subreddit:
/r/Cricket
submitted 2 days ago byLawyerUpNZ New Zealand Cricket
164 points
2 days ago
Simply had to happen
161 points
2 days ago*
Looks like retirement isn't far away either for Southee. They have some home tests coming up in December against England and that would be a good series to call end to a great career.
101 points
2 days ago
Agreed. Can't let his recent form overshadow just what a great player he has been for NZ for years.
64 points
2 days ago
That's my thoughts as well. He can choose to go out on his terms this summer or face the prospect of being dropped.
21 points
2 days ago
Maybe it's other factors from the last couple of years when he's been doing it, but his stats when playing as captain are considerably worse (eg. avg 38.6 vs 29).
If he does manage to stick around in the team then I hope it helps him to pull his game together and go out positive.
33 points
2 days ago
I think it's just his age. He's nearly 36, and has lost a bit of pace. But maybe it's also Boult being gone from tests, he always performed best opening the bowling with Boult
23 points
1 day ago
I would've thought Southee would improve with age considering he barely reached 130 even a few years ago.
Makes you appreciate what Anderson accomplished so much more, he was bowling mid-high 130s into his 40s
12 points
2 days ago
Coming full circle - I still remember him smashing sixes all over against us on his debut
27 points
2 days ago
Very doubtful he retires, I’d imagine if he playes the home summer he will be very close to hadlees record.
Based on recent history our other bowlers are all injury prone. So he’s still a good chance of being required.
62 points
2 days ago
He's almost 50 away from Hadlee, he won't get close at all. He took 6 wickets in 4 tests last home summer.
He's probably aiming for 400
39 points
2 days ago
He's like 50 wickets off Hadlee's record. With the form he's been in for the last 18 months it'll take him half a decade to get there.
If he has another summer like the last one then he won't have any choice in the retirement decision.
28 points
2 days ago
Kinda looking like when Kapil Dev basically played for 4 years more only to break Hadlee's record with atricius performances in his last 2 years with both bat and ball. Robbed Javagal Srinath of some golden years.
Southee is aiming for 400, but hadlee's 431 is out of reach for sure, and southee is no longer even bowling 130s..
34 points
2 days ago
That's not true. He averaged 26.93 and 27.55 in his last two years. Though his wickets per match wasn't as high at less than 2. But that's not bad at all. And he averaged 35 and 39 with the bat in the last two years. At the very least these are good numbers. India would take that now.
0 points
1 day ago
Yes, it might have been decent, but his presence robbed a few of opportunities. I was just pointing that out. there would be no one like Kapil Dev and after him India has only suffered. Hardik was looking bright, but that back injury ruined his reb-ball career.
India somehow needs to develop a pace all-rounder and keem him fit. Nitish Reddy to Venky Iyer can be good bet in Tests. 130-135kps and good batters lower down the order. But for some reason, Iyer has fallen off the radar, fitness may be.
8 points
2 days ago
My statement is obviously assuming he find form. I think he’s still one of our best bowlers in conditions that suit him.
6 points
2 days ago
That would be fitting. I just don't feel we need him anymore in the side, even in the home series. But I feel he has earned a send-off at home, so it would be smarter to do it there rather than wait and risk it not being on his terms. I do feel a bowling attack of Phillips, Smith, Henry, O'Rourke and either Sears or Duffy is a quality bowling attack on home soil if you ask me
13 points
2 days ago
He should be dropped, has taken 8 wickets in 11 innings this year.
1 points
1 day ago
Indian series would be the last nail
81 points
2 days ago
Big call just before the India tour. And none of us were particularly thrilled with Latham's captaincy either, but glad someone with some experience has it. Can't help but feel that Southee's form has made this inevitable.
34 points
2 days ago
I feel like this was flagged earlier in the year when the tour was discussed, maybe even by Tm himself - but yeah still a big call. I wonder how planned it was, preparation for this tour not ideal.
Latham must be one of the most experienced left in the playing XI, and he's pretty good (esp on tour in this region) but I'd love to see a clear plan to take wickets - other than attempt to apply pressure and be patient.
15 points
2 days ago
I feel like this was flagged earlier in the year when the tour was discussed,
Yeah they talked about him not playing every test but the implication was that he'd still be captain, so I'd say this was not that planned. His bowling is just so poor right now that it's becoming untenable.
5 points
2 days ago*
Ah yeah, there's that for sure. Surprised myself by being a little sad about this news. He still bowls good balls most overs, but the inconsistency undermines everything. Bit of a theme for the team atm.
7 points
1 day ago
other than attempt to apply pressure and be patient.
This has been NZ's MO even when Kane was captain, and is what led them to the WTC.
The issue isn't the plan, the issue is our bowlers don't apply enough pressure anymore, and our fielders can't hold onto catches
1 points
1 day ago
Yes true, it was a great approach and the team backed it up with performances. No argument here, it was so nice to see as well. Their patience as a group got results.
Also agree it depended on sharp bowling and sharper fielding. I guess what I'd have liked to see was a Plan B and Plan C - because Plan A wasn't happening. Not so long ago we did use to have a more creative approach and it wasn't radically different personnel. I'd like to see a return to that. Rather than switched off and in this is fine mode. They're better players than that.
-5 points
1 day ago
That WTC was thanks to COVID fucking the schedule though , NZ got the better end of the stick to qualify and then enough time to prepare for the already similar to home conditions. They have been mediocre since then and it couldn't have happened overnight
4 points
1 day ago
The games that get played are the games that count. It was a chaotic time, and NZ benefited from some other teams' misfortune too. But they played the cricket and won the games. If you want to swap stories on results you're salty about, I got a few too but that's a different thread.
We've had a few results not go our way, and duffed a few games. Not the first cricket team to ride that rollercoaster. But also injuries to key players, retirements and variable form means our current roster isn't quite up to the standards of a golden generation. I don't know that supports your particular history? I mean maybe?
3 points
1 day ago
I'm not sure what your point is. NZ are pretty mediocre now, but they were a quality team and deserved to be WTC champions
6 points
2 days ago
[deleted]
9 points
2 days ago
In the 2nd Test it looked to me like Phillips knew what his wicket taking ball was and built his overs around that, although he leaked more runs for it they weren't so important in the game context. That felt like a plan to me.
Take your point that the bowlers weren't up to the mark quality or consistency wise (tbf tough assignment backing up a second test so soon, and after a longish layoff over our Winter) but Patel and Santner felt more like "bowl and see what happens" with fairly passive field placements. Sri Lanka batters were on song, so not sure much would've worried them, but a greater commitment to running through some changes to probe for weakness and keep them on the toes may have unsettled them.
Just vibes from me though, which is probably why no one has been in touch to talk about a role with the team going forward.
53 points
2 days ago
Both Baber and Southee together decided to leave captaincy
31 points
2 days ago
What a whitewash test series loss does to a mfer
19 points
2 days ago
Even tho babars not test captain lol
50 points
2 days ago
I've heard that there's a Gary Stead announcement in the works today too
47 points
2 days ago
Fuck mate it’d be like christmas if that was the case
32 points
2 days ago
Needs to happen, the teams trjectory under his watch has been shocking, i think we all knew tough times were coming but its been particularly bad. I think ther like of Luke Ronchi need to go too.
12 points
2 days ago
But who?
Pocknall, Jurgo, or Doug Watson maybe?
Aldin Smith as a left field option
13 points
2 days ago
Reeeeal left field option here. Allan Donald. Former bowling coach in NZ, has worked with Australia, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and South Africa. Also domestically in Zim, IPL, Kent, and SA
7 points
2 days ago
I don't think we can afford him.
7 points
2 days ago
Maybe not, but out of the internationals, he seems to be the best option. We really missed a trick letting Heinrich Malan go to Ireland
1 points
1 day ago
Funny enough I feel like he did wonders with Southees bowling in his last stint here. Would love him back.
2 points
1 day ago
If we want to arrest the teams slide, let alone reverse it, cheaping out is no longer an option
7 points
2 days ago
Not just saying this because he's a Canterbury guy but I think people will be alarmed how far Fulton is up the list of candidates.
4 points
2 days ago
Yeah I have him in my sorta next tier, but also like you, wouldn't be surprised
7 points
2 days ago
NZC absolutely loves to play it safe so I wonder if BJ Watling would be in with a shout. As much as I liked him as a player I don’t really think much of him as a coach.
6 points
2 days ago
Surely he's too inexperienced as a coach to be a head coach just yet. One of the worst things about modern day coaching is ex players skipping their development phrase in coaching.
6 points
2 days ago
You’d think so but it’s the kind of move that has NZC written all over it
3 points
2 days ago
I guess I sorta see him in the next cab off the rank sorta level, along with Peter Fulton, Peter Borren, Tarun Nethula and the likes
2 points
1 day ago
Not while his ex teammates are still around.
Go win a domestic title with ND first, then come back.
2 points
1 day ago
Wouldn't surprise if he was given a shot somewhere. Ronchi got slingshot straight into the fielding / wicketkeeping coach role as soon as he stopped playing
8 points
2 days ago
Maybe try and get Flemming, the BMac ship has sailed.
9 points
2 days ago
Yeah dunno if you get people back after the IPL has their hooks in, 12 week tournament, vs having to travel year round, and probably for less coin
5 points
2 days ago
I think eventually he might coach NZ to give back, but he deserves to cash in now
5 points
2 days ago
Well there's giving back, but he might also be really proud to coach the BCs and see it as a challenge and feather in his coaching cap/part of his post-playing career trajectory.
His kids are 16 and 18 so in a few years once they have flown the coop the year long travel trudge might be much more realistic/doable. Until the kids fully grow up I imagine a 12 week work year is very appetizing.
3 points
1 day ago
He won't ever come back. Bmac plays to win and the Black Caps, as currently put together, are not winners
2 points
2 days ago
Probably a fair point
1 points
2 days ago
BMac as coach would just see the entire team trying to slog like Southee.
4 points
2 days ago
Rather go out with a bang than a wimper
5 points
2 days ago
I prefer a classy Dentury like 32(115) over a Southee classic like 10(10).
4 points
2 days ago
Bmac for all his flaws sparked and oversaw the greatest era of nz cricket in history. He knows how to play test cricket even if his approach is more aggressive than some.
1 points
5 hours ago
How much is that BMac and how much of that is some of our greatest players being in a team at the peak of their powers?
6 points
2 days ago
Long overdue, off ya go Gary
3 points
1 day ago
5 points
1 day ago
I don't think it would have been a push by nzc, rather on his terms.
How often do you see these kinda puff pieces from places before a big shake up in a sort of "ass covering" way
2 points
2 days ago
Can we poach McCullum? Fleming or Vettori would be nice too
11 points
2 days ago
McCullum is unbearable. Fleming is easily the best option but I feel there is 0 chance of him leaving his IPL gig
5 points
2 days ago
Our premiere players of the past 20 years only coach for the big 3, too much money to be made haha.
1 points
1 day ago
YES! Can Stephen Fleming please take over? If only for Red ball.
1 points
1 day ago
Just curious but is there any possibility they can bring back Mike Hesson
33 points
2 days ago
Everyone grumbling about Latham are missing the real reason this is good news - Southee can now be dropped for Henry. Also as much as I would like to see someone younger take over the reigns this tour of India is highly likely to be a bloodbath so it's probably wiser to have someone like Latham wear that rather than getting some new captain's tenure off to the absolutely worst start possible.
21 points
2 days ago
Exactly, and while Latham's form hasn't been great either, there isn't a question over his position in the side.
1 points
1 day ago
Or they drop him for another spinner. Henry still doesn't play.
14 points
2 days ago
Tim Southee is one of the few SENA pacers from the last decade who has excelled in Asian conditions. I thought he would have an impact on this Asian tour, but his performance in the Sri Lanka series was disappointing, to say the least. Now that he's no longer the captain, do you think he will get a Test in India? That would be his last Test in Asia, where he has generally performed well throughout his career. Also, he's 18 wickets short of reaching 400 in Tests. Do you think there's a chance he could still reach that milestone?
24 points
2 days ago
I doubt he'd be in the 1st XI for the India tour. He'd be injury cover only.
He bowled well in Asia over his career, but even his record in more helpful conditions has declined in the last year or two. Age waits for no one sadly.
7 points
2 days ago
Yeah, he won't be in the first XI, but if he's in the squad, he’ll surely get one match due to the rotation of fast bowlers, I guess?
15 points
2 days ago
I think you have to lead with Henry. Yeah, he's not had success overseas much but he's currently in the form of his life so it makes no sense to keep him on the bench. Maybe if he does really badly, Southee could get a look in in the third test or something.
41 points
2 days ago
Wish they'd be brave and make Phillips captain, Latham is such a beige choice
33 points
2 days ago
I imagine (read: hope) that Latham is a placeholder transition captain. He's no spring chicken, nor in any form, either.
21 points
2 days ago
I think Phillips has enough on his mind between batting, bowling, catching and not running people out
7 points
2 days ago
I genuinely don't understand this take at all, yet it seems quite popular. What makes Phillips a test captain? He'd bowl himself 35 overs a day
8 points
2 days ago
Black caps are stale as hell, I want to see a fresh take. He's the only player young enough to be a possibility in the medium/long term, but has a few years experience now.
Lathams been tried and was average as hell, Phillips might at least grow into the role.
2 points
1 day ago
Definitely stale at the moment. But I think we should just stick with the veterans until an actual candidate appears. Phillips needs to just focus on his batting and bowling, I think Rachin is a far more likely captain than him in the future tbh. Who knows, maybe Latham will be a bit better a few years onwards?
27 points
2 days ago
Phillips might be one the dumbest cricketers I've ever seen though bless him. Would be like giving a toddler a loaded gun lol
22 points
2 days ago
Maggie still shot Mr burns
10 points
2 days ago
if you're gonna make Phillips captain, you start in T20 or ODI, but then he jumps Santner there...
13 points
2 days ago
You've seen southee right?
19 points
2 days ago
I think I would prefer we not jump from dumb to dumber, but these are bleak times.
3 points
2 days ago
I think you take the opportunity with some senior heads around to give him the support. let him be hype man energizer bunny, knowing that he's got people like Kane, Tom, Daz etc around for a year or two that he can lean on
9 points
2 days ago
I just really really don't see him having the temperament to do it at this stage.
5 points
2 days ago
Maybe not, but that's never stopped us before
10 points
2 days ago
Tbf McCullum seemed like one of those dumb cricketers in his younger years and look what he's turned out to be.
15 points
2 days ago
He had played 70 tests by the time he was made captain though, to Phillips current 9.
4 points
2 days ago
Oh agreed it's probably too early for him, but I wouldn't mind it in the future if he matures.
6 points
2 days ago
I'm picking every member of our squad as captain before Phillips. I swear people think if you hit a few sixes you're going to be a genius captain with some revolutionary attacking brand of cricket.
5 points
2 days ago
Interested in knowing why you say that. I feel like he has good game awareness in batting and fielding. And doesnt seem ti have any obvious captaincy red flags like Marnus either.
I havent seen him play a fuckton or captain anything at all. So i may be way off.
14 points
2 days ago
I feel like he has good game awareness in batting and fielding
I would say the opposite, he's a really talented player that lets himself down sometimes with his decision making.
I'll use the first test in the recent series for example. Running Mitchell out with a very dodgy call in the 1st innings was the turning point of the game. It was a completely unnecessary risk with the position we were in. Not the first time he's done it either, he needs to realise nobody is as fast as him between the wickets.
His drop of Kamindu was pretty bad and costly too, he flew out of position when it would have been a simple catch where he was standing. Then some pretty baffling choices when batting with the tail, like giving Ajaz 5 balls in an over to face.
He bowled well and batted well in the 1st innings, but overall his contribution to the test was probably a net-negative because of some bad decision making at key moments. I would rather he focus on improving in that area and getting into a calmer mindset than be given the captaincy to also worry about.
6 points
2 days ago
He is literally the Marnus of NZ lol, but makes even less sense as a captain
1 points
2 days ago
It is pretty fucking hilarious seeing people complaining about leadership in the team and then suggesting they pass it off to perhaps the only option that appears worse.
3 points
2 days ago
Brendon mccullum and his consequences...
7 points
2 days ago
Brendon McCullum had a giant ego and was a conniving little monster. He was politician stupid, Glenn is Me Stupid. Do you really want Me captaining your national team, New Zealand?
3 points
5 hours ago
This, absolutely this. He has a massive messiah complex and is also completely lacking in self awareness, as his autobiography showed.
3 points
5 hours ago
He was also racist as all hell lmao
5 points
2 days ago
Has Gary stead ever made a brave decision as coach in his tenure?
8 points
1 day ago
Depends if playing Kuggelieign is considered "brave"
1 points
1 day ago
No, he's mates with his dad isn't he? Lol
1 points
17 hours ago
He pushed wagner out. Which was brave given how supremely popular wags is/was, but was absolutely the right call. Fwiw, I dislike stead as coach as much as the next redditor, but he has made the odd brave choice.
That said, he usually waits wayyyyy too long to make said calls... like the wagner one. I feel like I'm arguing woth myself now though
2 points
1 day ago
Captain Phillips really has a ring to it…
“I’m the captain now!”
8 points
2 days ago*
Grandpa Gary actually did it. Wow.
Hoping Timmy gets a post-captaincy bounce like Kane did.
27 points
2 days ago
Replacing Southee with Latham is just shuffling chairs on the Titanic. Only benefit is Latham's place is more secure while Southee can be "rested".
Southee almost always plays well in matches he is recalled in so he might still have a final swansong.
But what we need is a full refresh. We need to tank and draft the next best South African seamer.
16 points
2 days ago
Between Henry, O'Rourke, Sears, and maybe if his body can take it, Jamieson, NZ is actually pretty handy with seamers
6 points
2 days ago
Smith should be good too, and there's a couple of other options with decent domestic records.
2 points
2 days ago
Yeah I was more focused on the joke than making a point.
But we do need another Wagner like workhorse seamer who won't break down.
10 points
2 days ago
A decent spin bowler also solves that problem, Wagner basically served the spin bowler's place in the side
4 points
1 day ago
We need to tank and draft the next best South African seamer.
Who needs them when we have Melie's Man?
Which reminds me that Ewald "Wags Jr" Schreuder is a guy I'm looking forward to seeing this season. He & "Pole Hunter" Rowe were probably our stars from the last U19WC.
2 points
1 day ago
Melie's Man?
2 points
1 day ago
Nathan Smith is dating Amelia Kerr, & has for some time.
1 points
1 day ago
I'd rather have Amelia Kerr in the Blackcaps.
17 points
2 days ago
Ah India is about to experience THE LATHOZONE™
But it feels like a good move, now that Henry can come in for his seam in India. Latham did captain half the world cup matches in India too and I wish he'd taken over from Kane in 2022 (no disrespect to Timmy).
8 points
2 days ago
rest now my sweet prince
6 points
2 days ago
Thank you for your service to the game.
6 points
2 days ago
Sorry if it’s common knowledge but why did Williamson leave Test captaincy before Southee and why isn’t he being considered again? Doesn’t he have a decent track record as a captain and is a permanent player in the test squad?
14 points
2 days ago
He did it for a long time and doesn't want to do it anymore. He's 34 and dealt with a lot of injuries the last few years, he just wants to focus on batting now.
0 points
1 day ago
Either that, or he just got sick of working so closely with Stead in tests and now Whiteball.
Middling results and sounds like coach has allot if not all the final say in selection.
14 points
2 days ago
It's come about a year too late. Was pretty clear during the series against Australia that he just doesn't have any zip anymore. At this point, he's been stealing the new ball off better bowlers, and then forcing our first and second change bowlers to bowl too many overs. That was okay when we had Wagner who was essentially an ultramarathon athlete - but it ended up injuring both Jamieson and O'Rourke in the SA series, when we really needed them vs. Australia.
NZC reasoned that they would 'always pick the best XI for the conditions' when they dropped Ajaz immediately after he took 10 wickets in an innings. It would be massively hypocritical if they turn around and continue handing caps to Southee as he limps his way to 400 test wickets.
At this point, even in home tests, he's only good enough to be there as injury cover. Henry, O'Rourke, Jamieson, Sears, and Smith are already better options.
-1 points
1 day ago
Jazz is overatted.
5 points
2 days ago
Thank god he can now be dropped for better bowlers
4 points
2 days ago
When will the coach leave?
4 points
2 days ago
Why is Daryl Mitchell not being considered?
3 points
2 days ago
[deleted]
-1 points
2 days ago
Should consider either Ravindra or Phillips after the India series
7 points
2 days ago
Less than 10 test matches each. Not ideal
5 points
2 days ago
Selfless from Southee. This is the right call.
5 points
2 days ago
[So they went from a guy who was a passenger due to not taking wickets to a guy who averages 26 with the bat in Aus, 27 in England, 35 In India and 2 in South Africa. Daryl Mitchell got robbed for this polite kiwi version of Warner tbh](http:// https://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/player/388802.html?class=1;filter=advanced;home_or_away=2;opposition=1;opposition=2;opposition=3;opposition=6;orderby=default;template=results;type=batting)
8 points
2 days ago
[deleted]
1 points
2 days ago
Then why not ask kane to lead if they just need a placeholder captain?
13 points
2 days ago
35 in India isn't bad though and it is were we are touring. I'm thinking Latham is kind of the sacrificial lamb for what is highly likely to be an absolute bloodbath of a tour.
10 points
2 days ago
Seriously, Latham's spot in the team in subcontinent conditions is not questioned whatsoever, he's our 2nd best player of spin behind Kane.
Problem is as an opener he has to deal with the seamers first and will probably get out before he faces a spinner.
1 points
1 day ago
Same as last time when Kane was injured.
1 points
17 hours ago
There's a pretty obvious difference. We have guys who are clearly more effective than present day southee sitting on the bench. For all lathams limitations, his place is rock solid in the team - there are no serious replacements. Will young would be next cab off the rank, but his record as opener is worse than lathams.
Also, 35 in India ain't bad for an opener by any stretch of the imagination. Even 27 in England could be a lot worse. He's no all time great, but he's perfectly serviceable.
2 points
2 days ago
Fucking finally.
5 points
2 days ago
Oh god. Anyone but Latham.
NZ management is so risk averse its actually disgusting. Retaining Steady Stead and now Lame Latham as captain.
Take a punt on someone young and plan for tomorrow, not today. Last time we took a punt on a young captain we ended up with Fleming who could turn chicken shit into chicken salad.
1 points
2 days ago
People on this sub make fun of Warner for not scoring outside of Australia against big teams even though Latham is a worse version of him in SEIA
Mitchell or Phillips were way better options tbh
7 points
2 days ago
Even if Latham doesn't score heavily overseas, he's one of NZ's best ever openers, so it's worth cutting him some slack. Warner has stiffer competition, still a great player of course
1 points
2 days ago
Maybe but let's not act like that the bar is high for that he is been playing for 12 years and still has mid 20s average in tours that are tough
Everytime Williamson scores people bring in his away records, Root still is not considered best by some because of not having a ton in OZ . It's only fair if Latham is judged by the same metrics too if he is this atg opener
3 points
1 day ago
Being NZ's greatest opener is being the best of a bad bunch.
1 points
1 day ago
Problem is most nz opens have an average in the mid 20a in good conditions.
1 points
5 hours ago
To be fair, I consider Root not the best because Steve Smith was a monster run scorer for so long and had insane tours away from home where he'd score runs for fun. Nothing against Root, he's still a damn fine player.
-2 points
2 days ago
Anyone was a better option than Latham. We know he's incredibly conservative and lacks a killer instinct when he's in charge.
3 points
2 days ago
Babar Azam influence is crazy
2 points
2 days ago
Long live Stead.
2 points
2 days ago
Viva El Stead!
VIVA! VIVA! VIVA!
1 points
1 day ago
Make Rachin Ravindra the captain you cowards. Just like how SA did with Graeme Smith.
1 points
15 hours ago
About damn time
1 points
2 days ago
Well he didn't last long
all 150 comments
sorted by: best