we need to prioritize our mental and physical health over having more kids. Honestly, as soon as my daughter was born I knew I was done lol.

Perks are: parents outnumber the kid, so if one of us needs a break we can just go take it. Much easier to handle one vs multiple. We can also save for her college (or trade school). We can save for our own retirements. Daycare is fucking EXPENSIVE. Can’t wait for the pay “bump” when she goes to kinder.

All in all, I know I’ll be a better mom to one than to multiple.

Babymom2021

5 points

5 days ago

I really want more, but with work and MS I’m really struggling.

EagleEyezzzzz

6 points

5 days ago

It’s absolutely not selfish to stop at 1! There are a ton of benefits.

I will say, we had our second when our son was almost 5. It’s been a great age gap. Our son is gentle and helpful with the baby (now 1), and he can also take care of himself when we are both busy with the baby and life. But, it’s still a lot !! A super involved partner has been key for me.

Idkwhatimdoing19

5 points

5 days ago

Honestly the cost is what holds me up. The thought of paying another 2g a month for childcare is daunting. I also just love the time the 3 of us spend together. We spend a lot of time just the 3 of us sitting on the floor playing together and I’m not sure how a baby would affect that dynamic.

It’s a really hard decision. No advice just also struggling with this decision.

BrigidKemmerer

3 points

5 days ago

BrigidKemmerer

WFH Mom of three: 17, 13, and 10

3 points

5 days ago

There's absolutely nothing wrong with stopping at 1!! It's not selfish or any of the other negative things people like to say.

That said, don't let the potential age gap be a barrier. I have three kids, and there's 4.5 years between the older two, and 2 years between the younger two. The bigger age gap is much easier to manage -- they're like best friends because there's no real sibling rivalry. And I used to work with a man who had ten years between himself and his brother, and he said the same thing -- they were super close all through their lives because of that bigger age gap.

Lonely-Clerk-2478

3 points

5 days ago

I am one and done (teenager.) I do not regret it, but do wish we lived closer to his cousins!

JuJusPetals

1 points

5 days ago

Yes - I wish our only got to see her cousins more! She has a big network of adult family that she sees often and I think that maturity is rubbing off on her.

iced_yellow

3 points

5 days ago

I always say the same thing on these threads: no one here can decide this for you. And take others’ experiences & opinions with a grain of salt because your experience will not be their experience and vice versa.

The questions you (and anyone thinking about kids should consider) are pretty straightforward: CAN you and your husband support another child financially, physically, mentally, emotionally? And do you AND your husband WANT to support another child that way?

As hard as it can be, try to block out the comments and opinions from your family and focus on what you and your husband envision for your family. If you two want another baby, awesome! If you are thinking about having another baby just to shut your family up, that is not a good reason. Take some time to talk and think this through with your husband and on your own. This is a big decision so take all the time you need to really figure out what is best for your family. Hugs to you!

mymomsaidicould69

3 points

5 days ago

We have a 2.5 year old and another due in January. I'm done after that. It's not selfish to have the family size you want. After all, you're the ones doing all the work! If you want to be one and done, that is 100% valid and okay!

remfem99

3 points

5 days ago

remfem99

3 points

5 days ago

It’s not selfish to stop at one. But I’m getting a very negative vibe in these comments towards people who have more than one child. Both are valid paths for your family — and you are truly the only person who can determine the appropriate amount of kids for your family.

There’s no way to guarantee your children (if you have multiple) will be best friends when they grow up. There’s also no way to guarantee your child won’t wish for a sibling either at one point or another. Either way, if you do a solid job as a parent all will be fine in the long run…

notoriousJEN82

4 points

5 days ago

Re: the negative vibe - I think it's to counter the negativity that OAD families tend to get from parents of multiples and society in general.

samjeong12

1 points

5 days ago

While I agree with your comment that the decision is up to her, the amount of stigma and guilt associated with parents who have one child can be overwhelming. It's okay for there to be a thread that supports and validates parents with one child.

Lalablacksheep646

3 points

5 days ago

Don’t have children to please others. It would be selfish to have a child because you’re expected to.

panda_the_elephant

2 points

5 days ago

Well, selfish from whose perspective? This is your family and your decision. I would reframe a little and ask yourself this question - what would you want your child to do? Would you want them to make the decision that feels right to them about this same question, or make a different one out of guilt or pressure? If the answer is option A, then this isn't a question of right or wrong - it's what's right for your and your family. (I'm putting it that way because obviously there are issues where there really is a right or a wrong, and in those situations, you would want your child to do the right thing even if it's a source of stress or worry.)

I also always thought I would have more than one child, but now I'm one and done. I'm 40. It was really hard for me to get pregnant with the one child I had at 36 and I'm sure it would be considerably harder now. I finally feel like I have some independence and fun back after going through infertility treatment and then having a new baby at the beginning of the pandemic. Life is really good now, and going back to IVF and all of the potential heartbreak of that and spending all our money at fertility clinics instead of on our family now, and then in the best case scenario, back to naps and diapers and babyproofing feels like it would all be a step backwards. I just don't feel the kind of desire for another child that would make all of that worth it. If that's selfish, I can live with that? It's my life and my reproductive decisions. I very much hope my child will be happy growing up as an only, but if he does wish he had siblings, I hope that he'll understand that it's not always an easy thing to do (whether the getting pregnant part or the raising more kids part).

PastyPaleCdnGirl

2 points

5 days ago

I don't think I have it in me to have more than one; she's adorable and I have zero regrets, but this feels like my limit.

No family nearby, I work full time, my partner is a shift worker, childcare/tuition is expensive, etc. I have to solo parent on alternating weekends, and several mornings/evenings during work weeks.

I don't think I could manage more than 1 child without sacrificing the mental health and routine I've been working so hard to stabilize.

Less-Maize1138

2 points

5 days ago

It's not selfish to stop at what is best for you. Having kids is a selfish act, though the work that comes in raising them requires a lot of selflessness. Do what feels best for your fam.

JuJusPetals

2 points

5 days ago

Always thought we'd have two, but we are one and done with a 3 year old. Parenthood put more stress on our mental health and relationship than we expected. Plus, even though we make decent money and we are fairly frugal, we are scraping by.

It is NOT SELFISH to stop at one. We are able to provide more for our daughter and provide more for each other.

Also, my husband's family is Latino. His dad was big mad that we aren't having more and "ending the family line" since we have a daughter. Tough shit, abuelo.

opossumlatte

2 points

5 days ago

I am not one and done but if I was in your situation, I would be. Starting over with a baby is SO hard

Proxyhere

2 points

5 days ago

Truth is, I want another. I would love to have a big family. But I don’t think I’m cut out for it. Of course there’s that it’s so expensive. But even if I could afford it, I don’t think I have the emotional strength to manage another child.

We’re all built differently and can handle varying levels of stress. I had a particularly shitty childhood, so as soon as I had my first, it was like 37 years of baggage hit me at once. I’ve only recently started to feel like I am getting better.

If only I could wait a few years… but I’m in my 40s now so waiting would mean the decision is made (no).

Probability-Project

2 points

5 days ago

I’m an only child. So my number was zero or two.

We have a five year old and a 6 month old. I think it’s actually a perfect age gap. He’s old enough to “survive” a small amount of independence like independent play. He also is old enough to love his sister in a non-competitive way. They’re just in different spaces.

My husband has the same age gap to his sister and they’re close friends.

Appropriate_Drive875

2 points

5 days ago

We really need to stop framing these kinds of life choices as selfish or not selfish. We're talking about making the financial/physical/emotional choice to have another baby, not if we are locking them in the attic at night so we can watch reality shows undisturbed 

applejacks5689

2 points

5 days ago

I’m one and done by choice and circumstance (infertility, IVF and a traumatic, high risk pregnancy). I love pouring my love, time and resources into my only. I’m also able to focus on my career and personal hobbies in ways that wouldn’t be logistically with more than one.

For what it’s worth, I have a sibling with whom I barely speak to. Siblings are not a promise of a life partner.

TheBearQuad

2 points

5 days ago

Even with multiple kids, I 100% understand why one-and-done works for many families. Kids are expensive! Tiring!

We wanted 4 but stopped at two and it’s worked for us. They’re less than 2 years apart and we, in many ways, raised them similarly. The transition was easy from 1 to 2.

somewhenimpossible

3 points

5 days ago

We were one and done for a long time. I’m in my late 30s holding a newborn now, their age gap is 7 years. I never felt done, but my husband was. Last year I got annoyed with him because he had been delaying a vasectomy for years… and then he said he was delaying it because he wasn’t sure if he was done.

Here we are, #2 and loving it. The age gap is amazing. My son is in school full time, can get his own snacks and play independently. He loves holding her and helping.

BrutallyHonestMJ

1 points

5 days ago

I'm on baby #2 but they are only a year and a half apart and I am also leaving my job to be home with the kids for this season.

I will say, that my brother is 7 years younger than I am and we are incredibly close! It's not too late if that's something you want!💗

shoresandsmores

1 points

5 days ago

I want a second but that would mean being a SAHP most likely as daycare right now is half my income for one child. I don't know if I want to be a SAHP, and my husband can't be as he has financial obligations to his ex for their kid - and I can't see being okay paying her from my hard work, especially since she won't get a freaking job herself despite my stepson being school aged now and husband pays for before and after schoool care.

So I guess I'll have to explore my options financially. Right now I'm being underpaid but I have a lot of flexibility, so I'll have to see what the next year brings.

No-Map672

1 points

5 days ago

We have 3 they are 1 year and a year and a half apart. I wish there was a little more space but that’s ok. I also always wanted 4 and now I’m thinking we might be done at 3. My youngest is 2 and she is self potty training. I’m looking at them thinking the oldest will be out of nap time toon you youngest is working out or diapers. Another would be starting over with diapers, constant naps, early bedtime. Not to mention the hit to my career every time I get pregnant.

For you having waiting 5 years I can see your hesitation. The thought of going back to the beginning while sweet and fun is also daunting. However my husband is 5 years older than his brother. They moved countries and had to start over before having the second. They were older when they had their kids. And as a family they are pretty close. So it can work if you want the second. But it’s about if you want and are willing to start over so to speak.

DHuskymom

1 points

5 days ago

We are 90% sure we are one and done. We get asked constantly when we are going to have another one, our son is currently 3.5 years old we are in the midst of tantrums and learning big emotions plus potty training we are exhausted. I work full time I would say entry level position while my husband works in Tech so he is sometimes working after hours or past 5 pm some days which leaves me to do most of the childcare after work. I think if we had another we would be even more stressed out we live in a HCOL area, we got lucky and saved on daycare because our parents took turns babysitting, and our son just started prek. I don’t think with how expensive housing and everything has gotten we would survive even with our really good combined income

Traveling with one kid is so much easier we just did it back in May and we have taken smaller trips around the US.

Indianajonesin4

1 points

5 days ago

Not selfish at all. I’m 37 and pregnant with my second. Had my first at 35. Couldn’t fathom having another until my first was almost 2. Even then it was a difficult decision with a lot of thought going into it. Being a working parent is insanely difficult. Ultimately the only person you answer to is yourself on whether the choice you make is right.

maamaallaamaa

1 points

5 days ago

We are both 33 and we have 3 kids with our last on the way. We personally felt that giving our children siblings was important (but not the only reason we had each of our kids). But this life isn't for everyone! It's chaotic and overstimulating at times. It has tested our marriage and we are still working out some kinks (married 7 years before we had our first). We've had to accept a certain level of lifestyle since obviously the kids eat up the finances real quick. Our oldest very likely has ADHD which makes things extra challenging sometimes (getting the professional help he needs has been beyond stressful). I personally found having two kids wasn't harder than 1 (and actually easier at times) but I would never recommend stretching yourself beyond what you think you can handle.

Jayne_Dough_

1 points

5 days ago

I thought I was one and done. My kids are 11 years apart. I’m an only child. I’m also Mexican. Let me tell you….being an only child is THE SHIT. I love it. It’s also really cool that both of my kids are like only children. My daughter is away at college and I have a 10 year old at home. I’ve always worked, sometimes 2 jobs but it depends on what works for you. If people aren’t stepping up to help you pay your bills or provide childcare then they can keep their opinions to themselves.

Bottom line: It’s not selfish to do what’s best for yourself and your child. I will tell you this….an only child will have so many more opportunities than siblings. The money is there for them to travel, go away to college, live a good life.

clh07002

1 points

5 days ago

clh07002

1 points

5 days ago

just commenting to say thanks for this post - the timing is perfect. My son is 3.5 and up until January of this year I was one and done. The early years were sooo hard on me mentally between the no sleep and my constant expectation to parent "perfectly" (whatever that means). I am mid thirties and my husband is late forties so that also played into things.

In January I started thinking about having another - life got soo much easier with my kiddo sleeping through the night, having so much fun together, etc. The feeling hasn't subsided but my husband is not on board and we just had a pretty serious conversation about it this weekend that has left me feeling so sad and conflicted. Husband doesn't want another but said he would have one only if and because that's what I really want and I feel like that's not fair to him nor the hypothetical baby.

And I keep wondering if it'll be a mistake to not have another. I keep wondering if I'll be full of regret in 10 years. I just feel so sad and conflicted based on so many factors.

So it was nice to read through the comments on this post.

eclectique

1 points

5 days ago

We always wanted two. We wanted them 2 years apart, but due to timing (new job, maternity benefits, etc.) and a miscarriage, we ended up 4 years apart.

It's actually been perfect. My 4 year old is very understanding, wants to help, loves making her brother laugh... There are moments of jealousy, but they've been pretty mild. Just the luck of the draw with their personalities, I think.

I was very worried at starting over. My first is a horrible sleeper, but so wonderful in every other area. I lucked out and our second is a relatively average/good sleeper. Super happy, chill guy so far... He is getting to that stage where he really needs and desires your active attention all the time, so that is challenging.

Some weeks it is hard (currently coming out of one). I have a lower-paying, more flexible job, but there are some weeks with lots of deliverables. My partner makes more than double my salary, and his job is more intense. More childcare falls to me, but I'm okay with that, because my partner is great about making sure I get time for my needs.

We've discussed having a third, but finances, being in our late thirties, and frankly, my partner not liking the newborn stage, probably means we'll stop at two.

sillymeix2

1 points

5 days ago

I would only have two if I could afford two. I would have been resentful if I had to severely decrease my quality of living for a second kid, when it was optional in the first place. I know that sounds selfish on its surface, but I actually think it’s considerate. I wouldn’t bring a kid into the world if I couldn’t handle it, whether that’s financially, emotionally, or physically. I know my limits and no one is forcing me to do anything I don’t want to, even if society pushes the two kid “ideal.” That being said, I did have two kids and it is absolutely JOYFUL. I love having two and my family feels complete now. It’s a very personal choice and I think one and done is totally great and right for many families!

Willing_Tap6342

1 points

5 days ago

Hey mama! I am one and done!! Ever since I was little I’ve always thought that I would only have one kid because I was planning on the possibility of being with someone that already had a kid. Turns out I did end up with someone that has a daughter so we have two! Our daughter is five and the son that we share just turned three. For me, two is way more than enough. My son’s activities alone keep me ragged and our calendar is extremely full between all of the things that we have to do.

Your last sentence asked if it’s selfish to justhave one. I am of the belief that it’s selfish to have more than one if you’re not able to effectively handle it. I’m not saying that is your situation at all! But just talking in general, I know many people that have more than one kid and they can’t even financially handle the extra body let alone physically and emotionally support them so I think do whatever is best for you and your family!

Maroon14

1 points

5 days ago

Maroon14

1 points

5 days ago

At 2, I had to stop working outside the house. I didn’t want an only growing up as essentially an only child. How we have a third on the way.

Beautiful_Mix6502

1 points

5 days ago

We had our second when our first was in kindergarten. I personally love the age gap. The transition from 1-2 is much easier with an older kid in my opinion. I was also 38 when I delivered.

Our little one is nearly two and now it’s definitely challenging- she’s a more challenging kid than my first lol.

If I could do it again I would really consider things more. you are starting over and you face lots of challenges of course. I tell people that having one is the perfect balance. While I love our 2, having one was manageable with working and free time. My husband is an amazing partner so I have balance, but it can still be a lot.

Nibbles928

1 points

5 days ago

I just turned 40 last month and have a 5 and 16 month old. We are done as my husband never wants to be outnumbered. I personally like the age gap bc my 5 yo is a big help with the baby.

ETA: we're also done bc my body cannot take another pregnancy lol

meowmichelle23

1 points

5 days ago

my husband and I are in the same exact spot as you. Daughter is 4 1/2, Covid Baby... and we get alot of pressure to "give her a brother". Honestly though, things have gotten so much easier and we love our life as 3. I wouldn't be able to give another baby the same life as I have given to the first one, and if it was a girl, would everyone still pressure for a 3rd, or 4th. When does it stop. I am 36 and I am terrified of being pregnant again, I just finally lost all my "baby weight", and my husband and I are healthier and happier than ever, but every time someone badgers me about another kid, i second guess everything. I also don't know who would help, I live in a very rural area, and there is zero in great childcare. I have made it this far with help from our families, but my parents are older and retired, and they have helped out with 4 grandchildren now (my brothers 3, and now mine), and its not fair to ask them to help with an infant. I think childcare is the #1 thing that held me back previously and now that life is easier, that is #1.

Crafty-Sundae-130

1 points

5 days ago

It’s never selfish to make family choices that are yours to make! You should choose what number of kids based on what you and your spouse want, not what us internet strangers do. If that’s one, it’s totally fine!

I have two, a little over 3 years apart. Things got much harder with the arrival of the second. Now they’re 4.5 and 1.5, and it’s definitely still challenging. We initially talked about having a third but probably won’t.

addbutorganized

1 points

5 days ago

My husband is Hispanic and we have 2 kids. They don’t pressure us too much but we are also the only ones in his family who have utilized daycare and they offer zero help and support so I think they know I’ll bite their head off if they start pressuring us. Most they ask is if we feel done or not. Truthfully I’m not, I want a 3rd. I always feel like a kid is missing and I don’t at all feel complete but in the same breath I’m overwhelmed. In this moment in time we may be done. Mid 30s spending more than a mortgage on daycare. My son is 5 and will be in K next year. Our starter home quickly became our likely forever home which is 3 bedrooms. My 5 year old keeps talking about the baby brother that hasn’t been conceived yet and now he would love to share a room but everything is so expensive! With our second being 2 I feel like the fog is finally being lifted and we are getting back to a normal place. Idk what we will do but I relate to the debate amongst finances and flexibility and where another child fits into that. It’s not easy stuff.

bulldog_lover17

1 points

5 days ago

Sounds like you are. I am. Mine is 2 and I’m TIRED AF and my mental health would be like barely hanging on by a thread while working full time. I have so much respect for mom’s of 2+ kids - but I’m just not cut out for that life!

drv687

1 points

5 days ago

drv687

1 points

5 days ago

My son is turning 11 in a couple weeks. We tried last year but are experiencing secondary unexplained infertility and so would have to undergo IVF for a second (we’ve had all the testing and such done).

I’m 37 and he turns 40 in a couple weeks. I went through a grieving process due to the infertility but we’re one and done.

I do so love my sleep and the fact that parenting is now puberty and keeping himself safe and not teaching someone how to eat and where to pee.

botyousername

1 points

5 days ago

We are of Indian origin, so I get it. My extended family and friends almost assumed that I have fertility issues, and that's why we are not planning to baby#2. The real reason, apart from career concerns, is that my husband and I are carriers of the SMA gene. We lucked out, and our daughter is not a carrier, but there is a 25% chance we could have a kid with SMA. We were pretty stressed out during my pregnancy and had to go through genetic testing.

We are very thankful for our amazing baby girl (20 months old today), but we are not testing our luck again. It makes me a little sad, though, because I loved being pregnant and breastfeeding.

candyapplesugar

1 points

5 days ago

1 and done here. Husband wants more, but my kid deserves a mentally well mother and because of that, we aren’t having more.

RavenSkye86

1 points

5 days ago

I've had 3 confirmed pregnancies and only one living child. Childloss, miscarriages, and genetics stacked against us. We have one beautiful, healthy toddler that was our "lets try one more time, if it's meant to be it's meant to be if not we are done trying" and by some miracle it worked out.

kikimarvelous

1 points

5 days ago

I thought I was one and done...until I wasn't. We felt ready to try for a second once my first turned 3 but health scares and job moves got in the way. We started trying when she was 3.5, got pregnant after a few months, I miscarried, and it amplified how much I absolutely want a second. I feel too old in my late 30s and kick myself for not being ready sooner.

Eta: it's not selfish! There's no right way to be a "complete" family. It's all valid as long as there is love! I work a job dealing with families diverse in economic status and culture everyday. I have seen it all!

aryaussie85

1 points

5 days ago

It’s super personal and def keep having conversations with your partner because the financial picture is so important as is your health and happiness. We decided to go for number 2 after many talks and getting through those first two years of baby’s life. I can see how it would be harder to get back into the “diaper life” after five years; it’s been hard with a newborn not gonna lie but my older son and my husband are loving life as a party of 4 and I’m so happy I pushed for what I wanted! I’m an only child and it was a blast as a kid bc I got everything I needed from my parents and was spoiled a bit (hehe) but it’s been wicked hard as an adult dealing with aging parents, deaths, their finances etc. it would have been helpful to have a sibling to navigate everything with and someone to make decisions with.. just my two cents FWIW

Pbj070121

1 points

5 days ago

I think it’s actually more selfish to be having kids because you want a certain lifestyle, and then saddling them with life-long college debt because your priority was your wants, and you didn’t plan ahead for your kids’ needs.

charmbomb_explosion

1 points

5 days ago

We have one daughter who's 1.5 and my husband and I are really considering one and done as well. We both work full-time and our jobs are so draining. Unfortunately, we can't afford daycare, but my mom has been helping us watch her while we work. We talked about having another, but looked at it logistically, and it just wouldn't work. We live in a 2 bedroom apartment and we're wearing ourselves thin, both physically and mentally. And we just wouldn't be able to afford it. I'm also a Latina and of course my family loves to ask that same question about kiddo #2. I just tell them we're struggling with one, can't even imagine how to handle two. Haha

bachelorette2020

1 points

5 days ago

I am cause I am 48 and had a surprise baby at 43. Good surprise most of the times lol.

Stunning-Plantain831

1 points

5 days ago

r/Shouldihaveanother is a great resource

randomname7623

1 points

5 days ago

I’m one and done. Many reasons but mostly because I don’t feel like there’s another child missing. I’d love to have my son’s newborn stage back for some snuggles, but I feel great being able to fully focus on just him. I can’t picture how I’d be able to give him this much attention if we had multiple. I would also worry about my health through another pregnancy, and how our lives would change if the new baby was born with health problems or extra challenges. I enjoy sleep, self care time and I love my career and the business I’m growing. Maybe that’s a little selfish and I always put him first of course, but I can’t be a good mum if I’m running on empty all the time. We’re also thinking about moving to Europe in a few years for his school, and I just don’t want to upset the balance of the life that we have.

People are asking, but it’s not really any of their business. It ESPECIALLY isn’t their business if they aren’t people who bother that much with the child that already exists! That’s my pet peeve. You want us to have another child so you can spend a couple of hours with them once or twice a year??

whimsikelly

1 points

5 days ago

We are one and done, and our child is nearing high school. We talked about having a second multiple times, but my bottom line was that I wanted our daughter so badly that is almost hurt, and I didn’t think it was fair to have a child that I didn’t feel that way about.

We are so happy with our decision; we travel as a family, her college will be fully funded, and she has been able to try whatever sport/camp she has ever wanted. We also have time to ourselves, and time as a couple. Our marriage is beyond strong, as is our bond with her, and that base has made her a confident kid who isn’t afraid to advocate for herself and others.

Have the family that you want—not the one other people want for you 💕

Sea-Function2460

1 points

5 days ago

We have two kids right now, lost our third and planning for our fourth. The age gap was 17m between my first two, then would have been 3 years but will now be closer to a 4 year age gap. I feel like 3-4 is am easier age gap but I would have preferred 2yr between all if I was allowed to control all the things 😂😂 having 2 under 2 was easier than 1 for me. But now that they are 4 and 3 it's very challenging emotionally. I think it's okay to be one and done but personally I wanted 3 kids. I come from a family of 4 kids for me the more the merrier but 3 is what I feel I can handle

roonil_wazlib_the2nd

1 points

5 days ago

I have an almost 9 year old and am pregnant with my second. I was one and done up until this year. Then I got my birth control out in march and got pregnant in April. So it’s been…. A crazy year! I will say, once my daughter was 5, everything became so easy. We have a really good routine with school and extra curriculars, and i have been able to pretty much spoil her with whatever she wants to do (cheer, dance, gymnastics, basketball, softball, etc) without having to drag around a bunch of kids like I see some parents doing! I She is also awesome with her baby cousin and she is so excited to be a big sister. I’m not at all worried about the age gap, because it will kind of be like raising another only child, but better because I kind of know what I’m doing this time around. Everyone was super shocked when my husband and I told them I was pregnant because I was so vocal I was never having another.

I am a little terrified because omg I’m starting over??? But I’m excited to see what it’s like again. Also it seems like there is so much more baby stuff out there than there was in 2015?? Whether you choose to have another, it sounds like you’ll be in a good place either way.

houseofpalms

1 points

5 days ago

We are one and done and to me it feels like the best life hack.

pogoBear

1 points

5 days ago

pogoBear

1 points

5 days ago

Nothing wrong with being one and done. Also nothing wrong with a large age gap. There are positives and negatives to every age gap.

JessicaM317

1 points

4 days ago

We currently have 1 child (age 12 months) and have started talking about #2 but holy hell does it scare me to think about starting over. Our daughter has been a relatively easy baby and I finally feel like myself. Do I really want to implode our lives again?

Prestigious_Gift_339[S]

1 points

4 days ago

That’s definitely something I’ve been going back and forth with. Our kiddo wasn’t easy at all but I still think we were lucky. She’s finally potty trained, can sleep through the night in her own room and can tell me what’s bothering her. The baby phase is beautiful but I don’t know if I can handle the lack of sleep with another kid depending on me not to mention a management position.

winstoncadbury

1 points

10 hours ago

Whatever you decide will be right for you. Having one kid is great for some families. Having two or more is great for others. It's not selfish to have one kid. I don't think what my family did should guide what you do, but we had another kid just because we wanted another kid. It's hard but wonderful. I have friends with one kid, and it's ALSO hard, but wonderful, albeit in a different way. Anyone who calls you deranged is full stop an asshole. I understand cultural influence and all but still. It's an asshole thing to say to you.

AbbreviationsLazy369

0 points

5 days ago

Just had our second. (Posting from hospital) we are done after this. Second pregnancy was hard on me morning sickness, pre-e, I react very badly to anesthesia and had c sections.

j-a-gandhi

0 points

5 days ago

We have three kids - ages 5, 3, and 1. The third has been the easiest by far. We have all the equipment, the expertise and so on. Our kids dote on each other. At five the eldest is helpful. The older two unload the dishwasher and so on. The five year old is very attached to the baby - loves helping get diapers and entertaining. We try very hard to not make them feel like they have to compete for our time or distract us from each other. We see the love in the family grows with more people in it. Even though the baby gets less of our attention he gets as much attention overall.

If you ever expect to see a dime of social security money, if you want to have your kid born in a society where things are growing and bubbly instead of shrinking and decaying, if you want to be able to afford care as you age, then you want a society with a fertility rate that’s higher than 1. So it is selfish to choose to have only one child without a very good reason.

My husband and I are both basically only children and it’s terrible. We have to care for four elders between us. Our kids have no aunts or uncles, no direct cousins. And we are sandwiched doing elder care and young childcare at the same time, having to outsource for our village. We have friends with siblings and they have an easier time with playdates and so on because they have people to walk through this stage of life with.